It's the second-to-last day of November! Good luck to all of you who are sprinting towards the finish line, and a huge congratulations to everyone who's already won. Today's cover was created in 24 hours by the first-class Charlotte Strick:
Gayle Cord never thought that super powers were real-- until she survived an insane accident and found herself with powers that boggled her mind, among them (and her favorite) the ability to fly!
Fortunately, her father had been a big comic book fan (as well as a cop) before he died, and had passed that love on to her. They'd had long, rambling talks about the things in comics that would never work in the real world, so when Gayle decided to put on a costume and play superhero, she did things in a smart, thought-out fashion.
She hadn't realized, though, how her heroics would affect the world around her-- and how that would affect her. A secret identity turned out to be a pain in the neck-- but worse was her growing conviction that she couldn't possibly be the only person with super-powers for very long. Surely someone else would get powers-- and then things would be very different.
In fact, things were different already-- and as she struggled with how much of the truth to give the public that wanted to know as much as possible about the masked heroine Gayle Cord had become, she realized something very, very important:
When you are the first of anything, you have to lead...By Example.
Charlotte Strick is the Art Director of Faber & Faber, Inc. and the Trade Paperback division at Farrar, Straus and Giroux. She's the an award-winning designer known for creating the jackets for books by Roberto Bolaño, Lydia Davis, and Jonathan Franzen, among many others. She is also the Art Editor and designer of The Paris Review, and the mother to twin boys who turned one just yesterday. Until she finally gets around to designing her very own website, you can view some of her work here: http://designrelated.com/profile/pickupstrick
I'm not sure how I feel about the cover. On the one hand, the Moirre pattern dots (?) are the quickest way to signal 'comic book.' On the other hand... comic book art hasn't looked like that for at least 30 years. (Even the older style is off on this figure as she has no outilines!) I feel like if you want superheroes to be taken seriously, the design used to represent them needs to be updated to be closer to modern comic styles or a more professional-looking illustration style.
I guess I feel like the cover artist should have committed more to one style or the other. Either go all-out with the dark outlines and very illustrated style of the 50's comics to properly match the background, OR go with a sleeker, modern illustration; still stylized, but not so reliant on the dot pattern. You don't NEED that to let us know it's a superhero story. A girl in a cape will still get across the idea. (I could also see this cover being done with just a cape hanging on a wall or something less obvious.)
I admit, as an illustrator myself I would like to see some of the 30 Covers in future years feature actual *illustration* and not all this stock-photo design stuff. I think it would be nice to have the additional spectrum and a wider variety of art styles would show off people's novels to a better extent.
So are you saying that people who use stock photos and photo manipulation aren't *real* artist, because I can tell you it takes just as much work to find good photos and decide how they fit. You might want to check how you word things next time. :P
Well said! I have really no problem with stock photos--I hardly expect them to come up with entirely new illustrations, in addition to an eye-catching design.
No, what I was saying is that the 30 Covers 30 Days challenge is 100% graphic designers. I don't have a problem with graphic design-- it's an art all its own. I've done a little design work myself and creating a really eye-catching design is definitely difficult and takes a lot of skill. But they are very separate skills, most of the time-- most graphics people I know can't draw at all, and a lot of fine artists have no sense of design.
So I would like to see them pick a handful of illustrators to do covers as well as the graphic designers. I feel like it would give more variety to the challenge, especially since some genres are often better served by an illustration rather than photo-based design. Fantasy (including superheros) is one of these genres-- dressing someone up in a cape and snapping a photo of them just never seems to convey the same dynamic feel as a well-done painting or drawing.
Similarly, I think this particular cover design falls flat on its handling of the figure-- the background is fine, for a comic-book feel, but the figure lacks action. I think it would honestly be a lot more dramatic if there were some nice line-art to define the figure and make it look like an actual comic illustration.
FlameRaven wrote: So I would like to see them pick a handful of illustrators to do covers as well as the graphic designers. I feel like it would give more variety to the challenge, especially since some genres are often better served by an illustration rather than photo-based design. Fantasy (including superheros) is one of these genres-- dressing someone up in a cape and snapping a photo of them just never seems to convey the same dynamic feel as a well-done painting or drawing.
I disagree here. There's more to stock photography then people dressed up in ridiculous clothing. There are beautiful photos out there that I consider a million times better than paintings. Fantasy is really hard to convey in photography, but saying it can never match up is arrogant.
Also, don't forget that this is a 24 hour challenge. I would rather have good stock photos used, then a sloppy drawing.
FlameRaven wrote: I admit, as an illustrator myself I would like to see some of the 30 Covers in future years feature actual *illustration* and not all this stock-photo design stuff. I think it would be nice to have the additional spectrum and a wider variety of art styles would show off people's novels to a better extent.
Sure, I can see where you're coming from, BUT... I can also sympathise with what Anahlynn is saying.
Besides, these cover artists work so hard, and with very little time. If there was 'actual *illustration*', as you put it, and it was not completely refined, or not entirely to your tastes or in the style you expected it to be...
Hahaha, man -- I was sure no one would notice my incredible writing skills. I was verifying my word count infrequently for the most part, but then had to go in to a spate of testing things out for various people, which might explain the seesaw-ing a bit.
Congratulations on your wins/impending wins, and thanks for watching 30 Covers! Haha, I'm really, really glad to have had you three reading and commenting on these covers so wonderfully. (The Amy Farrah-Fowler icon always makes me grin.)
30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
It's the second-to-last day of November! Good luck to all of you who are sprinting towards the finish line, and a huge congratulations to everyone who's already won. Today's cover was created in 24 hours by the first-class Charlotte Strick:

By Example by Puella Hilare
Gayle Cord never thought that super powers were real-- until she survived an insane accident and found herself with powers that boggled her mind, among them (and her favorite) the ability to fly!
Fortunately, her father had been a big comic book fan (as well as a cop) before he died, and had passed that love on to her. They'd had long, rambling talks about the things in comics that would never work in the real world, so when Gayle decided to put on a costume and play superhero, she did things in a smart, thought-out fashion.
She hadn't realized, though, how her heroics would affect the world around her-- and how that would affect her. A secret identity turned out to be a pain in the neck-- but worse was her growing conviction that she couldn't possibly be the only person with super-powers for very long. Surely someone else would get powers-- and then things would be very different.
In fact, things were different already-- and as she struggled with how much of the truth to give the public that wanted to know as much as possible about the masked heroine Gayle Cord had become, she realized something very, very important:
When you are the first of anything, you have to lead...By Example.
Charlotte Strick is the Art Director of Faber & Faber, Inc. and the Trade Paperback division at Farrar, Straus and Giroux. She's the an award-winning designer known for creating the jackets for books by Roberto Bolaño, Lydia Davis, and Jonathan Franzen, among many others. She is also the Art Editor and designer of The Paris Review, and the mother to twin boys who turned one just yesterday. Until she finally gets around to designing her very own website, you can view some of her work here: http://designrelated.com/profile/pickupstrick
[Deleted]
Re: 30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
Fantastic synopsis and cover. I'd love to read this book!
Re: 30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
I like it.
Re: 30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
I like the synopsis.
I'm not sure how I feel about the cover. On the one hand, the Moirre pattern dots (?) are the quickest way to signal 'comic book.' On the other hand... comic book art hasn't looked like that for at least 30 years. (Even the older style is off on this figure as she has no outilines!) I feel like if you want superheroes to be taken seriously, the design used to represent them needs to be updated to be closer to modern comic styles or a more professional-looking illustration style.
I guess I feel like the cover artist should have committed more to one style or the other. Either go all-out with the dark outlines and very illustrated style of the 50's comics to properly match the background, OR go with a sleeker, modern illustration; still stylized, but not so reliant on the dot pattern. You don't NEED that to let us know it's a superhero story. A girl in a cape will still get across the idea. (I could also see this cover being done with just a cape hanging on a wall or something less obvious.)
I admit, as an illustrator myself I would like to see some of the 30 Covers in future years feature actual *illustration* and not all this stock-photo design stuff. I think it would be nice to have the additional spectrum and a wider variety of art styles would show off people's novels to a better extent.
Re: 30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
So are you saying that people who use stock photos and photo manipulation aren't *real* artist, because I can tell you it takes just as much work to find good photos and decide how they fit. You might want to check how you word things next time. :P
Re: 30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
Well said! I have really no problem with stock photos--I hardly expect them to come up with entirely new illustrations, in addition to an eye-catching design.
Re: 30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
No, what I was saying is that the 30 Covers 30 Days challenge is 100% graphic designers. I don't have a problem with graphic design-- it's an art all its own. I've done a little design work myself and creating a really eye-catching design is definitely difficult and takes a lot of skill. But they are very separate skills, most of the time-- most graphics people I know can't draw at all, and a lot of fine artists have no sense of design.
So I would like to see them pick a handful of illustrators to do covers as well as the graphic designers. I feel like it would give more variety to the challenge, especially since some genres are often better served by an illustration rather than photo-based design. Fantasy (including superheros) is one of these genres-- dressing someone up in a cape and snapping a photo of them just never seems to convey the same dynamic feel as a well-done painting or drawing.
Similarly, I think this particular cover design falls flat on its handling of the figure-- the background is fine, for a comic-book feel, but the figure lacks action. I think it would honestly be a lot more dramatic if there were some nice line-art to define the figure and make it look like an actual comic illustration.
Re: 30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
I disagree here. There's more to stock photography then people dressed up in ridiculous clothing. There are beautiful photos out there that I consider a million times better than paintings. Fantasy is really hard to convey in photography, but saying it can never match up is arrogant.
Also, don't forget that this is a 24 hour challenge. I would rather have good stock photos used, then a sloppy drawing.
Re: 30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
That is a good analysis, FlameRaven. I find myself agreeing with you totally.
Re: 30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
I was a graphic designer in a past life, and even I completely agree with what you're saying.
Re: 30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
Sure, I can see where you're coming from, BUT...
I can also sympathise with what Anahlynn is saying.
Besides, these cover artists work so hard, and with very little time. If there was 'actual *illustration*', as you put it, and it was not completely refined, or not entirely to your tastes or in the style you expected it to be...
Re: 30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
Cool cover. Anyone else notice that Tim Kim did like... 30k in ONE DAY?! Mistake?
Re: 30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
lol about Tim Kim's extraordinary writing prowess. Look, he's already won!
I think he wasn't bothering to validate. Maybe this was his sneaky way to psych out the rest of the nano admins ... ;-)
Re: 30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
Hahaha I even noticed he went from 7000 to 1 one day. It was weird.
Re: 30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
Hahaha, man -- I was sure no one would notice my incredible writing skills. I was verifying my word count infrequently for the most part, but then had to go in to a spate of testing things out for various people, which might explain the seesaw-ing a bit.
Congratulations on your wins/impending wins, and thanks for watching 30 Covers! Haha, I'm really, really glad to have had you three reading and commenting on these covers so wonderfully. (The Amy Farrah-Fowler icon always makes me grin.)
Re: 30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
I would totally pick this up and read it.
Re: 30 Covers, 30 Days 2011: Day 29
LOVE it-- both the cover and the synopsis! I wish it was already published-- I SO want to read this one!! :)
[Deleted]