RSS

Prologue/First Chapter Critique

Display mode:
KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

I know there are a few other threads going for critiques at the moment so I hope I’m not doing the wrong thing, but I found I wanted something a bit more than 200 words or three paragraphs. So… I thought I’d start a Prologue/first chapter critique (capped at 1000 words).

Moderators: Please feel free to lock or delete this if you see fit.



RULES for posting your excerpt (based on what I’ve seen in other threads):

No details to be given.

Post the prologue or first chapter of your novel up to 1000 words maximum.

Please do not post unless the person above you has received a critique, that way everyone can get some feedback.

Please don’t post your excerpt in someone else’s thread line. Start a new one.



CRITIQUE guidelines:

1. Critique (try to be specific and as detailed as possible):

2. Genre and age group:

3. Shelve it or buy it:

4. Score (either letter A, B, C, D, or out of 100):



Please be respectful and honest.

LadyStarlea
50194 words so far Winner!

Actually there is another thread for this in a way. People Critique the except on your NaNo page most people I believe put their first chapters up there I know I did.

http://www.nanowrimo.org/en/forums/critiques-feedback-novel-swaps/threads/20941?page=1

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

Yes, I did see that, but it's for an excerpt anywhere in your novel. I wanted to specifically target beginnings :-)

She BElieVIEd
57633 words so far Winner!

*Note: This is not ALL of the first chapter*

Memory Number One

"Mommy!"
The screech sets my throat on fire, but I don't care. My mother. My own mother. She's all I have left. They can't take her. I won't let her do this. No. No.
"No." It's as if my mother is reading my thoughts. "We've talked about this, Evol." Her voice is perfectly calm, at ease, almost reassuring. "In fact, I think it's time. They'll be here any minute now."
"Mommy!" The sobs rack me, punish me for letting her do this, for allowing it to happen. "What if you're not useful?" I'm screaming through my tears now. I know how hard it is to screech and sob by this point. And I'd hate to lose my voice before our goodbyes. "What if they...they..." I can't finish the sentence. I can't think it. I can't say it. No matter how much I believe it's what will happen. The deepest, darkest imaginings in the pitts of my black life will be here, arriving at the doorstep in just minutes.
"Oh, don't worry. There'll be nothing to see. If they don't like my level of intelligence, they'll shun me away. They can't afford another death, Evol. The human race is perishing. There's not too many of us left. They need me." All meaningless sentences, which we force ourselves to believe.
"Then why can't I be out of hiding? Don't they want to know what I have to offer?"
"Not until you're eighteen. Right now you still have a chance of growing, learning, existing." My mother, with her young age, bright green eyes, and even her prematurely graying blonde hair, will be gone. Not here, there, anywhere on this earth. Not living.
Gone.
"No, Mommy! I won't let them take you! Please, please no! Hide with me! Don't risk it. Don't do it." But my pleading is in vain. If they come here, they come knowing the house is not abandoned. That's why we got the note. The note that changed everything. The note--like a warning of death. If you run, they'll make it worse. If you attempt to conceal yourself, they'll announce the amount of blood there was on you when you died to your family. But if...if you come willingly, they'll go easy on you. Make it quick. They'll keep it quiet. Your family can then pretend that you were smart enough, that they took you to go live another life a ways away. I shudder involuntarily, remembering when I was seven and my mother had explained this to me, with my father's face buried in his hands, as we huddled around the fireplace. How dead her expression got, how she started to cry, rocking me in her arms. I had been frozen with indeciscion. When your leaders did not know which way to turn, you didn't either.
So pretending is what we turn to. Let's just say they got away, believe it...
But we all know. And if you get in their way during their procedures, they'll kill you too. That's why I have to stay trapped. Hidden. Safe as it gets. But my mother?
No. They can't do this to her. We've been out here, living like animals in the woods for so long. And now they've found us. All vulnerable and open from every angle in our small clearing. And they discovered Mommy.
Old enough to take the test.

Rushshock
0 words so far

1. Critique (try to be specific and as detailed as possible): I enjoyed reading what you have so far. Honestly, I think this is great. Your style is a breath of fresh air. My style is more descriptive and comparing. So this is a really nice read. Having said that, this first chapter plays the guessing game, which is good. I hope you intend to explain it out more in the book (well of course!) I like your dialogue although, her name doesn't need to be said as much as it is. Also, it's not in format. Meaning, the each time someones speaks it should start a new line like:

"Billy! Hey billy!" Sam said
"YO SAM!" Billy said back.

That sorta thing. I can find a few small grammar mistakes, but I won't go into them because their not really noticeable and as far as editing grammar goes, your story looks good so far. Again, I really like your dialogue it's probably the most striking thing about the beginning.

2. Genre and age group: Young Readers...fiction? I think possibly.

3. Shelve it or buy it: Buy it! I'd be very interested in reading it, it has potential as long as you keep at it.

4. Score (either letter A, B, C, D, or out of 100): Some where between a c+ and a b-. You need to add more, this beginning feels a little rushed.

Norse man

Prologue

Southern Italy

Lazily rising dust clouds marked the column of men and animals, their dark silhouettes could be glimpsed beneath, moving in the arid and bleak hilly landscape. The sun loomed high, baking the landscape and the unfortunate left unprotected in peak summer heat. Brown grass clang desperately to life among scattered trees, seemingly losing the fight.

The rough clad man noticed the strangers approach warily. It was time to go. He had near completed the tedious task of refilling his water skins. His breath had caught from his hurried efforts of hauling a corroded bronze bucket up and down an old well fashioned from red brick. A good well like that had been a lucky find. The armed groups who fought each other in these lands took turns poisoning or burying wells with stones, and rivers or streams in this dry landscape were scarce. Securing the vital water would heighten his chance of survival in the days to come, but loitering around to see if the strangers were friendly would not.

Serving as a stark reminder of the chaotic and dangerous times were the ruins encircling the well. Sturdy walls of the same red brick that made up the well coupled with a few costly marble columns still showed off the size and grandeur of the abandoned estate, but the roofs were missing from the manor house and nearby stables. Blackened and melted stones and bricks revealed their fate. Only charred earth marked where timber buildings had once stood, likely the quarters of the estate’s slaves and servants. No human remains lay among the ruins though. Either no blood had been spilt here, or someone had laid the fallen to their eternal rest. A defensive brick wall had been put up around the compound. Its mortar had looked new to the man’s eye while passing the broken front gates. Although higher than a man, well bedecked in slit holes, and with reinforced guard towers thoughtfully placed along its perimeter it evidently had not been worth the effort for whoever had commissioned it. Maybe he should have spent the coin on more personal guards, or perhaps chosen his alliances more carefully, the man thought to himself. Not that he himself had fared any better, he darkly added. His own vast riches were gone, save for the relatively small portion he had been able to salvage. Yet, he was still alive, and that was more than enough.

Scrubby plants sprouted from the ground floor, a year or two at least must have come and gone since anyone had claimed the estate. Distant family members eager to either inherit or to avenge should have arrived to do so by now. He guessed it was a sign as good as any that the current upheaval was all the more serious, with seemingly rich pickings like this being left to rats and wild birds for so long.

The last water skin was tied onto his grey mule. Neither she nor her gelded brown companion showed any more interest in the clear water put before them. They were laden with supplies, and had to carry the man’s weight from time to time as well, but they endured it well. The animals were strong and young, and quite large for mules, almost the size of horses. He would have much prepared the latter however. Unfortunately, they had proved to be more worth than both gold and loyalty a few days ago. As he prepared to leave, he glanced away from the nearing dust cloud, and looked at his own reflection in the bronze container, a sign of vanity that he should have put to rest long since.

He had like his surroundings seen much better days. A scruffy beard the color of dried mud covered his dust covered face. His hair seemed the nest of a particularly disordered bird, and his greyish eyes seemed as tired as he felt. Still, he pocketed a narcissistic satisfaction from admiring his own jawline and finely chiseled features. His face somehow spoke both of age and youth. In fact, many a man or woman would be hard pressed to ascertain his age. Earlier attempts at estimates varied from as low as a score and four, or over three dozen. He prided himself in that too, yet he wondered about it more, had in fact sought answers for a very long time without finding any. He was different, somehow. The years did not touch him as they did other men.

Scattering the reflection as he scooped up water to clear away some of the grime of travel from his face, he led the mules towards the smaller back gate, the only other opening in the brick wall besides the one he had passed through earlier. The heavy wooden gates were intact and now opened wide. The raiders that had torched the buildings had evidently been courteous enough to come knocking at the front. He expected to be long gone before the column reached the estate, and from the looks of them they were unlikely to pursue him. If they did, he had the means to dissuade them from further attempts, unconsciously feeling the smooth yew bow slung across his back with his fingers.

Suddenly, when he was no more than twenty paces away from the breach, a man appeared to bar his way. Then another. More men continued to spill through the gate, forming a half circle around him. Their eyes held him, javelins at the ready, dissuading him from taking another step. Two of them moved quickly towards the ruined buildings, eyes darting here and there scanning the area for anything or anyone of interest. Trapped, he had little choice but to stand his ground and study them, trying to calm his limbs and his wits.

Norse man

Trying to get the thread right this time....sorry.
..........................................................................................................................................

Prologue

Southern Italy

Lazily rising dust clouds marked the column of men and animals, their dark silhouettes could be glimpsed beneath, moving in the arid and bleak hilly landscape. The sun loomed high, baking the landscape and the unfortunate left unprotected in peak summer heat. Brown grass clang desperately to life among scattered trees, seemingly losing the fight.

The rough clad man noticed the strangers approach warily. It was time to go. He had near completed the tedious task of refilling his water skins. His breath had caught from his hurried efforts of hauling a corroded bronze bucket up and down an old well fashioned from red brick. A good well like that had been a lucky find. The armed groups who fought each other in these lands took turns poisoning or burying wells with stones, and rivers or streams in this dry landscape were scarce. Securing the vital water would heighten his chance of survival in the days to come, but loitering around to see if the strangers were friendly would not.

Serving as a stark reminder of the chaotic and dangerous times were the ruins encircling the well. Sturdy walls of the same red brick that made up the well coupled with a few costly marble columns still showed off the size and grandeur of the abandoned estate, but the roofs were missing from the manor house and nearby stables. Blackened and melted stones and bricks revealed their fate. Only charred earth marked where timber buildings had once stood, likely the quarters of the estate’s slaves and servants. No human remains lay among the ruins though. Either no blood had been spilt here, or someone had laid the fallen to their eternal rest. A defensive brick wall had been put up around the compound. Its mortar had looked new to the man’s eye while passing the broken front gates. Although higher than a man, well bedecked in slit holes, and with reinforced guard towers thoughtfully placed along its perimeter it evidently had not been worth the effort for whoever had commissioned it. Maybe he should have spent the coin on more personal guards, or perhaps chosen his alliances more carefully, the man thought to himself. Not that he himself had fared any better, he darkly added. His own vast riches were gone, save for the relatively small portion he had been able to salvage. Yet, he was still alive, and that was more than enough.

Scrubby plants sprouted from the ground floor, a year or two at least must have come and gone since anyone had claimed the estate. Distant family members eager to either inherit or to avenge should have arrived to do so by now. He guessed it was a sign as good as any that the current upheaval was all the more serious, with seemingly rich pickings like this being left to rats and wild birds for so long.

The last water skin was tied onto his grey mule. Neither she nor her gelded brown companion showed any more interest in the clear water put before them. They were laden with supplies, and had to carry the man’s weight from time to time as well, but they endured it well. The animals were strong and young, and quite large for mules, almost the size of horses. He would have much prepared the latter however. Unfortunately, they had proved to be more worth than both gold and loyalty a few days ago. As he prepared to leave, he glanced away from the nearing dust cloud, and looked at his own reflection in the bronze container, a sign of vanity that he should have put to rest long since.

He had like his surroundings seen much better days. A scruffy beard the color of dried mud covered his dust covered face. His hair seemed the nest of a particularly disordered bird, and his greyish eyes seemed as tired as he felt. Still, he pocketed a narcissistic satisfaction from admiring his own jawline and finely chiseled features. His face somehow spoke both of age and youth. In fact, many a man or woman would be hard pressed to ascertain his age. Earlier attempts at estimates varied from as low as a score and four, or over three dozen. He prided himself in that too, yet he wondered about it more, had in fact sought answers for a very long time without finding any. He was different, somehow. The years did not touch him as they did other men.

Scattering the reflection as he scooped up water to clear away some of the grime of travel from his face, he led the mules towards the smaller back gate, the only other opening in the brick wall besides the one he had passed through earlier. The heavy wooden gates were intact and now opened wide. The raiders that had torched the buildings had evidently been courteous enough to come knocking at the front. He expected to be long gone before the column reached the estate, and from the looks of them they were unlikely to pursue him. If they did, he had the means to dissuade them from further attempts, unconsciously feeling the smooth yew bow slung across his back with his fingers.

Suddenly, when he was no more than twenty paces away from the breach, a man appeared to bar his way. Then another. More men continued to spill through the gate, forming a half circle around him. Their eyes held him, javelins at the ready, dissuading him from taking another step. Two of them moved quickly towards the ruined buildings, eyes darting here and there scanning the area for anything or anyone of interest. Trapped, he had little choice but to stand his ground and study them, trying to calm his limbs and his wits.

CupboardOfWonders
50888 words so far Winner!

As the fire began ripping through the wooden hull of the ship, only one thought ran through Kale’s mind.
God really isn’t my friend today.
He recalled the day’s events briefly in his mind; the abrupt awakening at an ungodly hour in the morning, the hole that had mysteriously appeared in his favourite dress shirt, and finally this entire fiasco.
“Don’t worry about it, Blondie,” were the first mate’s exact words as he personally shoved Kale’s arms into the navy sleeves of his enormous coat. “It’ll just be a quick job.”
Kale scoffed at that. This was anything but quick.
As his body was weighed down by the enormous amount of loot stuffed into his pockets and spread over his back, he took a sweeping glance about the deck.
The cowardly men who had set their own ship alight were flinging themselves over the edge, choosing that as a preferable option than staying and burning slowly. He couldn’t say he blamed them. Others, people he recognized, were trying to get as high as possible to avoid the flames, yet still desperately clinging to whatever they had stolen. He felt no pity for them as their grip slipped and they also plummeted to their deaths.
There was little that he could do to save himself up here, he concluded, and moved away from the carnage surrounding him. He headed towards the captain’s chambers, and was pleased when he noticed that this was one of the rooms that had not been torched in their futile attempts to bring down the thieves with the ship. He shoved open the door using little force, unsurprised that it was unlocked. Captains were not cowards; they would not hide behind a locked door while their men died.
As soon as his foot stepped over the threshold it became clear that he was not the only person who had thought of his plan. A grubby man that he instantly recognized had shoved the dead captain’s body out of his chair, and was desperately searching the drawers of his desk. His head snapped up when he noticed Kale in the doorway, and shot him a look of disdain before continuing. Kale ignored him completely.
He marched over to the bookcases that lined the walls, carelessly tossing the books to the floor in search. Every time a heavy book struck the wooden floor it emitted a loud bang, and every time the other man flinched.
“Find anything?” he asked gruffly, not even looking up.
“Not yet,” Kale replied, sweeping an entire shelf’s worth onto the floor. “Dammit, where the hell would he put the thing?”
“Beats me. Every captain puts it somewhere different.”
Kale hummed in agreement and moved away from the bookcase, deciding them to be not worth his time. He headed towards the captain’s bed, making sure to step over the bloody corpse as he did so (knife to the back, a terrible way to go) and began to strip the sheets. The other man recognized the sound and snorted.
“Why would he hide it there?”
“Why wouldn’t he?” he snapped back, and quickly lifted the mattress. He cursed when it wasn’t there.
“We don’t have the time for this…” he groaned, running a hand through his hair. “The fire’s spreading as we waste our time here. Soon it’ll spread too far…”
“Are you gonna state the obvious or help us get out alive?” the man hissed, and began tearing the drawers out of the desk in the hope that he’d hidden it behind.
“Found it!” he cried in relief, and his fingers closed around the small device.
“Give it to me,” Kale ordered, holding out his hand. “My voice is clearer than yours.”
“Just ‘coz you’re a little rich bastard,” he muttered bitterly, but relinquished his hold nevertheless.
Kale snatched it instantly and pressed a button, praying that it worked like the one he owned.
“Mayday! Ship going down off the coast of Locksford. Our co-ordinates are-”
He offered the device to the other man, who practically screamed them before Kale took it back.
“We need immediate assistance. The whole thing is ablaze. Is anyone out there?”
There was silence for a few seconds before a voice crackled back.
“Roger. I think we see you.”
Thank God.
“Thank you. We’ll head to the deck now.”
“Be careful.”
It fell silent again and Kale let it fall to the ground.
“Let’s go.”

***

It look less than a few seconds for them to make it onto the deck, but Kale was immediately hit by just how much their situation had deteriorated. The deck itself was now ablaze, and men were clinging to the rigging desperately in hope of survival. He knew by the way the fire was twisting and writhing, dancing teasingly as though it knew just how easily it could take their lives, that it would take mere minutes for it to ruin the cotton sails and send them reeling off course, and seconds after that to reach the helium balloon suspending them in the air.
When that occurred, there would be no chance for it to even fall. The entire thing would be consumed in an explosion of fire, burning them alive before sending them towards the ground, a charred, bloodied but still very much alive mess. Until they hit the ground, of course.
Kale shivered at the sight of it, able to respect such a powerful thing while still being utterly terrified of it. He reached for the item around his neck, wishing not for the first time that it was a cross. Perhaps if God saw him genuinely praying then He would consider saving his life.
Instead, his fingers clasped around a small, golden heart-shaped locket that only he could open.

*This is all I could get in that was less than 1000 words...

FlameRaven
51589 words so far Winner!

Critique?: I have two problems with this, believability and prose.

For the first, I have some massive suspension of disbelief issues happening with this. Your MC seems awfully calm for being 1) a thief in the middle of a heist 2) on a ship that's ON FIRE. I also can't understand your premise: why would a crew set their own ship on fire to try to dissuade the thieves? Wouldn't they just, you know, fight the thieves? It seems like that would be a much better idea than setting the ship on fire and killing themselves AND losing their cargo.

I think a lot of this stems from problem #2, which is prose. Or, basically, "show don't tell." I think this is meant to be a tense scene, but it feels very leisurely. No one seems particularly worried about the fire while they loot through the rooms. I mean, you tell us that Kale is terrified, but I don't see that. Show us that he's scared but determined. Don't just tell us.

You can do this by breaking up your sentences more and giving us more sensory information:

EX: "As his body was weighed down by the enormous amount of loot stuffed into his pockets and spread over his back, he took a sweeping glance about the deck. "

"He stumbled out the door, steps slowed by the loot stuffed into every pocket. His back hunched under the weight of still more treasure. Eyes tearing up from the thick smoke, he glanced about the deck, taking in the scene before him."

EX: "Kale hummed in agreement and moved away from the bookcase, deciding them to be not worth his time. "

"Kale gave a grunt of agreement and threw the books away. They weren't worth his time."

Little changes like that will give a lot more life to your story.


Genre/Age: I'm guessing adult, historical/adventure

Shelve or buy? Probably shelve as it is now. As I said, despite an exciting setpiece (ship on fire!) I'm not very engaged in any of it.

Score: C. I feel like this has potential, but if this is your opening scene you need to make it much more intense. Give me a reason to worry whether Kale makes it off the ship or finds what he's looking for. Think about just how scary and chaotic a ship on fire would be and put that into the scene. Don't just tell us what happens but convey it through all our senses. Are there people screaming in the background? Are there smells of smoke, burning pitch/tar, and scorched flesh? Are the decks slick with blood/excrement? (When people die, they don't just bleed.) Can he taste the smoke and ash in the air? Also, give us emotions. Kale says that this has been a terrible day, but the only problems mentioned are minor. A hole in a shirt? Really? Those kind of small annoyances are okay but only if they compound each other. Show us how frustrated and stressed Kale is. Give us a sense of the ticking clock.

Polish this up, and it could be very exciting and engaging. Right now it's just meh.

CupboardOfWonders
50888 words so far Winner!

Thank you for your critique!

Mallorca Writer
29940 words so far

Hi Cupboardfulofwonders,
Just wanted to say, I hope you do take FlameRaven's critique seriously. The problem I see with your piece, and with many other openings, is that new writers focus too much on the first sentence hook. They make the mistake of thinking that all you need to do is create a killer first sentence and that's it. Unfortunately, the first sentence hook has to be attached to the line of sentences behind it that will actually reel the reader in.

Your first sentence is a great hook, but it is not attached to anything. You then start talking about a hole in a shirt. Again, I say, take note of what FlameRaven complains of in your writing.

Continue on with the immediacy that the first sentence promises.

lizmonster
50098 words so far Winner!

Critique: While I agree with the critiques pointing out that the beginning is a bit disjointed, I will say that by the time Kale got to the captain's quarters I was interested. I thought it picked up nicely from there. You've done a good job providing some exposition without being too bland, and without drawing me out of the story. I took Kale's equanimity not as a sign that he was uninvolved, but as an indicator of his character: based on what you have written, he seems to be fairly hardened and cynical, and probably too old and jaded to have much tangible fear of death. It's not clear to me at this point if I am meant to like him or not - not necessarily a bad thing, but it depends on what you're going for.

Genre and age group: Science fiction, probably aimed at adults, but possibly YA.

Shelve it or buy it: Too soon to tell for me, but I am curious. I'd definitely flip through more pages at the bookstore.

Score: About 80, I'd say. I think there is a lot of good stuff here to work with, although it could use a little reorganization. It's a nice, visual piece.

Golightly
0 words so far

Actually, if you clean up your prose quite a bit, if you "show, don't tell," (as FlameRaven explained), and if this little scene has a much bigger, realistic premise behind it... I could see myself being very interested in it. But I also didn't understand why, exactly, the sailors set the ship on fire and were throwing themselves overboard.

FlameRaven
51589 words so far Winner!

Chapter One
Memories


postmaster@university.edu
To: All Students
Subject: Cancellation of Classes
Date: Friday, December 12, 6:55am
Message:

Early in the morning of Thursday, December 11, a fire broke out in the computer labs of the Information and Technology Building. The exact cause of this fire has yet to be determined. An investigation is ongoing.

Due to this unfortunate occurrence, all classes will be cancelled for the days of Friday, December 12, Monday, December 15, and Tuesday, December 16. Final exams taking place within the Information and Technology Building are temporarily suspended. A replacement exam location is being found. Your teachers will contact you with further details on where and when your final exams will take place.

We hope you will join us in supporting the injured students as we work together to rebuild our campus after this terrible accident.

Sincerely,
Patricia McMuellan
Dean of Students

----

The bed she woke up in was not hers.

Blinking, she levered herself into a sitting position, trying to get a better look of her surroundings. She was in a hospital, or a clinic; there were half a dozen other beds in the room, all filled with college-age students. A few of them she recognized-- classmates, though none of them were close friends. All were obviously injured; bandages covered arms, legs, even a head. At the foot of the beds hospital staff milled around, checking charts or monitors. She could hear a low buzz of talk and hurried footsteps in the hallway. If she had to guess, she thought that this might not be the only such room.

She looked down at herself, searching for similar bandages. There was nothing; her skin was clean and unbroken. She ran her fingers through her short hair and found nothing on her head either.

What the hell was going on?

One of the doctors had finally noticed she was awake, and hurried over. Reaching into his pocket he pulled out a tiny flashlight. Flicking it in her eyes, he watched as she blinked, and seemed satisfied. "How are you doing, Viridian?" he asked, consulting his clipboard. "I'm Doctor Park."

She frowned. "It's Veri. Not Viridian." Someday she was going to get her parents back for that name. "And I'm fine... I think. Would you mind telling me what's going on here? What happened? What is all this?" she waved to encompass the beds and injured patients.

"Well, we were rather hoping you could tell us," he said. "All we know so far is that there was some kind of fire--possibly an explosion-- at one of the labs last night. You were found unconscious inside the building. So were the others. You're the first to wake up."

"An explosion?" she asked. "That sounds... serious," she managed. So why do I seem to be okay? A thought occurred to her, and she tried to wiggle her toes. They wiggled. She sighed a little in relief. Not paralyzed, then. And seemingly not even scratched. But the other students were all obviously badly hurt. Just what was going on?

"Yes, well, I understand they're still trying to determine the exact cause. But if you don't mind, I want to go through some routine questions with you, and later on I believe the police would like you to give a statement."

"The police?" she said, suddenly anxious.

"It's nothing to be worried about,” he said soothingly. “As I said, they are investigating what happened. Since you're the first to wake up, they just want to hear your take on events."

"Oh. Okay," she said. "So, what are these questions?"

"Routine things. We want to make sure you don't have any head trauma or memory loss... I need you to confirm your name for me, please."

"Viridian Fields."

"Age?"

"Twenty-one."

"Profession?"

"Uh, I'm a student. Here. Junior."

"And your major?"

"Advanced robotics and AI theory."

His eyebrows raised. "Robots, huh? Sounds impressive."

She shrugged. "I guess. I've always been pretty good with electronics and things."

He nodded absently, writing down her answers on a notepad, checking things off. "And do you remember what you were doing last night?"

She nodded, started to answer...and then stopped, blinking. "Actually, no."

"No?” he asked. “What is the last thing you do remember?"

"I..." she frowned, thinking back. It was just before finals, and the last week or so had been kind of a blur of late-night caffeine-and-cookie-fueled studying. She'd gone to the library to check out a stack of books she needed to finish that one paper, and she'd definitely started on the paper, because she remembered talking to Kim about it and making plans to do a study session for the final test. And then she'd had the Law's class and talked to him about her experiment... and that was it. "I remember going to class Thursday, talking to my teacher. I wanted to ask him some questions about my experiment. That's it."

"Thursday. What time on Thursday?"

"Uh... that's the afternoon class. It ends at 1:15, but I had to wait to talk to him because he was giving back test scores that day and a bunch of people had questions. So, I dunno, 1:30? Two?"

"And you don't remember anything after that?"

She searched her memory, but came up blank. "No."

He frowned, writing something on his clipboard. "Any previous history of blackouts?"

She shook her head. "No."

He pulled out the little flashlight and checked her eyes again. “Hmm. Well, you don’t have any of the normal signs of a concussion, but we should probably do a few more tests just to make sure there isn’t something we’re missing. I’ll see when we can schedule you in, and we’ll keep you here today just for observation. In the meantime, I want to do a simple exercise and make sure the rest of your memory checks out. I’m going to give you three words, and ask you to remember them in a few minutes. Okay?”

“Okay.”

“The three words are: leopard, bottle, spoon.”

“Leopard, bottle, spoon. Got it.”

“Right. So, Viridian. That’s an unusual name. Is there a story there?”

She sighed and rolled her eyes. “Ugh. My parents thought it was ‘poetic.’” She raised her fingers in sarcastic quotes. “They’re both kinda hippies, honestly. They got all into this back-to-nature kind of stuff and moved out to the middle of nowhere with some friends before I was born. That’s where I grew up—the middle of nowhere, all farm animals and endless grass and nothing to do.”

“And you came here for college?”

She shook her head. “Nah. I guess I was born with city blood, because I got sick of it when I was nine or ten. Went to live with my uncle up near Chicago. He runs a shop there, fixing things up. He used to do electronics, but now that everyone just throws theirs out and buys new stuff, he started doing cars instead. He used to let me tinker around with all the old stuff. Like I said, I’ve always been pretty good with that kind of thing. Used to build toy robots out of junk metal. Eventually I thought it would be cool to start building them for real.”

He nodded. “I see. So, do you remember the three words I told you a few minutes ago?”

Princeshelby
50140 words so far Winner!

CRITIQUE guidelines:

1. Critique (try to be specific and as detailed as possible): I really liked it. You didn't try too hard to be edgy, which is what usually happens with stories involving a disaster of some sort. I loved your writing style, too, but I wasn't really "hooked". That's just personal taste though, looking back on it I think the plot just isn't the kind I'd typically read. I'd like to know a little more info about the plot, but the amount of mystery also makes me want to read more. I'm just not quite sure what it's about other than some sort of explosion, which seems to be a smaller part of something much bigger.

2. Genre and age group: I'd need to know the rest of the plot... So far it seems like the age group is from 13 up through around mid thirties? As for genre, definitely mystery.

3. Shelve it or buy it: I'd read the synopsis on the back and read about a paragraph or so from the middle before I decided to buy it, but based on the beginning it's very likely that I would.

4. Score (either letter A, B, C, D, or out of 100): A, around 94 or 95.

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

Critique (try to be specific and as detailed as possible):
Firstly, the opening email letter doesn’t work for me. I found it annoying to read and I didn’t immediately make a connection with the story. Your first line after that is good and I would suggest starting there instead, although, it could be re-worded for more impact. It was a bit awkward for me.

I am a bit annoyed that we don’t get much of a feeling for the setting. This is all about Veri and her conversation with the doctor. I want action, and detail, more about what she sees around her and what she is feeling. I didn’t sympathise with Veri at all, or particularly like her. Your POV is in 3rd person so you have room to show us more than just Veri and the doctor. I found I got bogged down in the conversation and lost interest. I think dialogue should support the story, not form the story.

You do a lot of telling as well. She looked down. She did this and that etc. I didn’t really get a sense for her feelings and emotions either. I know if I woke up in a strange bed I would be very confused, and in a hospital bed? I would be frightened, scared, worried etc. She seems to just coast through with not much emotion, considering she recognises her class mates and they are in bandages, I would think her reaction would be more intense. Even though they are not close friends, the possibility that some could be would scare me half to death.

There are a few sentences beginning with and, and but. This is ok in some instances but starting a sentence with a conjunction is a pet peeve of mine, and I think in most cases there is a better way. Also, using the word ‘that’ – read the sentence out loud and if it works without it don’t use it.

Have you thought maybe writing a prologue to go before this chapter to replace the email? Then you can describe the fire breaking out in more detail. Or just leave it out entirely. I almost always write my prologue (if I have one) last, as by then I know what has happened and where the story starts.

Give us more meat and more action and I think I ill like it better.


Genre and age group: YA science fiction


Shelve it or buy it:
I would probably shelve this based on not enough to interest me. I think if you get more emotion in there and pick up the pace I would then be at least reading to the next chapter.


4. Score (either letter A, B, C, D, or out of 100): C

FlameRaven
51589 words so far Winner!

The fire's not terribly important besides kicking off the plot, so I'll probably just drop the e-mail.

One of the things I'm wrestling with as far as rewrites go is that, as I worked on it for NaNo, the first half sets up Veri's superpowers (the reason she has no injuries) and the second half deals with conflict at the superpower academy she goes to. I'm really wondering if maybe I shouldn't just get rid of that first half and start her off at the school. :/ It would be annoying to do so, but I think the pacing would probably be better served.

The emotion thing is definitely one of the problem areas I have, although it's something I was planning to address more in a second draft. We'll see if this draft even gets finished or if I rewrite it altogether.

Thanks for the critique. :)

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

I quite often start a story in a certain place, then later on as things progress realise it was not the right point to start. If this is your first draft it is not terrible, and I would love to read your revised beginning when you're ready.

FlameRaven
51589 words so far Winner!

Yeah... this story already shifted on me a couple times during NaNo, so I suppose I shouldn't be surprised. Still catches me off-guard sometimes, though. More slippery than eels, stories.

Thanks for the kind words. If I ever wrestle this story into some kind of finished shape, I'll let you know.

LadyStarlea
50194 words so far Winner!

1. Critique (try to be specific and as detailed as possible):
Interesting way to start things with the letter. Thing is I feel it is more of a gimmick to tell the reader what happened instead of showing them. Be better if someone was reading and reacting to this letter. Also you didn't mention Saturday classes (most collages and universities have classes on Saturday too) and the letter can lead someone to think that the building will be fixed in time for classes Wednesday which I find hard to believe. If you keep the letter you need to correct that. Maybe just stating the Information and Technology Building is closed and teachers will be contacting them with rescheduled locations for classes and exams. Lastly on the letter if the fire happened early on Thursday then why did it take them a full day to send this letter? Also the letter says the fire happened early morning Thursday and in her memories she was in the building talking to the teacher in the afternoon. So you have a bit of an inconsistency there. I think you will be fine to ex the letter fully and start with the MC waking up. Let the reader discover about the fire as your MC does. I think it will be a stronger opening without the letter.

2. Genre and age group:
sci-fi/mystery as I find it strange MC has no injuries leads me to think sci-fi since it doesn't feel like a fantasy to me. Mystery as she doesn't remember and has to go finding the answers. Age: YA-adult

3. Shelve it or buy it:
go to library and borrow to read as no money to buy

4. Score (either letter A, B, C, D, or out of 100): middle A as other then the letter and the inconsistency between the letter and the rest it was well done

FlameRaven
51589 words so far Winner!

Hm, it seems no one likes the e-mail so I'll probably drop that. The fire was meant to break out around 1-2am Thursday night/Friday morning so that was just a mistake on my part, should have been 'Friday morning.' So the e-mail would have been sent about 5 hours later.

Thanks for the input!

ohthatmomagain
59193 words so far Winner!

1. Critique (try to be specific and as detailed as possible):
I really liked the idea of this story, and the opening (not the email, but after that). I'm very interested in the story and would love to read it sometime. There were a few sentences that I could have done without ("So why do I seem to be okay? A thought occurred to her, and she tried to wiggle her toes. They wiggled. She sighed a little in relief. Not paralyzed, then. And seemingly not even scratched. But the other students were all obviously badly hurt. Just what was going on?") Other than that, I found it very interesting.


2. Genre and age group: I'm thinking 'maybe' YA. Could be adult.

3. Shelve it or buy it: I'd definitely read more.

4. Score (either letter A, B, C, D, or out of 100):
I'm gonna say an A-

Princeshelby
50140 words so far Winner!

(Imagine this first paragraph-thing in italics, please, I don't know how to make it italicized on here...)

The man bent over his guitar
A shearsman of sorts. The day was green.
They said, “You play this blue guitar
You never play things as they are.”
The man said, “Things as they are
Are changed upon this blue guitar.”
And they said then, “But play, you must
A tune beyond us, yet ourselves
A tune upon the blue guitar
Of things exactly as they are.”

“I quit,” I spit out hurriedly. I just wanted out of this prison, but the power of my words hit me like a dozen jail bars afterward.
“Pardon?” my teacher asked. Her eyes burned into mine, and I was tempted to lower my eyes. I knew I needed to stand my ground, however, so I managed to muster the courage to glare back.
“I said, ‘I. Quit.’” Maybe it came out in a disrespectful tone, but the words were already hovering overhead. Miss Young, my definitely not young cello teacher, let her artificial smile falter for a quarter of a second, but it was quickly repaired.
“Don’t talk to me like that, young lady. Now sit down, and play that movement precisely as it’s WRITTEN. Now! No buts, no questions, just play it.”
Her eyes were pretty intimidating, but I was not about to back down to a little lady with what appeared to be a bouffant that was ran over by a tractor. You could tell the fifties must have gone pretty well for her, because she always dressed like it was ‘fifty-two. A whole decade off, but who knows if she ever realized it.
“I’m sorry ma’am, but considering that in all technicality I just fired you, you can’t be telling what I can and can’t do,” I said, already starting to pack my cello up. “I’ll have my parents call later about refunding the lessons they’ve paid for this coming year. Thanks for all these years, Ms. Young, but I need to move on. Bye!”
With that I grabbed the case and walked out of the lesson room, trying to keep enough confidence up to keep me from turning around and running back to her, telling her I was just joking.
Amazingly, I made it outside and onto the sidewalk. That was when it hit me. What had I done? My legs almost collapsed beneath me. Ten years of lessons, very possibly wasted. I could probably consider the scholarships Ms. Young had helped me get gone, too. Funny how two words, properly paired, could so easily abolish so much. My parents would undoubtedly be beside themselves. It’s not like I could just not tell them, either. And when I told them, they’d more than likely not understand what motivated me to up and quit so abruptly. They wouldn’t see all the thought I put into it, or how unkind and close-minded teacher could be. They definitely wouldn’t believe me when I told them I had simply forgotten to tell them my plans. That is truly what happened, but how believable a story is that? “Yeah, well, I just kind of forgot to tell you about this life-changing decision of mine and make sure you guys were okay with it. Sorry about that.”
Yep, I was good as dead.

Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

CRITIQUE guidelines:

1. Critique (try to be specific and as detailed as possible): For starters, the paragraph at the end about lost me. At most a paragraph should have eight sentences; only half of that if you have really long sentences. Next, I would like to know if the italicized bit is supposed to be a song or something else. When I got to the part where it mentioned her playing the cello, I found myself going back up to try and put music to the italics. Maybe I'm just weird. Something tells me that this protagonist is about 13 or 14, but I've never heard of someone taking cello lessons that early. Dance, yes; big instrument that requires focus and dedication? Nope. You might want to mention her age somewhere.

2. Genre and age group:
General fiction, YA
3. Shelve it or buy it:
I'd probably sit in Barnes and Nobel with a cup of cappuccino reading it to see if it was worth the money. There's nothing here that'd make me drop the book and run away screaming but also nothing that would make me desire to have said book in my possession immediately.
4. Score (either letter A, B, C, D, or out of 100): A- (90) It sounds like the makings of a very interesting book but the lack of definition and sensory details would lose me pretty quickly.

LadyStarlea
50194 words so far Winner!

@Chaos-Insanity
My daughter could have picked up cello last year when she was in fifth grade ten years old when she started orchestra in her school. She opted for violin though but there were two kids in her class who picked up the cello last year one boy and one girl.

Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

I'm sorry, that's a little confusing.

She mentions that the child had taken ten years of lessons for the cello; somehow I cannot see a child learning the cello at three or four years of age.

Anahlynn
56995 words so far Winner!

Uh, you do realize that string instruments come in different sizes, right? And people start learning strings at any age. My friend started learning violin when she was four. Most world-class musicians started on their instrument when they were young kids. I started viola when I was in fifth grade.

Sorry if this seems hostile. I just get peeved when people offer up their opinions as facts.

Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

They do? You learn something new everyday, I guess.

aaalllyyysssaaaaa
4326 words so far

Yeah, absolutely. I started violin when I was four, my cousin started cello when he was three. Basically all the musicians I know started when they were younger than five. You've never seen the youtube videos with the little five year old Paganinis?

LadyStarlea
50194 words so far Winner!

I was under the impression the MC was at a music collage hence the scholarships and the talk of playing for ten years. But might be nice to know what year of school the MC is in.

Princeshelby
50140 words so far Winner!

She's meant to be a junior in high school, but I couldn't figure a way to fit that in somewhere without disrupting the flow. I'm probably going to be rewriting a large portion of it, though, so I'll be sure to do that. I probably also need to make her sound older, anyway.

And thanks so much again for all the critiques, they're really helpful.

LadyStarlea
50194 words so far Winner!

1. Critique (try to be specific and as detailed as possible): < em > is italics < /em >
The first paragraph is confusing. Maybe it was how it was spaced that made it hard to read for me.

missing word " you can’t be telling what I can and" needs a "me" -> you can't be telling me what I can...

Okay this does nothing to entice me to read on. Where is the conflict? Not much of a story if this just about how he tells his parents what he did. Maybe just not my cup of tea. Not sure what this story is about at all. You need to add some emotions into this. Seems your MC is a bit on the emotionless side though all this. You need to show more instead of telling.


2. Genre and age group: I guess YA general fiction

3. Shelve it or buy it: Shelve it

4. Score (either letter A, B, C, D, or out of 100): C

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

1. Critique (try to be specific and as detailed as possible):
Overall I think this may have potential, but the verse at the beginning threw me. I found it hard to read and because of that I could lose interest very quickly. Is it supposed to be at the beginning of the chapter, or like a quote on a separate page first?

The first sentence starts out having good impact, but you lose me ending it in ‘afterwards’. Maybe the comparison is a bit awkward and I think it needs re-wording.

I also found reading this a little hard as you haven’t formatted it for web. There are some grammar mistakes and a few poor word combinations too.

For example: “Her eyes were pretty intimidating, but I was not about to back down to a little lady with what appeared to be a bouffant that was ran over by a tractor.”

Try: “Her eyes were quite intimidating, but I wasn’t about to back down from a little lady sporting a squashed bouffant.”

And this: “I could probably consider the scholarships Ms Young had helped me get gone, too.”

The words ‘get gone’ don’t work together.

Try: “I could probably kiss goodbye the scholarship Ms Young helped me get as well.” Or something to that effect.

Also, Ms doesn't need the period (Ms.)



2. Genre and age group: I think it’s set in the sixties from your reference but I’ll say general fiction or maybe historical fiction.

3. Shelve it or buy it: At this stage, shelve it. If you re-work your sentence structure and get rid of the unnecessary words it will be much better.

4. Score (either letter A, B, C, D, or out of 100): C+

Princeshelby
50140 words so far Winner!

Thanks, I'll work on all that... How do you format it for web?

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

I just meant putting a line break between the paragraphs so it's easier to read. They all seemed to mesh into each other :-)

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

I originally posted the first 200 words of this in the 200 word critique and have made some changes from the feedback I received. I would love to hear some thoughts about the whole prologue. Thanks :-)

_______________________________________________________

Prologue – Where the Trouble Began

The Dragon roared over the valley as the girl ran. She pumped her arms furiously and beads of sweat trickled down her back. Tufts of grass and dirt flicked up around her and stuck to the back of her legs. She could hear her best friend panting and smell his fear, and no doubt the Dragon could too. She’d already decided they were never coming back, this was the last time.

Glancing to her right their eyes met and she yelled, “Now!”

This was the part they’d planned in advance. It would be tricky to pull off while running so fast over uneven ground, but they had no other choice. It was either, take the risk and hope it landed in the right place, or stop running and face the beast behind them. Stopping was not an option.

She waited for him to throw the book out in front of them, praying it would land the right way up. To her horror it hit the ground with its spine, opening slightly, and the momentum forced in onwards. It rolled over a few times collecting bits of grass along the way. Time seemed to stop and the only thing she saw moving was the book. She held her breath and her stomach felt heavy with worry, like she’d swallowed a stone. Finally, the book came to rest a few metres away with its yellowed pages open to the sky. She grabbed the boy’s hand and they took two final steps before jumping into the book.

They landed heavily on top of one another on the back lawn of the estate. The girl scrambled to her feet, brushing the grass from her hair. Her grey eyes blazed with an intense anger and the boy shied away from her. He lay on the grass with the closed book beside him and sunlight gleamed off the emerald at its centre. She lunged over him and hastily picked it up, wedging her nails under the edge of the amulet and tearing it from the leather cover.

“This,” she said, shaking the book in the boy’s face, “get rid of it. I don’t care how, just…” and she threw it at him where he caught it at his chest. She clenched her fists, one closed around the amulet and its chain dangled between her fingers. She turned away from him until her anger subsided a little. “Never again do we go back there.”

“But we can’t just leave him,” the boy said, protesting strongly and getting to his feet.

The girl spun on her heels and her anger flared again. “Yes we can!” She pushed him in the chest and he stumbled back sitting down heavily on the grass. He brought the book up like a shield. “Lock it up and throw away the key. Swear to me you will never go back.” The silence between them was thick as they stared at one another. She towered over the boy, her steel glare boring into him. “Swear on your Mother’s life,” she said.

Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

CRITIQUE guidelines:

1. Critique (try to be specific and as detailed as possible): Is Dragon a title? If it is just a species, then that needs to be lowercased. I don't know if this is just the sentence registering funny in my head but did you mean to attach tufts to dirt as well? Because I read it as Tufts of grass and tufts of dirt, associating the word with both. This whole excerpt seems like something out of the middle of the book and really, that's where it should be. I don't get what they're talking about at all, and by the point where you (probably) explain, I would no longer be reading. What also confused me was the use of meters. I get the feeling that they are about ten or twelve. Jumping a few meters is a bit difficult unless you're rather athletic and/or you've been training for such a thing.

2. Genre and age group:

General fiction, perhaps fantasy. YA

3. Shelve it or buy it:

Shelve it.

4. Score (either letter A, B, C, D, or out of 100):
B- (82) It sounds promising but I would quickly lose interest if this was the way it was told throughout.

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

Hi Chaos-Insanity,
Yes, Dragon is a title hence the capitalisation.
I see what you mean with the grass thing, thanks.
In terms of the metres, it says they take two final steps before jumping into the book. By then the book would be right in front of them.
This event happens about thirty years before the story starts.
Thanks for your feedback.

Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

Meters: Ah okay, makes sense now. Thanks for clarifying that.
Dragon: Lol, now all I can think is that an angry Klansman is chasing them, which is obviously not the case.

I'd love to read this when you're done. It really does sound quite interesting.

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

Yes, I am Australian so we spell metre with an re, not er.
No, not an angry clansman, but that made me laugh.
I am about half way through the story so when I'm finished I plan to post in the fantasy critique thread.

Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

I'm American, so we spell it with an er. Funny how spellings change with location.

Twilight7fire
20000 words so far

Came here via the 200-words topic. :)

I like the changes you have made, although I still think the first sentence could be better. I'd put a semicolon at the end of the first paragraph, so "(...)back; this (...)", but that's a personal preference.

The first four paragraphs are the best, in my opinion. After that, the narration lapses a bit. Stylistically, I would prefer if you started a new paragraph for each new line of dialogue.

Again, I started off thinking this was a third person limited perspective, but in the 5th paragraph, you shift the focal point again to a sort of omniscient narrator. This happens again in the last paragraph.

The sixth paragraph doesn't flow so well, possibly because your sentence structuring there is very similar. Try to vary a bit more.

I was pleasantly surprised by the fact that they jump into the book - from the 200 words excerpt, I'd actually expected that they would somehow use the book to catch the dragon (a sort of reverse Inkheart, haha).

It's a very intriguing story. There are some obvious snarls in your writing, but you said before you haven't been writing for very long, so that's understandable. I think you could be very good if you keep this up and keep practicing.

If you need more of your text reviewed (and you can deal with my incredibly blunt comments), feel free to Nanomail me. I'm intrigued by your story.

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

Thank you! I have sent you a nanomail :-)

Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

The first thing you should know is this: we all die. There is no happy ending; there is no happily ever after. There is just this: we all die. When I refer to we, I mean those currently alive, carefully excluding Jailinus. My name is Daimeon Warnaout and I’ll be your narrator for the beginning of this story, only because the true protagonist has yet to be born.

Some may think it’s weird that I’m directly addressing the reader but even though you may not be able to see me, I certainly can see you. Now now, don’t panic. I’m not going to kill you, I’m not working with the government, and I most definitely am not going to sweep you off your feet into an unhealthy relationship. Unlike a certain person who shall remain nameless.

I really should start in the beginning, rather then the present, for only the past truly knows the path of time and in this, the path is very important.

When I looked out my second floor window that snowy December morning, I thought perhaps there’d be enough snow to have reason for not showing at work that day. Never would I have thought that day, of all days, would be the one that changed the world for the worst.

I turned and went to make a sandwich, contemplating the snow. There never was anything but a white Schneefrei since we gained the ability to alter the weather as we pleased. By we, I mean the human race. In those days, there was but we the humans living in Lon, a land discovered thanks to yet another of our scientific achievements.

Three hundred years prior, had you said there were multiple universes, you would have been laughed at. Not now, not after we scrubbed ourselves free of religions of all kinds. The revolution of the atheists against the theists came about 2050-60. No specific beginning point, just the majority making itself known.

That majority was largely correct in their assumption that there were no deities in any form living in their world. Imagine their surprise when they made it through the barrier and the first person they met was a god. The god was friendly enough, if a bit of a joker, and luckily for us, was amused by our progress.

Had he been of any temperament but friendly, we would have been dead there and then. Frankly, death is a rather depressing end to any scientific excursion, never mind one that plants you squarely where no man has ever gone before.

My door swung open behind me and in walked trouble on six-inch heels. Her grace and poise was disarming but deceptive; she was a coiled death adder waiting to strike. She also happened to be my fiancée.

She scowled at me and said, “Why are you still here? Don’t you have work? Get off your ass, you lazy bum.” I shrugged my shoulders helplessly at her and gestured to the snow. She rolled her eyes and said, “You know for a fact there won’t be enough snow to justify your laziness. Go to work.”

Something about her continued persistence in my going to work made me suspicious. I eyed her distrustfully as I walked over to the bedroom to grab my pants off of the door and yank them on.
“I guess I’m off then,” I said, moving her out of the way and walking out the door.

She closed it behind me and the moment the door was fully closed, I pulled out my enhet, a small device that had usurped the cellphone’s position as king of mobile communications. It was far more useful than a phone of any kind, having a variety of things it could do in addition to making calls, accepting texts, and playing games.

Tapping the screen with fury, I activated the bugs in the walls and watched her as she walked around the apartment.
“Yes, send over Meinhard Mout. He’ll do fine,” she said to the person on the other side of the enhet. Curious, I put the name into a search and found the first result to be a brothel on the other side of town, the side that we Sol were never supposed to go to but did so anyway.

It was simply the only way to get certain things; little luxuries like alcohol and medicine. Of course, there were always the unscrupulous criminals that insisted upon peddling drugs but the trade was highly regulated by an unlikely source.

One would think that since he got paid either way, Cat wouldn’t give half a fuck about what his drugs did to the users but he did. As he put it, “We can’t kill all the fools; there’d be a whole lot of product with no buyers.”

In the end it was money that he was concerned about, but it was the thought that counted. I ducked out of the way into a different corridor as voices approached my front door. Peering out into the hall, I saw a tall blond stride up and knock softly at the door. Rage blossomed in the pit of my stomach as I charged out of my hiding place and attacked him.

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

Critique (try to be specific and as detailed as possible):
I am not against 2nd POV narrative, but for some reason I think of Kiefer Sutherland and his husky voice.

I didn’t really find the reference to Twilight very amusing either and thought it didn’t fit with the rest of the story. Plus this would be lost on a lot of people; surprisingly not everyone has read Twilight. Also, the line about where no man has ever gone before just made me think of Star Trek.

You lost me at the use of the word Schneefrei. I am not German so had no idea what this meant and I had to look it up. It just seems very out of place to me and like you want to use ‘big words’. Also, the last thing I want to have to do when reading the first page is look up the meaning of a word, maybe half way through the book, but not so early on. It just made me want to put it down.

The fiancé, I just pictured a giant snake on high heels. Maybe you need to show us a bit more about her face or something to counterbalance that image.

You seem to be trying very hard to talk in a formal manner and this just annoyed me, I felt like I was being talked down to.

There are some basic grammatical errors. Using then instead of than. Cellphone’s is two words, not one.

This:
“I really should start in the beginning, rather then the present, for only the past truly knows the path of time and in this, the path is very important.”

I think should read:
“I really should start AT the beginning, rather THAN the present, for only the past truly knows the path of time and in this, the path is very important.

I also wanted to replace the last path with past. The past is very important?

Also, this sentence:
“In those days, there was but we the humans living in Lon, a land discovered thanks to yet another of our scientific achievements.”

“there was but we the humans”? Can you re-word that, it just sounds weird.

The first paragraph is good but I was disappointed I didn’t get to hear more about Jailinus. I know this probably comes later, but you mentioned a name and nothing else. Also, the name Warnaout, I wanted to read Warnout or Warnabout.


2. Genre and age group: Adult Sci-fi due to the swearing


3. Shelve it or buy it: shelve it.


4. Score (either letter A, B, C, D, or out of 100): B-. May have potential for me to read a bit more if the tone wasn’t so condescending.

Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

1. I apologize for the formal tone; it is just the way I speak (and thus, the way I write). By the time this is ready to get shipped out, it won't be that way if my editor has anything to say about it.
2. Schneefrei was my pitiful attempt at making a holiday. When I am at loss for a name for something, first instinct is to jack words from other languages (second being making up words, then finding out later that they are actual words)
3. I should probably edit this to mention that Jailinus was the god that was encountered. The reason why he is specifically excluded is because by the end of the book, he is still alive thanks to his invulnerability/immortality.
4. I was both trying and not trying to reference Twilight. I had typed that sentence as foreshadowing to the ill-fated relationship that the narrator has with his fiancée but it came out sounding like a reference to Twilight.

Thank you for your critique; I will work on making my writing sound more colloquial.

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

There is no need to apologise and that's great that you already have an editor :-)

J_S_C
100145 words so far Winner!

Unlike the other reviewer, I am not going to be as forgiving in the citique.

The first thing you should know is this: we all die. There is no happy ending; there is no happily ever after. There is just this: we all die. When I refer to we, I mean those currently alive, carefully excluding Jailinus. My name is Daimeon Warnaout and I’ll be your narrator for the beginning of this story, only because the true protagonist has yet to be born.

Some may think it’s weird that I’m directly addressing the reader but even though you may not be able to see me, I certainly can see you. Now now, don’t panic. I’m not going to kill you, I’m not working with the government, and I most definitely am not going to sweep you off your feet into an unhealthy relationship. Unlike a certain person who shall remain nameless.

I really should start in the beginning, rather then the present, for only the past truly knows the path of time and in this, the path is very important.


Cut it. Cut every word. Who cares. As soon as I read these paragraphs, I almost stopped reading. They are not important.

I do not think it weird that the narrator is addressing the reader, I think it is cheap and a gimmick. There are better ways for a character to be introduced other than having them tell you their name. That, too, is cheap and a gimmick.

When I looked out my second floor window that snowy December morning, I thought perhaps there’d be enough snow to have reason for not showing at work that day.

This is where the story begins. Not before, and if the true protagonist is not involved in your narrative until the time of his/her birth, then I could care less than about anything that happens before his involvement in the story.

By we, I mean the human race. Irrelevant. Unless your narrator is an alien, there is no explanation needed.

Three hundred years prior, had you said there were multiple universes, you would have been laughed at. Not now, not after we scrubbed ourselves free of religions of all kinds. The revolution of the atheists against the theists came about 2050-60. No specific beginning point, just the majority making itself known.

The send person narrative needs to be eliminated as well. It is not good. I think that the whole thing is unnecessary and would most likely cut it.

Had he been of any temperament but friendly, we would have been dead there and then. Frankly, death is a rather depressing end to any scientific excursion, never mind one that plants you squarely where no man has ever gone before.

This is an instance of you liking your prose. You already told us that the diety was a friendly sort and the reprecussions of that. You don't need to tell us the converse. The reader can think. "Where no man has ever gone before," is cliche.

My door swung open behind me and in walked trouble on six-inch heels. Her grace and poise was disarming but deceptive; she was a coiled death adder waiting to strike. She also happened to be my fiancée.

"My door," can just be turned into "the door behind me."

"Her grace and poise was disarming but deceptive." Read this again. There is a logical flaw in this sentence. It is also passive like a lot of your writing.

It was far more useful than a phone of any kind, having a variety of things it could do in addition to making calls, accepting texts, and playing games.

Again, irrelevant. We all know what a cell phone can do. If something surpasses it, the chances of it having more capablilties are greater rather than not.

As for the rest, it is disjointed, and does not make much sense.

I read in your reply that you write how you speak. This is not true. You write how you think you speak. We don't sit and analyze what we say unless we are spkeaing with intent. On a whole, we don't speak formally. We eat contractions like they were candy, and not using them, even in first person narrative, gives the whole thing a fake appearance.

I too, like the other reviewer, am glad that you have an editor. You both have your work cut out for you.

--JSC




Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

First off, thank you for not going easy on me. I realize that my highly formalized style of writing needs to be broken down so my stories sound different from my essays but it is a bit difficult when you're used to working solely on writing that is academic.
Second, and this is completely off topic, how did you get the words bolded like that? I've been trying to figure out how to do that for a while but never could.

I think I'm just going to cut the death line altogether. I was going for a Shakespearian feel, where you know how it ends but you read it because you want to know the how and why of it but it seems I failed horribly at doing so.

I don't get what you mean when you say there is a logical flaw in the sentence. Mind cluing me in?

EmmaMayfield
50060 words so far Winner!

You bold like this < strong >Whatever you are bolding< /strong > Minus the spaces

chibisarel
50014 words so far Winner!

[Her grace and poise was disarming but deceptive.]

I think what J_S_C means is that something can't be disarming at the same time as it's obviously deceptive. It's the only thing I can see, at least. I know what you mean, that the narrator knows it to be deceptive through experience. At the risk of ending up with too many long sentences, I'd suggest a re-write to something like "Her grace and poise might seem disarming, but I knew [...]" to indicate that it's something that isn't readily apparent.

(And yes, this is almost a week later, but...)

Anahlynn
56995 words so far Winner!

These are just my opinions, so take it with a grain of salt.

1. Critique (try to be specific and as detailed as possible): Okay if I'm going to be honest, I'd stop reading after the first paragraph. I hate when the narrator directly address the audience. It feels cheap and gimmicky.

Your tone makes it seem like you're trying way too hard. It's too formal and that annoyed me. And the random info dumps interrupted the story for me. You don't have to let your reader know everything right off the bat. When I open a good book I expect to be taken right into the middle of things, not to be given a history lesson.

2. Genre and age group: Adult fantasy/sci-fi

3. Shelve it or buy it: Shelve it.

4. Score (either letter A, B, C, D, or out of 100): C

EmmaMayfield
50060 words so far Winner!


The cries and wails of newborn infants could be heard from the female dormitory. Young mothers met their child once, and then their child was carried into the babies’ dorm, not to be seen again until they were old enough to join either the male or female dorm.

The youngest mothers were taken off of the List for one year to regain their strength, as were the sickly ones. The older ones, however were kept constantly on the list until 25, upon which they were released with their respective male and sent to an assigned house, where any further children could live with them.

Some said it was to repopulate the earth after most of it was wiped out in a devastating war, leaving only 200 kids, 100 male, 100 female, and 10 adults on the planet. But others explained that many on the earth had in fact survived the war, and the Supervisors, as they were called, wanted to grow their own army and destroy the rest of the survivors.

Escape? It was unheard of. Many had tried, and those who did were bumped to the top of the List to become the next ones to undergo treatment.

That was where Raine and Brooke came in. Both had tried to escape, and now they were at the top of the List, the first ones to undergo the ‘treatment’ the next morning, and it was not going to be pleasant, that was for sure. That is where their story begins.

Chapter One

The cold hard floors of the main building made Raine’s feet fall asleep as she waited with dread. This was her first time at the top. Why did everyone dread the top of the list? She had asked that of Lizzie, one who had already been in the list once, not too long ago.

“The list has sections. The top no one knows what happens. And as you know, those on the top usually don’t come back. Those in the middle section are given one or two assignments, from childbearing or experimental subjects, and the bottom, where everyone wishes to be, is the waiting section or ineligibles.” Lizzie had told her a few months before.

“Why do they want to do this do this to us?” Raine asked in despair, knowing after the little escape attempt of hers that she was put on the top.

“Honestly,” Lizzie said, looking around and lowering her voice, “I think there were survivors.”

At that time Raine was 14, too young to be put at the top of the list. But when she turned 15 a week ago, she was put up at the top with her best friend and cousin Brooke. And now Raine knew she had made a terrible mistake.

Brooke watched the nervous movements that Raine made from across the room, along with the ten other young girls as they waited. The boys were in the next room over, Brooke knew, having talked to one in the hall using hand signals.
“Number seventy-two and seventy-five!” A loud voice bellowed from the other side of the huge white door.

Raine cast a terrified glance at Brooke as one of the ‘nurses’ grabbed her hand and took her beyond the white door, and yet another grabbed Brooke as she struggled to break free, anything to get out of the mess she was in.

“You,” One of the women said with a glance over Raine. “Follow me.” She said with a smirk as she took a folder from
the filing cabinet and forced Raine along the winding corridor, leaving Brooke alone as another woman approached.

“And you are?” She asked with a disgusted tone, turning toward the filing cabinet to look for her file.

“Number seventy-five.” Brooke said, looking down at the floor. Everyone of them had names, but no one called them by their names, at least not the adults.

“Brooke Whitfield, aged 15, and you have been in this facility for 11 years, correct?” The woman asked in a business-like tone that made Brooke keep looking at the floor as the guard behind her held her cuffed arms.

All Brooke could do was nod. The woman turned toward the guard and handed him a file.

“She goes into room 21, further down the hall, you know where it is.” The woman said with a glance of disgust at Brooke.

The guard roughed her down the corridor and down a flight of stairs, into a room filled with scientific equipment. But they passed that room by and walked out the other end, into a holding room for the test subjects.

“Number sixty-seven, you come with me.” The guard said, shoving Brooke into the room as he grabbed the other girl and took her out, leaving Brooke’s cuffs on, and tight too.

Inside the testing room was a piece of equipment no one dared use before, deemed too dangerous to use until they had gotten more test subjects to use in case of a misfire.

The guard took the girl and strapped her onto a table, put a piece of tape over her mouth, and motioned for the pair in the door to come to the table.

“The subject is ready.” He said, handing a folder to one of the scientists from the cabinet against the wall, which held numerous documents and files of sorts that many had never seen before.

“Ah, how perfect. Elizabeth Harris, aged 16, known as Lizzie to some girls, known to us as an elaborate escape artist. What procedure did the director wish for us to perform today?” The woman asked, looking up from the folder at the other man.

“Procedure 49. The Director said three of the other subjects had miscarried their children, and the Director wishes for us to stay on target growth.” The other scientist said with a nod.

From the room Brooke was in, she heard everything perfectly. She knew the girl. It was Lizzie.

Suddenly loud and muffled screams filled the room as the whirring of tools started, and then all fell silent.

Anahlynn
56995 words so far Winner!

All of this is just based on my reading preferences so take everything with a grain of salt.

EmmaMayfield wrote:

The cries and wails of newborn infants could be heard from the female dormitory. Young mothers met their child once, and then their child was carried into the babies’ dorm, not to be seen again until they were old enough to join either the male or female dorm.

The youngest mothers were taken off of the List for one year to regain their strength, as were the sickly ones. The older ones, however were kept constantly on the list until 25, upon which they were released with their respective male and sent to an assigned house, where any further children could live with them.

Some said it was to repopulate the earth after most of it was wiped out in a devastating war, leaving only 200 kids, 100 male, 100 female, and 10 adults on the planet. But others explained that many on the earth had in fact survived the war, and the Supervisors, as they were called, wanted to grow their own army and destroy the rest of the survivors.

Escape? It was unheard of. Many had tried, and those who did were bumped to the top of the List to become the next ones to undergo treatment.

That was where Raine and Brooke came in. Both had tried to escape, and now they were at the top of the List, the first ones to undergo the ‘treatment’ the next morning, and it was not going to be pleasant, that was for sure. That is where their story begins.
This is information that you could easily work into your story. And as a reader I don't like being told, "This is where character x's story begins." You should just jump into the story.

Chapter One

Your story starts here.The cold hard floors of the main building made Raine’s feet fall asleep as she waited with dread. This was her first time at the top. Why did everyone dread the top of the list? She had asked that of Lizzie, one who had already been in the list once, not too long ago.This paragraph loses suspense because you already explained the list in your info dump. Another reason to cut it.

“The list has sections. The top no one knows what happens. And as you know, those on the top usually don’t come back. Those in the middle section are given one or two assignments, from childbearing or experimental subjects, and the bottom, where everyone wishes to be, is the waiting section or ineligibles.” Lizzie had told her a few months before.

“Why do they want to do this do this to us?” Raine asked in despair, knowing after the little escape attempt of hers that she was put on the top.

“Honestly,” Lizzie said, looking around and lowering her voice, “I think there were survivors.”

At that time Raine was 14, too young to be put at the top of the list. But when she turned 15 a week ago, she was put up at the top with her best friend and cousin Brooke. And now Raine knew she had made a terrible mistake.

Awkward POV change. Having read the entire thing it seems better to just start with Brooke's point of view. Brooke watched the nervous movements that Raine made from across the room, along with the ten other young girls as they waited. The boys were in the next room over, Brooke knew, having talked to one in the hall using hand signals.

“Number seventy-two and seventy-five!” A loud voice bellowed from the other side of the huge white door.

Raine cast a terrified glance at Brooke as one of the ‘nurses’ grabbed her hand and took her beyond the white door, and yet another grabbed Brooke as she struggled to break free, anything to get out of the mess she was in.

“You,” One of the women said with a glance over Raine. “Follow me.” She said with a smirk as she took a folder from
the filing cabinet and forced Raine along the winding corridor, leaving Brooke alone as another woman approached.

“And you are?” She asked with a disgusted tone, turning toward the filing cabinet to look for her file.

“Number seventy-five.” Brooke said, looking down at the floor. Everyone of them had names, but no one called them by their names, at least not the adults.

“Brooke Whitfield, aged 15, and you have been in this facility for 11 years, correct?” The woman asked in a business-like tone that made Brooke keep looking at the floor as the guard behind her held her cuffed arms.

All Brooke could do was nod. The woman turned toward the guard and handed him a file.

“She goes into room 21, further down the hall, you know where it is.” The woman said with a glance of disgust at Brooke.

The guard roughed her down the corridor and down a flight of stairs, into a room filled with scientific equipment. But they passed that room by and walked out the other end, into a holding room for the test subjects. "Roughed her down," is a really awkward way to phrase that. Also, if they just passed the room why mention it? Just skip to the part where she enters the other room.

“Number sixty-seven, you come with me.” The guard said, shoving Brooke into the room as he grabbed the other girl and took her out, leaving Brooke’s cuffs on, and tight too.

Inside the testing room was a piece of equipment no one dared use before, deemed too dangerous to use until they had gotten more test subjects to use in case of a misfire.Needless drama...

The guard took the girl and strapped her onto a table, put a piece of tape over her mouth, and motioned for the pair in the door to come to the table.

“The subject is ready.” He said, handing a folder to one of the scientists from the cabinet against the wall, which held numerous documents and files of sorts that many had never seen before.

“Ah, how perfect. Elizabeth Harris, aged 16, known as Lizzie to some girls, known to us as an elaborate escape artist. What procedure did the director wish for us to perform today?” The woman asked, looking up from the folder at the other man.

“Procedure 49. The Director said three of the other subjects had miscarried their children, and the Director wishes for us to stay on target growth.” The other scientist said with a nod.

From the room Brooke was in, she heard everything perfectly. She knew the girl. It was Lizzie.

Suddenly loud and muffled screams filled the room as the whirring of tools started, and then all fell silent.



I think my main issue with this is that it starts in the wrong place. If you started right when Brooke was introduced this chapter would have been stronger. Don't be afraid to let your reader get confused. If you have really a really strong writing style they'll continue on reading anyway.

Genre and Age group: Young Adult Sci-fi

Buy it or Shelve it: Shelve it, because the info dump was boring.

Grade: B-

EmmaMayfield
50060 words so far Winner!

Thank you for the critique. This is the first time I've written anything like this, and it helps alot to get feedback. I will certainly take your advice.

Anahlynn
56995 words so far Winner!

Your welcome! I actually really liked your chapter, minus the info dump. It seems like a really good idea and I hope to see more in the future. :)

EmmaMayfield
50060 words so far Winner!

Well, I just took out what was mentioned and fixed a few bits to make it work when needed so it would make sense. As soon as I finish more I'll be back to post more and critique others. As I said, I'm totally new to this genre, so I'm enjoying getting feedback.

LadyStarlea
50194 words so far Winner!

1. Critique (try to be specific and as detailed as possible):
Ok not going to be nice here but I will explain why....

EmmaMayfield wrote:
The cries and wails of newborn infants could be heard from the female dormitory. Young mothers met their child once, and then their child was carried into the babies’ dorm, not to be seen again until they were old enough to join either the male or female dorm.

The youngest mothers were taken off of the List for one year to regain their strength, as were the sickly ones. The older ones, however were kept constantly on the list until 25, upon which they were released with their respective male and sent to an assigned house, where any further children could live with them.

Some said it was to repopulate the earth after most of it was wiped out in a devastating war, leaving only 200 kids, 100 male, 100 female, and 10 adults on the planet. But others explained that many on the earth had in fact survived the war, and the Supervisors, as they were called, wanted to grow their own army and destroy the rest of the survivors.

Escape? It was unheard of. Many had tried, and those who did were bumped to the top of the List to become the next ones to undergo treatment.

That was where Raine and Brooke came in. Both had tried to escape, and now they were at the top of the List, the first ones to undergo the ‘treatment’ the next morning, and it was not going to be pleasant, that was for sure. That is where their story begins.

Chapter One

Strike the prologue your story starts with chapter 1. I am going to quote two sources for why you do not want a prologue.

Quote:
advice on prologues: Mostly: Don't do 'em. There are, of course, exceptions. One popular exception is a prologue in a book in an established series. A prologue is sometimes used in such a book simply to bring the fans of the series up to speed for the current read. Many times, it will include a short synopsis of where the protagonist was when the previous book ended — and perhaps a major shift he has undergone offstage since the previous story. There are other legitimate reasons to employ a prologue. But don't use one if you're just trying to sneak in backstory. If that's the sole reason for writing a prologue, it's probably best to forego the prologue altogether.

Edgerton, Les (2007-04-12). Hooked: Write Fiction That Grabs Readers at Page One & Never Lets Them Go (p. 22). F+W Media, Inc.. Kindle Edition.


Quote:... In other words, by the time we are given the full explanation of the world, we already care about the people involved in saving it. Too many writers of event stories, especially epic fantasies, don't learn this lesson from Tolkien. Instead, they imagine that their poor reader won't be able to understand what's going on if they don't begin with a prologue showing the “world situation.” Alas, these prologues always fail. Because we aren't emotionally involved with any characters, because we don't yet care, the prologues are meaningless. They are also usually confusing, as a half-dozen names are thrown at us all at once. I have learned as a book reviewer that it's usually best to skip the prologue and begin with the story — as the author also should have done.

Editors of Writer's Digest Books (2010-08-22). The Complete Handbook Of Novel Writing: Everything You Need to Know About Creating & Selling Your Work (p. 257). F+W Media, Inc.. Kindle Edition. STORY STRUCTURES FOR SCIENCE FICTION & FANTASY BY ORSON SCOTT CARD


Granted you only dropped two names not half a dozen. But really you explain the important parts of your world in the opening of chapter one with Raine's flashback about what Lizzie told her. So really you do not need the prologue. I think people can understand things fine with your opening of chapter one. If you want them to learn more about the world let them do it though Raine and Brooke.

EmmaMayfield wrote:
Raine cast a terrified glance at Brooke as one of the ‘nurses’ grabbed her hand and took her beyond the white door, and yet another grabbed Brooke as she struggled to break free, anything to get out of the mess she was in.

“You,” One of the women said with a glance over Raine. “Follow me.” She said with a smirk as she took a folder from
the filing cabinet and forced Raine along the winding corridor, leaving Brooke alone as another woman approached.


“And you are?” She asked with a disgusted tone, turning toward the filing cabinet to look for her file.


this is really the only place in chapter one I had a big problem with. You already had Raine leave though a white door. You then mentioned Brooke struggling yet you do not mention anything else. You are mostly telling here not showing. Where are the emotions Brooke is feeling? What happen when she struggled to be free? Was she dragged away? subdued?

Strike the next paragraph unless you are going to switch back to Raine's POV but since you are staying with Brooke then striking that paragraph and just mentioning what is going on with Brooke. Though the whole chapter remember you need to show us not tell us what is going on. Let us feel what Raine and Brooke are feeling. Everything seemed very disjointed. I could not get into this story at all. You want to hook me into your story, draw me in. Make me want to keep reading because I feel Brooke's fear.

2. Genre and age group: fantasy/sci-fi even though the MCs ages should make this be middle school or YA I feel this is more adult in nature

3. Shelve it or buy it: Shelve it. Everything seemed cold and unfeeling and I could not feel myself getting pulled into the story at all.

4. Score (either letter A, B, C, D, or out of 100): C though I think there is potential to be a good story here.

Trixter
50378 words so far Winner!

Oooo, I wanna play along, too. :)

Dream of a Thousand Stars - Prologue

Etheris Edgerton needed a smoke.

It was pouring rain as he opened the backdoor of his shop and stepped out under an awning that didn’t quite manage to keep the rain off his heavy tiku-leather boots. The clouds muted the night into only the faintest shades of gray, filtering out all but a trace of moonslight. As dark as the night was, it was just as loud. Massive raindrops beat a rhythm on the taut waxed canvas of the awning. With a thought Etheris turned on the night vision in his retinal lenses, relics from his time with Arandee, and fished a cigarette box and his old metal lighter out of the pocket of his coat.

It had been a long day, but profitable, from the early afternoon farmers looking to add to the gaia-focusing tattoos that helped grow their crops, the evening kids just wanting something for decoration, and bleeding into the late-night semi-inebriated customers looking to have something done to their bodies they would regret in the morning. Gaiamancer though he was, arms lined with his own focusing tattoos, Etheris sympathized most with the latter group. He took a long draw on his cigarette, closed his eyes, felt it fill his lungs and wondered if it was too late into the night to do something he would also regret in the morning.

It wasn’t until he opened his eyes, night vision shifting the waterlogged alley into shades of blue and green, that he noticed the roughly man-sized bundle of blankets lying on the soaking ground.

Etheris choked out the lungful of smoke in surprise, leaned against the wall hacking until he got back his breath. Through tears squeezed out by the coughing fit he could make out a smallish hand poking between folds in the bundle. He stared at it. It didn’t move. Grumbling to himself about vagrants, he stubbed his cigarette out on the wall, scowled at the sky, accepted that the sky had no intention of quelling the torrent, and stepped out from under the awning.

He crouched beside the blanket and lifted the hand. The skin was cold and clammy, but he could sense the gentle warmth of its gaia underneath. After a moment’s searching he felt the telltale throbbing of a pulse beneath his fingers. Not a corpse, at least.

It was a few feet from where the bundle lay to the relatively dry haven by the door. Etheris regarded the distance, shivering as cold fingers of water wound their way down the back of his neck despite his oiled leather duster. Brute strength wasn’t among his gifts. He turned back to the unconscious bundle, leaned forward and peeled away part of the blanket, trying to get a glimpse of the person he was considering risking injury to help. The face he uncovered was a boy who couldn’t be any older then fifteen, pale, far paler than anyone Etheris had encountered outside of the clans. He turned his night vision off. The hair plastered to the boy’s scalp was a shade of orange he’d never actually seen on a human before. The boy’s cheeks and eyes were sunken, and if he hadn’t felt that flutter of a pulse under his skin Etheris would have taken him for dead. A kid, and a sick one at that. He cursed under his breath.

Ignoring the cold that soaked through the front of his clothes from the sodden blankets, Etheris wrapped his arms around the boy and hauled him to the door. He fell against the wall beside him, panting. The boy was still unconscious. It occurred to him then that the boy didn’t smell like a drunk. He didn’t reek of cheap fruit wine, just wet human. Something else, then, tanni milk or akasham or whatever cheap thrill Paolo’s street kids snorted or shot into their veins. Etheris frowned, running his fingers over the boy’s cool cheek. He had seen a lot of things wash up in the alleys here, and any shop known for gaiamancy was going to be a magnet for vagrants in need of a healing touch. But so young…

There were no more appointments tonight. He could take the boy in, let him sleep off whatever he had gotten into inside where he’d at least be warm, give him a meal in the morning and set him loose. Despite whatever terrible choices had left him passed out in the alley, he was a cute kid. Much too young for Etheris, but cute nonetheless.
That decided, Etheris pulled himself to his feet. As he looked back down at the boy he noticed an envelope, pale brown paper held against his chest by the wrapped blankets. Reactivating his night vision, he teased the thing out from the sodden mess, careful not to tear it. On the front his name was starting to bleed across the paper. Despite the cold he started to sweat, and the world turned to glass around him, threatening to break as he eased open the flap. There was money inside, a thick sheaf of bills, and underneath it something he hadn’t seen in years, not since he left Arandee’s Academy. He unfolded it slowly, willing it to defy his expectations, willing them to not draw him back into his father’s machinations. But it was exactly what he feared it was. On the paper was a schematic of cybernetic augments, with a note scrawled at the top:

REMOVE THE TRACER FIRST.

Anahlynn
56995 words so far Winner!

Trixter wrote:
Oooo, I wanna play along, too. :)

Dream of a Thousand Stars - Prologue

Etheris Edgerton needed a smoke. Awesome opening sentence

It was pouring rain as he opened the backdoor of his shop and stepped out under an awning that didn’t quite manage to keep the rain off his heavy tiku-leather boots. I found this sentence really long and tiresome to read. Perhaps shorten it or remove all of the unnecessary detail. The clouds muted the night into only the faintest shades of gray, filtering out all but a trace of moonslight. As dark as the night was, it was just as loud. Massive raindrops beat a rhythm on the taut waxed canvas of the awning. With a thought Etheris turned on the night vision in his retinal lenses Referencing technology immediately lets me know that this is set in the future. Nice, relics from his time with Arandee, and fished a cigarette box and his old metal lighter out of the pocket of his coat.

It had been a long day, but profitable. From the early afternoon farmers looking to add to the gaia-focusing tattoos that helped grow their crops, to the evening kids just wanting something for decoration, and bleeding into the late-night semi-inebriated customers looking to have something done to their bodies they would regret in the morning. Gaiamancer though he was, arms lined with his own focusing tattoos, Etheris sympathized most with the latter group. He took a long draw on his cigarette, closed his eyes, felt it fill his lungs and wondered if it was too late into the night to do something he would also regret in the morning. So far Etheris(love the name) seems like a chill guy. As a reader, I find that I can relate to him easily. Make the Big Exciting Incident all the more interesting.

It wasn’t until he opened his eyes, night vision shifting the waterlogged alley into shades of blue and green, that he noticed the roughly man-sized bundle of blankets lying on the soaking ground.

Etheris choked out the lungful of smoke in surprise, leaning against the wall hacking until he got back his breath. Through tears squeezed out by the coughing fit he could make out a smallish hand poking between folds in the bundle. He stared at it. It didn’t move. Grumbling to himself about vagrants, he stubbed his cigarette out on the wall, scowled at the sky, accepted that it Repeating the word Sky in the same sentence is really awkward. had no intention of quelling the torrent, and stepped out from under the awning.

He crouched beside the blanket and lifted the hand. The skin was cold and clammy, but he could sense the gentle warmth of its gaia underneath. After a moment’s searching he felt the telltale throbbing of a pulse beneath his fingers. Not a corpse, at least.

It was a few feet from where the bundle lay to the relatively dry haven by the door. Etheris regarded the distance, shivering as cold fingers of water wound their way down the back of his neck despite his oiled leather duster. Brute strength wasn’t among his gifts. He turned back to the unconscious bundle, leaned forward and peeled away part of the blanket, trying to get a glimpse of the person he was considering risking injury to help. The face he uncovered was a boy who couldn’t be any older then fifteen, pale, far paler than anyone Etheris had encountered outside of the clans. He turned his night vision off. The hair plastered to the boy’s scalp was a shade of orange he’d never actually seen on a human before. The boy’s cheeks and eyes were sunken, and if he hadn’t felt that flutter of a pulse under his skin Etheris would have taken him for dead. A kid, and a sick one at that. He cursed under his breath.

Ignoring the cold that soaked through the front of his clothes from the sodden blankets, Etheris wrapped his arms around the boy and hauled him to the door. He fell against the wall beside him, panting. The boy was still unconscious. It occurred to him then that the boy didn’t smell like a drunk. He didn’t reek of cheap fruit wine, just wet human. Something else, then, tanni milk or akasham or whatever cheap thrill Paolo’s street kids snorted or shot into their veins. Just like all of the other teenagers I know. Etheris frowned, running his fingers over the boy’s cool cheek. He had seen a lot of things wash up in the alleys here, and any shop known for gaiamancy was going to be a magnet for vagrants in need of a healing touch. But so young…

There were no more appointments tonight. He could take the boy in, let him sleep off whatever he had gotten into inside where he’d at least be warm, give him a meal in the morning and set him loose. Despite whatever terrible choices had left him passed out in the alley, he was a cute kid. Much too young for Etheris, but cute nonetheless. Etheris must have some kinky preferences if he thinks emancipated bodies are cute...

That decided, Etheris pulled himself to his feet. As he looked back down at the boy he noticed an envelope, pale brown paper held against his chest by the wrapped blankets. Reactivating his night vision, he teased the thing out from the sodden mess, careful not to tear it. On the front his name was starting to bleed across the paper. Despite the cold he started to sweat, and the world turned to glass around him, threatening to break as he eased open the flap. There was money inside, a thick sheaf of bills, and underneath it something he hadn’t seen in years, not since he left Arandee’s Academy. He unfolded it slowly, willing it to defy his expectations, willing them to not draw him back into his father’s machinations. But it was exactly what he feared it was. On the paper was a schematic of cybernetic augments, with a note scrawled at the top:

REMOVE THE TRACER FIRST.


In my opinion, this is a really good opening. The way you introduced Etheris was smart and his character leaped out. I think creating a character the reader will like is more important then getting down to the action-packed stuff. The only thing left to say is that your sentences are unnecesarily long and complicated. I had to reread several of them to get what you were saying.

Genre and age group: Adult Sci-fi

Buy it or Shelve it: Buy it.

Grade: A-

Trixter
50378 words so far Winner!

Thank you for the feedback! I've always had a tendency to get lost in the depths of my own overwrought sentence structure, and it's something I'm definitely working on improving as I edit the novel. I've always had a strength for characterization, too, and thank you for confirming that I've still got that going for me!

Repenthea
55198 words so far Winner!

Critique: This is the only opening so far that's been readable for me. Excellent grasp of character, vivid location sketch (not too detailed), and a quick jump into story. Great. Etheris' name is weird, but not too so much so that I get confused and think I won't get used to it.

My only turn-off (and this is entirely a personal one) is that I really don't like the word gaia. I simultaneously think of hippies and bad anime whenever I hear it. That being said, your story sounds interesting enough for me to get past it.

Genre and age group: Adult sci-fi

Buy it or Shelve it: Buy it.

Grade: A

Anahlynn
56995 words so far Winner!

Chapter One

The snow beat against the aged glass. The sound reminded Liam of half-forgotten memories. Of a place far, far away from this primitive planet and their primitive people. A place he didn't want to remember.

“If this was your fiftieth time in a diner this week, what would you recommend?”

The waitress blinked, a curious look settling over her homely face. A short, plump woman with peroxide blonde hair and a permanent stick of bubble gum in her mouth, Gwen Harper had seen her fair share of weirdos at Cantalen's Diner and Pit Stop. Still, that didn't stop her from being surprised by the boy's question.

Liam waited for her response, his hands trailing the battered menu. Whoever made it, Cantalen he supposed, had tried to make it appear fancy, like what you saw in upscale restaurants. It was a soft orange and words had been written by hands to give the reader the "homemade" feel. It worked. He sniffed it, delighting in the smell of peach cobbler that filled his nose. Gwen gaped at him, but Liam continued his examination. On the fifth day of his arrival, the menu had become so familiar to him, he was sure he could list every item from memory.

A cough startled him out of his thoughts to discover Gwen the Waitress looking at him as if he were a interesting science project.

"Well?" he said raising an eyebrow. The woman had not answered his question.

Gwen stuttered to reply. "Have you tried the Peach Cobbler?"

"Five times." He flicked through the menu.

"Homemade Jammers?" she asked, referring to the roll of bread stuffed with whatever fruit they had lying around at the time.

"They tasted like old socks."

"A Mushroom Swiss Burger?"

"I hate swiss." He could see her becoming frustrated and a slight chill ran through him. Someone was paying attention to him, acknowledging him.

She popped her hip. "Do you like anything?"

Liam paused at the question. Did he like anything? It was hard to tell. Too soon to adjust to this strange planet and their strange customs. "I like apples." He decided.

She matched his haughty expression. "We're out." As soon they'd left her mouth she wanted to take back the words. The boy looked crestfallen. How strange, she thought. Sucking in air, she applied a smile to her cracked lips. "How 'bout I make you some eggs?"

The boy blinked at the offer. "Eggs?" He tested out the new word.

Gwen blinked at the boy's apparent confusion. How could he not know eggs? "Eggs. You know the stuff that comes outta chickens?" She flapped her arms for emphasis. The boy continued to stare. Just as she was about to try another gesture a loud snicker interrupted her. Pete, the chef, was at the counter, wearing his customary smirk. Gwen's face burned as she realized he must have been watching the entire time.

She looks like an unattractive lady bug. Liam observed the woman who had been making ludicrous hand gestures at him. Most be a human greeting. He pantomined her and Pete the Chef laughed. Liam took his laughter for approval and smiled, while Gwen wished she could crawl under a rock.

Gripping the side of the table, she said, "I'll just go place an order right now." She scurried into the kitchen, eager to escape the strange boy and her co-workers laughter.

Liam stared after her before returning to his menu, content to just re-read the booklet over and over again. Human writing was so strange...

A pleasent smell filled the air and he breathed in deeply. Maybe he would like these eggs after all. So wrapped up in his thoughts and wonders of this world, he didn't notice the figure at the door.

Activity stopped. Liam amd Pete the Chef looked, wondering who else would be walking around in the middle of a snow storm. Gwen's humming could be heard through the thick silence.

The stranger stood for a moment, his head bent, hair covering his face. Slowly he made his way over to a booth, his face hidden from sight. As he took a seat, their eyes met. For a brief moment, Liam caught the man's acidic green glare. His heart thumped. Stark-white hands gripped the countertop as he tried to control the sudden flurry of emotions. The man should not have been there, could not be there. It was wrong, very wrong.

The man shrugged off his coat, revealing a long, spindly body. His eyes remained on Liam, the corners of his mouth curving upward. Liam returned it with a blank stare. For a moment, not a sound could be heard. They stared, waiting for the other to break first. Lights flickered above and the man blinked. Liam smiled innocently and returned to his menu, singing a Christmas tune and swinging his legs.

"These angels sing their songs on high, sing me Noel today..."

Pete the Chef glanced uneasily between the too. They were rivals of some sort. Warring gangs. A rising problem in the small town and now it was at his diner.

He stepped out from behind the corner, hands raised. "Hey I don't know what you guys are fighten 'bout, but take it somewhere else. Don't need no drama here."

The man acted first. Leaping over the table, he whipped out a gun. Pulling the trigger, a small orb of light appeared and took aim to Liam. The boy lunged to the side. All that remained of the booth was the burnt stub the table sat upon. The light had blown a hole through the booth, which now glowed an unholy red.

Liam scrambled to his feet as the man reloaded the gun.

"You damn Yulics never die!" The man fired.

J_S_C
100145 words so far Winner!

The snow beat against the aged glass. The sound reminded Liam of half-forgotten memories. Of a place far, far away from this primitive planet and their primitive people. A place he didn't want to remember.

Punctuation error. "....half-forgotten memories, of a place..." "A place he didn't want to remember" is fine because of the impled "It was."

like what you saw in upscale restaurants

I would change you to one, but that is stylistic and prevents the reader switching to momentary second person.


Other than those, this is most excelent, probably the best beginning I have read on these boards in some time.

Grade: A
Genre: Sci-Fi
Would read further: Yes.

--JSC

Anahlynn
56995 words so far Winner!

Thank you for the critique! When I posted on here I was expecting something meaner since I just started writing it. It's good to know I'm on the write track.

I never even thought about the "You" style until now and I'm a little ashamed to say I use it quite frequently. Just goes to show I have a lot to learn about the world of writing.

Repenthea
55198 words so far Winner!

Anahlynn wrote:
Chapter One

The snow beat against the aged glass. The sound reminded Liam of half-forgotten memories. Of a place far, far away from this primitive planet and their primitive people. A place he didn't want to remember.

“If this was your fiftieth time in a diner this week, what would you recommend?” I would insert in a "said" line here, because until I read a few sentences in I wasn't sure if it was Liam who said this or if it was Gwen.

The waitress blinked, a curious look settling over her homely face. A short, plump woman with peroxide blonde hair and a permanent stick of bubble gum in her mouth, Gwen Harper had seen her fair share of weirdos at Cantalen's Diner and Pit Stop. Still, that didn't stop her from being surprised by the boy's question.

Liam waited for her response, his hands trailing the battered menu. Whoever made it, Cantalen he supposed, had tried to make it appear fancy, like what you saw in upscale restaurants. It was a soft orange and words had been written by hands to give the reader the "homemade" feel. It worked. He sniffed it, delighting in the smell of peach cobbler that filled his nose. Gwen gaped at him, but Liam continued his examination. On the fifth day of his arrival, the menu had become so familiar to him, he was sure he could list every item from memory.

A cough startled him out of his thoughts to discover Gwen the Waitress looking at him as if he were a interesting science project.

"Well?" he said insert comma raising an eyebrow. The woman had not answered his question.

Gwen stuttered to reply. "Have you tried the Peach Cobbler?" "Stuttered to reply" is odd. I would simply say "Gwen stuttered." The fact that she replied is obvious.

"Five times." He flicked through the menu.

"Homemade Jammers?" she asked, referring to the roll of bread stuffed with whatever fruit they had lying around at the time.

"They tasted like old socks."

"A Mushroom Swiss Burger?"

"I hate swiss." He could see her becoming frustrated and a slight chill ran through him. Someone was paying attention to him, acknowledging him.

She popped her hip. "Do you like anything?"

Liam paused at the question. Did he like anything? It was hard to tell. Too soon to adjust to this strange planet and their strange customs. "I like apples." He decided.

She matched his haughty expression. "We're out." As soon they'd left her mouth she wanted to take back the words. The boy looked crestfallen. How strange, she thought. Sucking in air, she applied a smile to her cracked lips. "How 'bout I make you some eggs?" You just changed POV here. I find omniscient 3rd person (which is what you're using here - jumping between the two viewpoints without a chapter breakup or anything to delineate them) to be very confusing.

The boy blinked at the offer. "Eggs?" He tested out the new word. If he had memorized the menu (which you state that he's done) why wouldn't he be familiar with the word eggs?

Gwen blinked at the boy's apparent confusion. How could he not know eggs? "Eggs. You know the stuff that comes outta chickens?" She flapped her arms for emphasis. The boy continued to stare. Just as she was about to try another gesture a loud snicker interrupted her. Pete, the chef, was at the counter, wearing his customary smirk. Gwen's face burned as she realized he must have been watching the entire time.

She looks like an unattractive lady bug. Liam observed the woman who had been making ludicrous hand gestures at him. Most be a human greeting. He pantomined her and Pete the Chef laughed. Liam took his laughter for approval and smiled, while Gwen wished she could crawl under a rock. Whoa omniscient 3rd person. Confusing. I would pick a character (probably Liam, since he seems to be your protagonist) and stick with his point of view throughout. Also, I'm having a lot of difficultly imagining a woman looking like an unattractive ladybug. What does that even look like?

Gripping the side of the table, she said, "I'll just go place an order right now." She scurried into the kitchen, eager to escape the strange boy and her co-workers co-workers' laughter. An order of what? He didn't order anything.

Liam stared after her before returning to his menu, content to just re-read the booklet over and over again. Human writing was so strange... delete the dot dot dots

A pleasent smell filled the air and he breathed in deeply. Maybe he would like these eggs after all. So wrapped up in his thoughts and wonders of this world, he didn't notice the figure at the door.

Activity stopped. Liam amd and Pete the Chef looked, wondering who else would be walking around in the middle of a snow storm. Gwen's humming could be heard through the thick silence.

The stranger stood for a moment, his head bent, hair covering his face. Slowly he made his way over to a booth "He slowly made his way over to a booth,", his face hidden from sight. As he took a seat, their eyes met. For a brief moment, Liam caught the man's acidic green glare. His heart thumped. Stark-white hands gripped the countertop as he tried to control the sudden flurry of emotions. The man should not have been there, could not be there. It was wrong, very wrong. I find it a little redundant to say that their eyes met and then that Liam caught the man's stare. It sort of made me think that Liam looked away and then back, which I don't think is what you're intending. Also, this is an issue with using the POV you're using - I'm not sure who's eyes the man is meeting after he takes a seat. The last person you mention is Gwen, and before that Pete, so it could conceivably be either of them.

The man shrugged off his coat, revealing a long, spindly body. His eyes remained on Liam, the corners of his mouth curving upward. Liam returned it what is he returning? with a blank stare. For a moment, not a sound could be heard. They stared, waiting for the other to break first. break what? I get it that you mean the stare, but it sounds too slang-y, which would be fine if that was the tone you were using throughout, but it's not, so I would clarify. Lights flickered above and the man blinked. Liam smiled innocently and returned to his menu, singing a Christmas tune and swinging his legs.

"These angels sing their songs on high, sing me Noel today..."

Pete the Chef glanced uneasily between the too. They were rivals of some sort. Warring gangs. A rising problem in the small town and now it was at his diner.

He stepped out from behind the corner, hands raised. "Hey I don't know what you guys are fighten 'bout, but take it somewhere else. Don't need no drama here."

The man acted first. Leaping over the table, he whipped out a gun. Pulling the trigger, a small orb of light appeared and took aim to Liam. "took aim at" but also, the orb of light presumably doesn't have the intention of taking aim. I would change this to "shot at" or "flew towards" or something. The boy lunged to the side. All that remained of the booth was the burnt stub the table sat upon. The light had blown a hole through the booth, which now glowed an unholy red. "all that remained of the booth was a burnt stub" and then "the booth...now glowed an unholy red." I think you mean that the stub of the booth now glowed an unholy red.

Liam scrambled to his feet as the man reloaded the gun.

"You damn Yulics never die!" The man fired.


Critique: It's an interesting premise. The trope of "alien discovering humanity" is a well-trod one, but still has merit, in my opinion. Your writing, however, makes it fairly confusing to figure out what exactly is going on. I would steer FAR away from using 3rd person omniscient (narration style where you jump around to different characters' point-of-view). It's confusing and generally doesn't allow the reader to connect with any one character. As for plot: it lags. The action doesn't start until the very end, at which point we've read an awful lot about diner food and seen a kid act weird, neither of which engrosses the reader enough to continue. There seem to be some potential plotholes. Like how does Liam (an alien, I'm assuming) know Christmas songs? How has Gwen not managed to see this kid at all in the last five days he's been coming to the diner constantly?

A little note: the chef surmises that Liam and the skinny guy must be from warring gangs, which seem to be a growing problem in his small town. As someone living in a small town I find it HIGHLY unlikely that enough people could divide themselves into gangs to merit a growing problem. This is my personal opinion, however, and others may not agree.

Genre: YA sci-fi
Buy it or shelve it: shelve it
Grade: D

J_S_C
100145 words so far Winner!

Events of a person’s life can change in the space of a day or even a couple hours. With me, the utterance of a couple of words from a doctor after he had run a bunch of tests, had me in stirrups attempting to put a speculum inside of my untested vagina, and another spreading cold clear goo over my lower abdomen and probing it with an ultrasound, changed me forever. Those tests started after my sixteenth birthday.

Remembering turning fifteen to sixteen now is like trying to remember a dream. Images that appear with closed eyes are fleeting and more impressionistic than real. My best friend at the time, Lacey was constantly going to the bathroom. She said it was because she had drunk too much water the night before and during the day. Nodding, I knew that it was best to not embarrass her. Why she thought that having her period was a thing to be ashamed of I didn’t understand then, and don’t understand now.

At the time, there was nothing insidious in my having to go to the bathroom, for I really did. Lacey was in there and I could hear her humming something indistinct. Outside in the hall, I was doing what my dad would have called the “piss and shit shuffle.” She finally came out after flushing the toilet and was startled to see me standing there moving from one foot to the other. She followed me with her eyes as I went into the bathroom, and I think I still felt the gaze after the door shut.

What prompted me to look under the sink after I had done my business, I'll never be able to say. Maybe suspicion or maybe envy of something that I had not yet experienced. Now, looking back on it, I can say the latter. I hadn’t had my period. Inside the waste-basket lay several clumps of toilet paper. Despite the grossness of it, I picked one up, unwrapped the white paper, and found a pad, evidence of Lacey’s womanhood. The aisle of the grocery store that held all of the feminine products was like a shrine to commercialism and the biological functions of a woman. I never understood what my mom said when she talked about heavy flow and spotting and light flows. To me it was all the same. Looking at the pad in my hands, I wondered if the dark brown spot was a heavy or light flow. With the care that Lacey seemed to wrap the pad, I put it back in the waste-basket and washed my hands. Blood never grossed me, and it was probably my most boy-like trait, other than sports.

“You took a long time in there,” Lacey said to me as I opened the bathroom door.

Shrugging my shoulders I said, “There was a lot. I’ve been holding it for a long time.”

If she accepted the lie, I couldn’t say. She seemed satisfied though, and I never brought it up. There was privacy in the menstrual cycle, I suppose, and it was something that only those that had experienced seemed to be able to discourse.

Besides Lacey, Jennifer and Heather were also at my birthday party. They were my best friends at the time. We were a clique at school, nowhere near the status of the popular crowd, but also nowhere near the high-school socially damned. I met Jennifer on the gymnastics team, but since she was going to college in the fall, we wouldn't be around each other much after the summer, if at all. Lacey I can’t remember how I met her. We just fell in with each other and were friends after that. Heather was Jennifer’s friend, a little older than me, and it was through Jennifer that I met her.

The doctor told my mother once when I was fourteen or so that it was because I was so involved in sports and gymnastics that I had not yet had my period. He assured her of my normal development, and that I should have it any time. Any time became months, and months became quarters, and those became years. Mom would brush my hair as I looked at myself in the mirror and tell me that things were going to be okay and that all things came to each of us in their own time.

“Later,” she said to me, “you are going to be thankful that it has been so late in coming.”

How thankful can we be in the delay of normal?

My dad baked the cake that day and he said that it was one of his best. He baked professionally. Clarke's Confections the store was called, and some said it housed the best bunch of sweets that you could get east of the Mississippi. I don’t know about that, but I do know that if it was not for my athletic activities, I would have been a statistic. It was not that my dad pushed sweets on us, but he did not deter us either. It was a gigantic thing, the cake, looking like it belonged on a wedding table: three tiers, fondant and pink frosting everywhere on it. He made his own flowers and the ones that were on the cake were my favorites: lilacs and lilies.

“Thank God you do not like roses,” my dad would tell me every year he made a cake for my birthday. If roses were my favorite, he would have spent nights upon nights making them for me. As it was, he spent nights upon nights making this cake, and that was with me telling him that I didn't want anything fancy.

--JSC

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

J_S_C wrote:
Events of a person’s life can change in the space of a day or even a couple hours. With me, the utterance of a couple of words from a doctor after he had run a bunch of tests, had me in stirrups attempting to put a speculum inside of my untested vagina, and another spreading cold clear goo over my lower abdomen and probing it with an ultrasound, changed me forever. Those tests started after my sixteenth birthday.


The second sentence seems very long, is there any way to break this up?


J_S_C wrote:
Remembering turning fifteen to sixteen now is like trying to remember a dream. Images that appear with closed eyes are fleeting and more impressionistic than real. My best friend at the time, Lacey was constantly going to the bathroom. She said it was because she had drunk too much water the night before and during the day. Nodding, I knew that it was best to not embarrass her. Why she thought that having her period was a thing to be ashamed of I didn’t understand then, and don’t understand now.


'Remembering turning' is a little awkward for me. Can you try something like: Remembering when I turned sixteen is like trying to remember a dream.

These were the only two things that really bothered me. Other than that I was interested and am intrigued as to what is wrong with this girl.

Genre and age group: Adult drama/fiction

Buy it or Shelve it: I definitely want to read more but I'm not sure if I would buy it yet.

Grade: A-

LadyStarlea
50194 words so far Winner!

Ok I had posted my opening in the 200 words one but I have done quite extensive editing since then based on feedback from people and other things.

Also Really want to know if I should keep the posted scroll towards the end here or strike it out? I italicized the scroll so if is found easily. I also included a bit after the posted scroll as I wanted to show the scroll and a bit after to see what people think about pulling what the scroll says from the chapter which is telling what the MFC and SFC are reading instead of showing though what the MFC and SFC say or not. With the scroll pulled I am very close to the 1000 max though still a bit over with the editing of combining the before the scroll and after scroll I will most likely do if I strike the scroll out. Please let me know what you all think please.

FYI my book will have a Glossary I wanted to remain true to the concept of criers so I use what they use. "OYEZ. —used by a court or public crier to gain attention before a proclamation."
************************************************************************************************************
A dark haired young lady, with her hair in a warrior's tail, and her companion entered the dry goods shop. The shop was one of the open booths with actual wooden floor and walls, but no glass in the windows in the front, which led to the market square. Smaller bags of different flours, salt and sugars, as well as yeast, were on the shelves that lined the inside walls. As they looked over the shop, the shopkeeper was looking her and her strawberry blonde friend over, since he had not seen them in town before. They were dressed the same, but they were in casual clothes - not something that could be seen as a uniform. They had long sleeved white tunics belted over what looked like a long brown skirt. The pair walked over to him at his counter and smiled to him.

“Hello, sir. My name is Tracey and this is Jenny,” she introduced We would like to place an order for a number of the fifty pound bags of things but I don’t see any of them on the shelves only the twenty-five pound bags are there. Do you carry them or do we have to special order them?” the dark haired girl asked.

“Morning Ladies, I am Jon Thorison and I have the large bags out in the back. What can I do you for?” he asked, pulling out a clipboard with a form on it that he used for large orders. He looked up towards the front doorway as they heard the loud ringing of a large brass bell and the call of: "Oyez, Oyez, Oyez!" Jenny turned around and looked out of the shop, her pony tail swinging as her head turned. Tracey remained focused on Mr. Thorison, tough, so he returned to her and taking their order down.

Jenny saw a lanky young man with soft blonde curls, who she thought was close to their age, walking into the center of the market square. ‘Ah, that must be one of the king's criers wearing all that...well I wouldn't be caught wearing that elaborate red and gold jacket...well maybe the long black boots. But white breeches? Really? They will be a bitch to clean.’ She watched from the shop as he walked to the center of the square, ringing his bell. She wondered if he had arrived last night, as they had, or if he had just come in. If he had just arrived, he had timed things perfectly as it was now nearing lunch time, so the market was at its most crowded time of the day. As he strolled though the square with a large scroll and his bell, she heard him call out again: "Oyez, Oyez, Oyez!" People left the stalls to watch him. A handful of them followed him to the center, and she wondered what brought the king's crier today. It wasn’t that they never saw one. A crier would come a few times a year to make the king’s announcements, but everyday kingdom news were delivered by the traveling bard. So the crier meant the information was important, whatever it was, and everyone needed to hear it, like a new royal proclamation.

Jenny tapped Tracey as the crier got nearer the center of the square. She was in the middle of bartering over the dry goods they needed when she turned to her friend, who nodded her head to the crier to call her attention to him. When she saw the red coat, instead of blue, that the town crier wore she understood what Jenny was telling her. With a nod, she turned back to the merchant. "If you can see those things delivered to the academy's storage in the Bartleys’ Pub and Grub, it will be appreciated," she told him. He agreed and she turned to exit the shop, leaving to listen to the crier with her friend.

The crier climbed up on the widest part of the fountain in the center of town. It was designed to provide a small stage to allow any crier to stand above the crowd. The crier cleared his throat and projected his voice in the special way crier’s and bards have that while he wasn’t yelling, everyone in the market square even the farthest corner could hear him clearly as if he was next to them. “Oyez,Oyez! The King’s Rangers Wish All To Know The Trials Of Three Will Be Held On The thirty-third Day Of The Maiden. All Participants Must Be Registered By eight Bells. The Trial Events Starting At nine Bells. Come One Come All To Bear Witness As The Best In The Realm Prove Themselves Worthy To Be Called A Member Of The King’s Rangers. Additional Information Will Be Posted”

The Crier took a calming breath as he finished looking, over the small crowd about him. He stepped off the fountain and took the few steps to the announcement board, where he posted the Ranger’s scroll explaining the trials and the timing for everything. The scroll was like an unofficial test, as only those who could read would be able to get the information. As he walked away, a few people from the crowd moved to read the scroll which surprised him, as not many towns taught their youths to read nowadays, even though the Rangers preferred all their members to know how to read and write. He smiled as he left, it was always nice to see a town that strove to be better than the average.
Tracey and Jenny were among those who crossed the square to the board. They read over the posted scroll…

(The Ranger's trials of three is upon us once more.
The trial of threes has three rules and three games.
All participants are expected to perform the basics in each of the trials.
The three rules are simple:
Rule number one: Anyone under the age of 18 must be sponsored by a current Ranger.
If under 16, the sponsor must be the Captain of the Rangers with support from his second.
Rule number two: Cheating and lying are expressly forbidden, and basis of disqualification.
Rule number three, the rule of three: A participant cannot partake in the trials more than three times.
Registration begins at six bells on the thirty-third day of the maiden and ends at eight bells.
The first event will commence on the same day after nine bells have tolled.
In the following days, all participants must be present by six bells, with each event starting after seven bells have tolled.
Upon the fourth day, at exactly seven bells, the fifteen top warriors shall be announced.
All are welcome to bear witness.
So come, one and all, to the trial of three.)


As the girls read over the posted scroll, two older men drew near and seemed to read over their shoulders. The girls glanced back at them, their hands hovering defensively over their belts. The men also watched the two girls, wondering if they were fighters thinking of trying out, or if they were merely planning to watch the trials.

Tracey’s polished silver gaze cut towards Jenny, a glimmer of excitement dancing within, "Well, Jen, looks like it’s that time of year."

"Aye, I will need to get a sponsor though. You will be able to sign up no problems, Trace. We need....." Jen replied.

“Ya right, lady. These games are for men only. If you girls want to fight, go join the king's guards,” interrupted the man standing slightly behind Tracey rudely.

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

These are just some of my suggestions and my personal opinion. Please take it or leave it. A dark haired young lady, with her hair in a warrior's tail, (do we need to know this in the first sentence? and her companion entered the dry goods shop. The shop was one of the open booths with actual wooden floor and walls, but no glass in the windows in the front, which led to the market square. (This sentence makes no sence to me. I know what you are trying to say but  you are doing a lot of telling and no showing. Smaller bags of different flours, salt and sugars, as well as yeast, were on the shelves that lined the inside walls. As they looked over the shop, the shopkeeper was looking her and her strawberry blonde friend over, since he had not seen them in town before.The shopkeeper did not recognise either of the girls. They were dressed the same, but they were in casual clothes - not something that could be seen as a uniform. They were both dressed in similar white tunics and brown skirts, but they didn't appear to be in uniform. They had long sleeved white tunics belted over what looked like a long brown skirt. The pair walked over to him at his counter and smiled to him.  The girls walked to the counter and smiled at him. I'm really sorry but this entire first paragraph is just not working for me and I have no desire to read anything beyond this point. You have given me no reason to becoome attached to these girls. I know I said to you in a previous post that description is good, but I don't want to know about the shop and bags of flour, I want to know about the MC. I don't feel anything when I read this. “Hello, sir. My name is Tracey and this is Jenny,” she introduced introduced what? There are words missing here.  We would like to place an order for a number of the fifty pound bags of things but I don’t see any of them on the shelves only the twenty-five pound bags are there. Do you carry them or do we have to special order them?” the dark haired girl asked. This previous sentence does not sound like natural speech. It's awkward and disjointed. “Morning Ladies, I am Jon Thorison and I have the large bags out in the back. What can I do you for?” he asked, pulling out a clipboard with a form on it that he used for large orders. He looked up towards the front doorway as they heard the loud ringing of a large brass bell and the call of: "Oyez, Oyez, Oyez!" Jenny turned around and looked out of the shop, her pony tail swinging as her head turned. Jenny turned to look towards the sound. Tracey remained focused on Mr. Thorison, tough, (this word is inncorrect. It should be though) so he returned to her and taking their order down. and he continued to take their order. At this point I'm sorry but I am just not interested enough to continue reading. You are telling me what is happeneing rather than showing me, and I have formed no emotional attachment to any of the characters. Sorry if I sound harsh, and I know my own writing is far from perfect, but these were my initial thoughts. Genre and age group: Fantasy/YA Buy it or Shelve it: Shelve it Grade: D+/C-

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

Sorry, the strike through didn't work on my previous reply. Trying to fix it now.

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

These are just some of my suggestions and my personal opinion.

Ok, I am no good with the HTML code things so try this. Just follow my REPLACE WITH lines to see my train of thought.



A dark haired young lady, with her hair in a warrior's tail,

do we need to know this in the first sentence?

and her companion entered the dry goods shop. The shop was one of the open booths with actual wooden floor and walls, but no glass in the windows in the front, which led to the market square.

This sentence makes no sence to me. I know what you are trying to say but you are doing a lot of telling and no showing.

Smaller bags of different flours, salt and sugars, as well as yeast, were on the shelves that lined the inside walls.

DELETE: As they looked over the shop, the shopkeeper was looking her and her strawberry blonde friend over, since he had not seen them in town before.

REPLACE WITH: The shopkeeper did not recognise either of the girls.

DELETE: They were dressed the same, but they were in casual clothes - not something that could be seen as a uniform.

REPLACE WITH: They were both dressed in similar white tunics and brown skirts, but they didn't appear to be in uniform.

DELETE: They had long sleeved white tunics belted over what looked like a long brown skirt. The pair walked over to him at his counter and smiled to him.

REPLACE WITH: The girls walked to the counter and smiled at him.



I'm really sorry but this entire first paragraph is just not working for me and I have no desire to read anything beyond this point. You have given me no reason to become attached to these girls. I know I said to you in a previous post that description is good, but I don't want to know about the shop and bags of flour, I want to know about the MC. I don't feel anything when I read this.



“Hello, sir. My name is Tracey and this is Jenny,” she introduced introduced what? There are words missing here. We would like to place an order for a number of the fifty pound bags of things but I don’t see any of them on the shelves only the twenty-five pound bags are there. Do you carry them or do we have to special order them?” the dark haired girl asked.

The previous sentence does not sound like natural speech. It's awkward and disjointed.

“Morning Ladies, I am Jon Thorison and I have the large bags out in the back. What can I do you for?” he asked, pulling out a clipboard with a form on it that he used for large orders. He looked up towards the front doorway as they heard the loud ringing of a large brass bell and the call of: "Oyez, Oyez, Oyez!"

DELETE:Jenny turned around and looked out of the shop, her pony tail swinging as her head turned.

REPLACE WITH:Jenny turned to look towards the sound.

DELETE:Tracey remained focused on Mr. Thorison, tough, (this word is inncorrect. It should be though) so he returned to her and taking their order down.

REPLACE WITH:Tracey remained focused on Mr. Thorison, and he continued to take their order.



At this point I'm sorry but I am just not interested enough to continue reading. You are telling me what is happeneing rather than showing me, and I have formed no emotional attachment to any of the characters. Sorry if I sound harsh, and I know my own writing is far from perfect, but these were my initial thoughts.

Genre and age group: Fantasy/YA

Buy it or Shelve it: Shelve it

Grade: D+/C-

LadyStarlea
50194 words so far Winner!

No you are right. Thank you. I guess in my effort to add in more description I went back to telling instead of showing. I reworked it. Course now it is longer but please re-review. Still need to know if I should strike the scroll which is once more in italics or not?
***********************************************************************************************************************

Jon Thorison looked up as two young ladies he had not seen before entered his dry goods shop. He wondered who they were. They were similar in dress both wearing long sleeve white tunics belted over brown skirts...no correct that those are a pair of skirt pants that the female off duty guards normally wear. Though they are too young to be guards or are they accepting them younger now, he wondered. No, if there were new town guards he would know of them. He watched as they walked about his shop looking at the small twenty-five pounds of four and rice and the ten pound bags of salt and sugar he had out on the shelves. His expert eyes took in every detail of these two young ladies. Both were of average height though the darker haired one was slightly taller then her strawberry blonde friend. Though they were young they did walk in a way a practiced warrior would. Their hands relaxed yet still hovering near their pouches to protect what is in them.

When Tracey and Jenny had walked into the shop the first thing they noticed was the wooden floor they had stepped up on. Not many shops in the market had taken the intuitive in putting in floors just going with the packed dirt underneath that was common now-a-days. Tracey had looked up her silvery steal eyes taken in how the shop keeper watched them. She knew Jenny was seen as being pretty with her strawberry blonde curls she wore up in a pony tail but really neither of them had time to think of boys. She turned to shelves that lined the wall, Jenny already picking up and looking at a few of the bags of goods there. Tracey picked one of the bags of salt looking at the ten pound bag wondering if he had bigger bags of this stuff.

"The flour and rice is only twenty-five pounds here" Jenny told her. Tracey nodded taking in the information with what she saw of the small ten pound bags of the salt and sugar. The bags were too small for how much they wanted. She will have to see if he can get the things in bigger bags.

Her dark hair swung some as she turned towards Jon even though she had it tied back in a warrior tail he noticed. He watched as her blonde friend also joined her as they walked over to him at his counter and smiled to him. “Hello, sir. My name is Tracey and this is Jenny,” she introduced herself and her friend to him. "We were wondering if you carried your dry goods in fifty pound bags or will we need to special order the fifty pound bags?”

“Morning Ladies," he greeted them kindly "I am Jon Thorison and I have the fifty pounders out in the back. So, what can I do for you pretty ladies?” he asked, pulling out a clipboard with a form on it that he used for large orders. He looked towards the doorway at the sound of loud ringing coming from the square. It sounded like the sound from a large brass bell. The call of: "Oyez, Oyez, Oyez!" confirmed what he thought.

Jenny turned around at the sound walking to pear out of the doorway. Her pony tail swinging as her head turned. Tracey had only made a glance to towards the square at the sound. Seeing Jenny going to investigate she turned back to their task of placing their order with Mr Thorison.

Jenny saw a lanky young man with soft blonde curls, who she thought was close to their age, walking into the center of the market square. She cringed at seeing how he was dress. She would never be caught wearing such loud, bright clothing. His jacket was an elaborate red and gold number that screamed money to her. His white breeches made her cringe even more as thoughts of how they had to be a bitch to clean went though her head. The only thing she saw as being even practical was his long black boots. Now those I might wear. She watched from the shop as he walked to the center of the square, ringing his bell. She wondered if he had arrived last night, as they had, or if he had just come in. If he had just arrived, he had timed things perfectly as it was now nearing lunch time, so the market was at its most crowded time of the day.

As he strolled though the square with a large scroll and his bell, she heard him call out again: "Oyez, Oyez, Oyez!" People started to leave their stalls to watch him. A handful of them followed him to the center, and she wondered what brought a king's crier to their trade town today. It wasn’t that a king's crier was never seen outside the capital. It is just that usually it was only a yearly thing during the the time of the mother they usually came she thought. That was the time of year to make the king’s announcements, but everyday kingdom news were delivered by the traveling bard. So the crier meant the information was important, whatever it was, and everyone needed to hear it, like a new royal proclamation.

Jenny walked back over to Tracey and Mr Thorison. She tapped her on the shoulder getting her attention. She was in the middle of bartering over the dry goods they needed when she turned to her friend, who nodded her head to the crier, who was crossing tot he cent of the square. When she saw the red coat, instead of the blue, that the town criers wore she understood what Jenny was telling her. With a nod, she turned back to the merchant. "If you can see those things delivered to the academy's storage in the Bartleys’ Pub and Grub, it will be appreciated," she told him.

"Not a problem Miss Tracey. My nephew can drive it on over in a bit." He agreed

She smiled kindly at him as she passed the agreed on amount for the order to him before she turned walking to the exit of the shop with her friend. Walking out of the shop they saw the crier climbed up on the widest part of the fountain, that seemed like a mini stage in the center of town.

They watched and listened as the crier cleared his throat and projected his voice in the special way criers’ and bards’ have that while he wasn’t yelling, everyone in the market square even the farthest corner could hear him clearly as if he was next to them. “Oyez,Oyez! The King’s Rangers Wish All To Know The Trials Of Three Will Be Held On The thirty-third Day Of The Maiden. All Participants Must Be Registered By eight Bells. The Trial Events Starting At nine Bells. Come One Come All To Bear Witness As The Best In The Realm Prove Themselves Worthy To Be Called A Member Of The King’s Rangers. Additional Information Will Be Posted”

They watched as the Crier took a calming breath at the end of his announcement. As he stepped off the fountain and took the few steps towards the announcement board. Tracey and Jenny made their way towards him and the board where he was posting the Ranger’s scroll he had mentioned. Tracey wondered if the scroll was like an unofficial test, as only those who could read would be able to get the information. Not many towns taught their youths to read nowadays, though the academy they went too did. But then as they were taught, if you want to one day work up into a leadership position in any arm force you need to know how to read and write.

(The Ranger's trials of three is upon us once more.
The trial of threes has three rules and three games.
All participants are expected to perform the basics in each of the trials.
The three rules are simple:
Rule number one: Anyone under the age of 18 must be sponsored by a current Ranger.
If under 16, the sponsor must be the Captain of the Rangers with support from his second.
Rule number two: Cheating and lying are expressly forbidden, and basis of disqualification.
Rule number three, the rule of three: A participant cannot partake in the trials more than three times.
Registration begins at six bells on the thirty-third day of the maiden and ends at eight bells.
The first event will commence on the same day after nine bells have tolled.
In the following days, all participants must be present by six bells, with each event starting after seven bells have tolled.
Upon the fourth day, at exactly seven bells, the fifteen top warriors shall be announced.
All are welcome to bear witness.
So come, one and all, to the trial of three.)


As the girls read over the posted scroll, two older men drew near and seemed to read over their shoulders. The girls glanced back at them, their hands hovering defensively over their pouches.

The men also watched the two girls, wondering if they were fighters thinking of trying out, or if they were merely planning to watch the trials.

Tracey’s polished silver gaze cut towards Jenny, a glimmer of excitement dancing within, "Well, Jen, looks like it’s that time of year."

"Aye, I will need to get a sponsor though. You will be able to sign up no problems, Trace. We need....." Jen replied.

“Ya right, lady. These games are for men only. If you girls want to fight, go join the king's guards,” interrupted the man standing slightly behind Tracey rudely.

J_S_C
100145 words so far Winner!

To answer the question that you have posited twice concerning the scroll, you can keep it. It does not hinder the story.

The larger problem is the writing. it is too wordy. I am not opposed to prose. The prose that you present to us feels clunky and forced, and this is the main detractor to reading your sample. To illustrate what I am trying to say, let's look at the first couple of lines:

Jon Thorison looked up as two young ladies he had not seen before entered his dry goods shop. He wondered who they were. They were similar in dress both wearing long sleeve white tunics belted over brown skirts...no correct that those are a pair of skirt pants that the female off duty guards normally wear.

The first sentence can be clipped to "Jon Thorison looed up as two unfamilliar young ladies entered his shop." Is it necessary to know that it is a dry good shop? No, you show us it is a dry good shop by what they are browsing for in the same paragraph.

You can cut out the "They were similar in dress," and just change the sentence to "They wore long sleeve white tunics belted over brown skirts."

Then you add more redundant prose that I cannot tell if it is the narrator making a mistake, or Jon making a mistake in observation. I would personally cut out the "no correct that" segment, and make single accurate desciptor:

"They wore long sleeve white tunics belted over brown skirt pants popular with off duty female guards."

What I have tried to show you is the problem I have with the sample. I can't say it's bad; but I can't say it's good either. I will say that it has potential, but it is gonna take some work. Tighten the prose, polish it like one would the silver.

Genre: Fantasy
Grade: C
Would I pick it up or put it down: Currently, put it down.


--JSC

.

LadyStarlea
50194 words so far Winner!

hmm okay will work on it again. though the mistake is in Jon's head as he looks them over and it is there to show that they can be mistaken for skirts quite easily unless looked at closely when they walk. This is to searve two purposes one it shows how good Jon is at catching small details and it shows how most would think they were just wearing skirts.

J_S_C
100145 words so far Winner!

Again, I stand by my critique by saying that in him noticing that they they were, indeed, skirt pants because you just said that they can easily be mistaken for skirts. My suggestion both eliminates unneeded prose and shows us that he is observant. Two birds, one stone.

LadyStarlea
50194 words so far Winner!

Oh I did not mean I was not taking your advice. I did reword it all. Even the parts on the skirt pants. Just in a different way. Still working on it and will post it when done for a re-critique

EmmaMayfield
50060 words so far Winner!

Chapter One


Brooke watched the nervous movements that Raine made from across the room, along with the ten other young girls as they waited. The boys were in the next room over, Brooke knew, having talked to one in the hall using hand signals.
“Number seventy-two and seventy-five!” A loud voice bellowed from the other side of the huge white door.

Raine cast a terrified glance at Brooke as one of the ‘nurses’ grabbed her hand and took her beyond the white door, and yet another grabbed Brooke as she struggled to break free, anything to get out of the mess she was in.

“You,” One of the women said with a glance over Raine. “Follow me.” She said with a smirk as she took a folder from the filing cabinet and forced Raine along the winding corridor, leaving Brooke alone as another woman approached.

“And you are?” She asked with a disgusted tone, turning toward the filing cabinet to look for her file.
“Number seventy-five.” Brooke said, looking down at the floor.

“Brooke Whitfield, aged 15, and you have been in this facility for 11 years, correct?” The woman asked in a business-like tone that made Brooke keep looking at the floor as the guard behind her held her cuffed arms.

All Brooke could do was nod. The woman turned toward the guard and handed him a file.

“She goes into room 21, further down the hall, you know where it is.” The woman said with a glance of disgust at Brooke.

The guard nodded as he whisked her down the corridor, going into a room which had another door, which he opened with a smirk.

“Number sixty-seven, you come with me.” The guard said, shoving Brooke into the room as he grabbed the other girl and took her out, leaving Brooke in her cuffs, tightening them before leaving.

The guard took the girl into the room outside the door and strapped her onto a table, put a piece of tape over her mouth, and motioned for the pair standing in the doorway to come to the table.

“The subject is ready.” He said, handing a folder to one of the scientists from the cabinet against the wall, which held numerous documents and files of sorts that many had never seen before.

“Ah, how perfect. Elizabeth Harris, aged 16, known as Lizzie to some girls, known to us as an elaborate escape artist. What procedure did the director wish for us to perform today?” The woman asked, looking up from the folder at the other man.

“Procedure 49. The Director said three of the other subjects had miscarried their children, and the Director wishes for us to stay on target growth.” The other scientist said with a nod.

From the room Brooke was in, she heard everything perfectly. She knew the girl. It was Lizzie.

Suddenly loud and muffled screams filled the room as the whirring of tools started, and then all fell silent.

-----

Raine struggled as she was forced onto a table and tied down. The whirring of tools and bleeping of monitors filled the air. Then another person clamped a mask tightly onto her face, filling it with sweet-smelling gas, and watched her with a sharp look on his skunk-like face. But soon the gas turned into a different kind of gas, as Raine struggled and shook with terror, as she started to scream at the top of her lungs, "NO! HELP ME SOMEBODY PLEASE!!!!"She screamed as her body convulsed and shook wildly, her arms scratching frantically at the restraints, and then she grew silent as she fell into a deep sleep.

The man next to her stood up and threw the syringe away into a bucket.

"My work here is done." He said, glancing at the woman in the corner.

"Good." She said, smirking at him with a nod. "Grandmother would have been pleased."

The man turned and walked out the door with a stamp of his foot in disgust. "Grandmother was an evil and disgusting woman. She did what she did in hatred of that group of people that escaped and freed her prisoners. But I'm going to change that." He whispered fiercely as he cast one more glance at the victim through the open door.

Determined, he walked off, knowing he could be a part of this no longer.

-----

Brooke shuddered as she thought of what was happening just outside her door, the pure horror of the screams she had heard sending chills up her spine.

Am I next? Brooke wondered, fear and dread entering her mind, the screams still echoing in her mind.

The door opened, the bright light filling the previously dark room. “Come on out now, hurry!” A deep and gruff voice ordered.

That’s when Brooke’s heart sank. She knew that there would be no escape. Her fate was sealed.

EmmaMayfield
50060 words so far Winner!

^{REVISED VERSION}^

Wilson3sd
12338 words so far

I am a fool, I posted the critique as its own post instead of as a reply. Please see below for your critique.

LadyStarlea
50194 words so far Winner!

EmmaMayfield wrote:
Chapter One


Brooke watched the nervous movements that Raine made from across the room, along with the ten other young girls as they waited. The boys were in the next room over, Brooke knew, having talked to one in the hall using hand signals.
“Number seventy-two and seventy-five!” A loud voice bellowed from the other side of the huge white door.

Raine cast a terrified glance at Brooke as one of the ‘nurses’ grabbed her hand and took her beyond the white door, and yet another grabbed Brooke as she struggled to break free, anything to get out of the mess she was in.

“You,” One of the women said with a glance over Raine. “Follow me.” She said with a smirk as she took a folder from the filing cabinet and forced Raine along the winding corridor, leaving Brooke alone as another woman approached.



I said it before. these two paragraphs make no sense. You are missing a lot of what happens here. If Raine is already gone how can Brooke hear what the woman says? Combine them into one or clarify what is missing -> (Raine cast a terrified glance at Brooke as one of the ‘nurses’ grabbed her hand. “You,” the women said with a glance down at Raine. “Follow me.” She said with a smirk a folder in her other hand as she forced Raine down the corridor and though the white door at the end. Another woman grabs Brooke, she doesn't like this at all and starts to struggle to break free of the woman's iron grip.)

Here you need to talk about what happens to Brooke as she struggles! What happens to her? does the nurse call the guards? is she subdued? drugged? bound? beaten? What happens to her here? You need to add some action and emotion in here to make the reader feel something for Brooke. I stopped reading at this point and just skimmed over the rest.

EmmaMayfield wrote:
“And you are?” She asked with a disgusted tone, turning toward the filing cabinet to look for her file.
“Number seventy-five.” Brooke said, looking down at the floor.

“Brooke Whitfield, aged 15, and you have been in this facility for 11 years, correct?” The woman asked in a business-like tone that made Brooke keep looking at the floor as the guard behind her held her cuffed arms.

All Brooke could do was nod. The woman turned toward the guard and handed him a file.

“She goes into room 21, further down the hall, you know where it is.” The woman said with a glance of disgust at Brooke.

The guard nodded as he whisked her down the corridor, going into a room which had another door, which he opened with a smirk.

“Number sixty-seven, you come with me.” The guard said, shoving Brooke into the room as he grabbed the other girl and took her out, leaving Brooke in her cuffs, tightening them before leaving.

The guard took the girl into the room outside the door and strapped her onto a table, put a piece of tape over her mouth, and motioned for the pair standing in the doorway to come to the table.

“The subject is ready.” He said, handing a folder to one of the scientists from the cabinet against the wall, which held numerous documents and files of sorts that many had never seen before.

“Ah, how perfect. Elizabeth Harris, aged 16, known as Lizzie to some girls, known to us as an elaborate escape artist. What procedure did the director wish for us to perform today?” The woman asked, looking up from the folder at the other man.

“Procedure 49. The Director said three of the other subjects had miscarried their children, and the Director wishes for us to stay on target growth.” The other scientist said with a nod.

From the room Brooke was in, she heard everything perfectly. She knew the girl. It was Lizzie.

Suddenly loud and muffled screams filled the room as the whirring of tools started, and then all fell silent.

-----

Raine struggled as she was forced onto a table and tied down. The whirring of tools and bleeping of monitors filled the air. Then another person clamped a mask tightly onto her face, filling it with sweet-smelling gas, and watched her with a sharp look on his skunk-like face. But soon the gas turned into a different kind of gas, as Raine struggled and shook with terror, as she started to scream at the top of her lungs, "NO! HELP ME SOMEBODY PLEASE!!!!"She screamed as her body convulsed and shook wildly, her arms scratching frantically at the restraints, and then she grew silent as she fell into a deep sleep.

The man next to her stood up and threw the syringe away into a bucket.

Syringe? what syringe? when did a syringe come into this? You seem to skip over much of what is happening. This whole thing seems to have no emotions like you are telling it dispassionately, like you do not care at all about any of what is going on so why should a reader care?

EmmaMayfield wrote:
"My work here is done." He said, glancing at the woman in the corner.

"Good." She said, smirking at him with a nod. "Grandmother would have been pleased."

The man turned and walked out the door with a stamp of his foot in disgust. "Grandmother was an evil and disgusting woman. She did what she did in hatred of that group of people that escaped and freed her prisoners. But I'm going to change that." He whispered fiercely as he cast one more glance at the victim through the open door.

Determined, he walked off, knowing he could be a part of this no longer.

-----

Brooke shuddered as she thought of what was happening just outside her door, the pure horror of the screams she had heard sending chills up her spine.

Am I next? Brooke wondered, fear and dread entering her mind, the screams still echoing in her mind.

The door opened, the bright light filling the previously dark room. “Come on out now, hurry!” A deep and gruff voice ordered.

That’s when Brooke’s heart sank. She knew that there would be no escape. Her fate was sealed.



this is good can be better. It has emotion and action. need to reword the second paragraph or sentence here sounds off try. -> (Brooke wondered as fear and dread filled her, the screams echoing over and over in her mind.) might want to add in the third line how the sudden light blinded her. Just some thoughts.

2. Genre and age group: fantasy/sci-fi even though the MCs ages should make this be middle school thinking more YA

3. Shelve it or buy it: for now Shelve it. Everything still has an overall feeling of being cold and unfeeling and I could not feel myself getting pulled into the story much.

4. Score (either letter A, B, C, D, or out of 100): C+/B- getting better you did have some parts that had some feeling. You need to bring more action into some of it and more overall feelings. You can do better I feel

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

I quite enjoyed reading this and would love to read more. As you have received two other critiques I won't go into too much detail, but I'd like to address some basic punctuation issues.

Dialogue punctuation: When someone is speaking, the he said or she said is still part of the sentence, so you need to use a comma instead of a period.

You have this:
"My work here is done." He said, glancing at the woman in the corner.
and
"Good." She said, smirking at him with a nod. "Grandmother would have been pleased."


It should be:
"My work here is done," he said, glancing at the woman in the corner.
and
"Good," she said, smirking at him with a nod. "Grandmother would have been pleased."


The he/she said and he/she asked etc should always be lower case, even after question marks, exclamation marks etc.

In sentences where the conversation continues after the dialogue tag, you should use commas and lower case. For example:

You have this:
“You,” One of the women said with a glance over Raine. “Follow me.” She said with a smirk...

It should be:
“You,” one of the women said with a glance over Raine, “follow me,” she said with a smirk... (I actually think this paragraph needs work)

Try this:
“You,” one of the women said, glancing at Raine, “follow me.” She smirked as she took a folder from the filing cabinet. Forcing Raine along the winding corridor, Brooke was left alone as another woman approached.


Overall I enjoyed the story, and with some more tidying up I think it has lots of potential.

Genre: Fantasy or Sci-fi and YA

Grade: C+/B- because of the basic punctuation and grammar errors.

Wilson3sd
12338 words so far

There have been some very good critiques on this thread, I hope this helps! So, here we go! (Of course, YMMV)

Chapter One


Brooke watched the nervous movements that Raine made from across the room, "Brooke watched Raine's nervous movements from across the room." seems to flow a bit better. along with the ten other young girls as they waited. Are the other girls fidgeting or are they also watching Raine? The boys were in the next room over, Brooke knew, having talked to one in the hall using hand signals. This sentence is good but may work as "Brooke knew the boys were in the next room over, having talked to one in the hall earlier with hand signals."
“Numbers seventy-two and seventy-five!” A loud voice bellowed from the other side of the huge white door.

Raine cast a terrified glance at Brooke as one of the ‘nurses’ grabbed her hand and took her beyond the white door,period, I'd say cut "and yet" so that your next sentence could begin with "another" and yet another terrified glance or 'nurse'grabbed Brooke as she struggled to break free,Period here also. This way you can give more weight to Brooke's willingness to do anything to break free. anything to get out of the mess she was in.

“You,” OneI don't believe you need to capitalize one. of the women said with a glance over Raine. “Follow me.” SheSee above said with a smirk as she took a folder from the filing cabinet and forced Raine along the winding corridor, leaving Brooke alone as another woman approached. This sentence momentarily made me rethink this as written from Brooke's POV. Nothing serious, just a thought.

“And you are?” She asked with a disgusted tone, With disgust in her voice, the nurse asked "And you are?" turning toward the filing cabinet to look for her file.
“Number seventy-five.” Brooke said, looking down at the floor. Looking at the floor, Brooke replied "Number seventy five."

“Brooke Whitfield, aged 15, and you have been in this facility for 11 years, correct?” The woman asked in a business-like tone that made Brooke keep that kept Brooke looking at the floor as the guard behind her held her cuffed arms. Brooke's arms or is the guard holding her own, cuffed, arms?

All Brooke could do was nod. The woman turned toward the guard and handed him a file.

“She goes into room 21, further down the hall, you know where it is.” The woman said with a glance of disgust at Brooke. With as much disgust and contempt as you seem to be giving these nurses and guards, it seems as if they wouldn't waste as many words as they do on the girls. A curt response, or a clipped order would convey the underlying bias much better.

The guard nodded as he whisked To me, 'whisked' implies a whimsical jaunt, maybe "hustled" or "shuttled" her down the corridor, going into a room which had another door, which he opened with a smirk. From "going" He placed her in a room with a second door, which he opened with a smirk.

“Number sixty-seven, you come with me.” The guard said, shoving Brooke into the room as he grabbed the other girl and took her out, leaving Brooke in her cuffs, tightening them before leaving. Ok, in conjunction with the paragraph above, you have the guard placing Brooke in a room with a second door which he opens. The way this next paragraph read to me was that the girl and the room Brooke was shoved into were the initial room. I understand that, instead of what I think it is, the action is the guard removing the girl from the second room and placing Brooke there. It just didn't seem to read correctly.

The guard took the girl into the room outside the door and strapped her onto a table, put a piece of tape over her mouth, and motioned for the pair standing in the doorway to come to the table. When did the table get in the anteroom? Where did the people come from?

“The subject is ready.” He said, handing a folder to one of the scientists from the cabinet against the wall, which held numerous documents and files of sorts that many had never seen before.

“Ah, how perfect. Elizabeth Harris, aged 16, known as Lizzie to some girls, known to us as an elaborate escape artist. What procedure did the director wish for us to perform today?” The woman asked, looking up from the folder at the other man.

“Procedure 49. The Director said three of the other subjects had miscarried their children, and the Director wishes for us to stay on target growth.” The other scientist said with a nod.

From the room Brooke was in, she heard everything perfectly. She knew the girl. It was Lizzie. Moving this sentence before the preceding two paragraphs would make it more clear as to the shift between Brooke's POV and the narration. Then you get Brooke's knowledge and a reaction when the doctor says "known as Lizzie."

Suddenly loud and muffled screams filled the room as the whirring of tools started, and then all fell silent. Did they just start and stop? How long did Brooke have to listen to the sounds?

-----

Raine struggled as she was forced onto a table and tied down. The whirring of tools and bleeping of monitors filled the air. Then another person clamped a mask tightly onto her face, filling it with sweet-smelling gas, and watched her with a sharp look on his skunk-like face. A man with a skunk-like face clamped a mask on her and filled it with sweet smelling gas. He watched her with a sharp look as the odor changed. Raine shook with terror and fought against her restraints. She began to scream at the top of her lungs. "NO! HELP ME SOMEBODY PLEASE!" The screamng continued as she convulsed, flailing and scratching at the restraints. But soon the gas turned into a different kind of gas, as Raine struggled and shook with terror, as she started to scream at the top of her lungs, "NO! HELP ME SOMEBODY PLEASE!!!!"She screamed as her body convulsed and shook wildly, her arms scratching frantically at the restraints, and then she grew silent as she fell into a deep sleep.

The man next to her stood up and threw the syringe away into a bucket. I think it would be "a syringe." This is the first one that the reader has seen or heard about, nor do we have any introduction that this man was there. (Unless it is the man with the skunk-like face.)

"My work here is done." He said, glancing at the woman in the corner.

"Good." She said, smirking at him with a nod. "Grandmother would have been pleased."

The man turned and walked out the door with a stamp of his foot in disgust.This made me think he was tap dancing out of the door disgustedly. Sorry, just a funny image the way it read. "Grandmother was an evil and disgusting woman. She did what she did in hatred of that group of people"in hatred of those that escaped" that escaped and freed her prisoners. But I'm going to change that." He whispered fiercely as he cast one more glance at the victim through the open door.Why would he tell his coworker what he was going to do? Or is that phrase meant to be quietly to himself?

Determined, he walked off, knowing he could be a part of this no longer.

-----

Brooke shuddered as she thought of what was happening just outside her door, the pure horror of the screams she had heard sending chills up her spine.

Am I next? Brooke wondered, fear and dread entering her mind, the screams still echoing in her mind.

The door opened, the bright light filling the previously dark room. “Come on out now, hurry!” A deep and gruff voice ordered.

That’s when Brooke’s heart sank. She knew that there would be no escape. Her fate was sealed.

Has the room been dark the whole time? Brooke should have reacted to it. You also don't need a "the," bright light works.

Genre: Dystopian future
Grade: High B/Low A 88-92
Buy or Put back? I'd probably buy, I'd like to see where it was headed.

The story is there, I enjoyed it. :)

ohthatmomagain
59193 words so far Winner!

Prologue
He bent down to the ground, lungs burning from exhaustion and terror.
This couldn’t be happening. Not now. Not after everything.
His mind raced. No time could be wasted.
He knew if he didn’t do something quick, she would die.
With shaking fingers, Asher moved the ginger hair stuck to the girl’s face. He couldn’t lose her—not this girl he had grown to care about despite his best efforts to avoid it. Her lifeless body screamed to him for help which he tried but failed to give. He had done everything he knew to do, and it wasn’t good enough.
Death crept in to take her away from him.
He fell back on the ground in a sitting position, not taking his eyes away from her. He had to do something. There had to be a way.
With all other options depleted, Asher did something he hadn’t done since he was a small boy. He prayed.





Chapter 1
“Are we there yet?”
“Seriously,” David Andrews laughed from the driver’s seat of the 15-seater van. “Are we two?”
“Apparently Sid is,” he heard a male voice, most likely Sid’s unexpected guest Asher, coming from behind him. David smiled and kept his eyes on the road. Their destination inched closer as the van traveled through the chilly early morning.
David had been driving ever since they had left Grant, Georgia around ten o’clock the night before. Susan Drake, the van’s shotgun rider, had offered several times to drive while he slept, but David had declined each one. Truth be told, he was too excited to sleep. The trip represented the first of its kind at Grant Gospel Church, and its new youth program.
Grant, Georgia’s newest red light at Willow Avenue and Jefferson allowed it to avoid the distinction of being called a “One Light Town”… but just barely. The town’s claim to fame consisted of a former U.S. congressman as a native son, and the smallest ‘Super Wal-mart’ on the planet. Four churches called Grant home, Grant Gospel claimed the biggest spot with fifty-five on the membership roll. Nine of them were in the church van with David cruising toward a weekend of hiking and fun in the Great Smokey Mountains National Park.
David checked the rearview mirror again, smiling at the motley crew behind him. Only a few lights, mostly cellphones and eReaders, lit up the darkness. From the relative quietness and occasional snore, he imagined that most of the teens were sleeping. He couldn’t tell exactly who remained awake, but he had a pretty good idea. He figured he could guess at least one of them right off. A girl named Ruth.
***********
Ruth Harker’s mind was not on sleep. Truth be told, her overly active brain revolved mostly around getting away from home at least for a little while. She had anticipated the hiking trip ever since Mr. Andrews had mentioned it two months before during youth service. She loved the outdoors, and even though the Smokey’s were only an eight hour drive away, she hadn’t been in years. Returning to the mountains at some point in time had been a dream of hers for a while, but this year especially appealed to her.
She needed a vacation away from home, but she found that the farther she got from Georgia, the more guilt she felt. The guilt kept her awake, idly flipping through books on her eReader, not really reading any of them.
At around six a.m., Ruth could see the first glimpses of mountains silhouetted against the early morning sunrise. The dull pink and radiant orange sky around the peaks stood out in stark contrast to the dark mountains. A few red whisps, the color of Ruth’s curly long hair, began filling the sky as well.
Ruth closed her eyes and tried to remember the last time she had seen that sunrise. Immediately, she remembered the day nine years ago it like it was yesterday. Her, her mom, and her dad had all gone on vacation in Gatlinburg, a town right under the mountain. Her dad had waken her up early their last night there to show her the sunrise from their hotel room balcony. To her seven year old eyes, it was magical. Her sixteen year old eyes saw beauty as well but not like before; not like when she had witnessed it with her father.
Ruth shook her head, trying to get those once happy now painful memories out of her brain. She looked over to her left to check on her friend, Carly. Sure enough, the brown haired beauty still snored away, a fact Ruth knew would mortify her. Ruth had no doubts that someone would erroneously think it would be a great idea to aggravate Carly about her loud sleeping habits, and that someone would be named Sid.
******************
“Almost there,” David said to the insomniac few like himself. As the mountains got closer and closer, the anxiety grew inside of him. Had he made the right decision bringing the kids that far away from home? Did they bring everything they needed? Had they needed more chaperones? What would he do if he saw a bear? And had God picked the right person to lead this group that meant so much to him?
As all of the thoughts circled his mind, a bright light coming from the cab made him wince. Someone, and he could probably guess who, had turned on one of the overhead lights. “So, that means we can return to the land of the living, right,” the familiar voice of Sid asked.
“Yes. Yes, you can. Although, your fellow traveling companions might want to bless you out, and not in the most Christian of ways, for blinding them at this unpleasant hour.” David said with a smile.
He caught Sid’s shrug in the rearview. “They’ll get over it, brother,” Sid said, stretching his arms over his head and adjusting his staple, his never-left-behind red cap.
“Wouldn’t be too sure of that,” David laughed under his breath.

Harlow
51784 words so far Winner!

It seems as though your prologue and first chapter start off quite slow. Despite the young woman being passed out and Asher being horrified about it, there isn't much else to pull me in. It basically boils down to a rather slow-paced beginning, with a very rural town. While that is a promising beginning if your story is a thriller, I do hope that it picks up quickly.

The writing itself is fine. It's descriptive without being pretentious, which I appreciate. The plot just needs something to get my attention, though.

GRADE: B- (80/100)
Buy or Shelve: Actually, turn the page to see if this improved.
Genre: Thriller of some sort.

Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

Prologue: I don't have much to say on this. Really, it is quite excellent, and nothing particular jumps out at me for changing.

Chapter One: First off, the scene switches (that's what they are, right?) bother me. I don't like it in movies and it's a complete deal breaker for me in books. Second, you only need to mention the state once. It does not matter what state they are in unless it becomes important later. Third, you ought make some mention of what the time is. I was picturing an early morning drive until you made mention of the lights in darkness. Also the comma between eReaders and lit is superfluous. Last but not least, you started a sentence with and. This bothers me, as it is grammatically incorrect.

Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

Almost forgot.

Grade: C+
Buy or shelve: Shelve.
Genre: Spiritual/Thriller

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

I haven't read the excerpt ohthatmomagain posted above, but I thought I should say this:

While beginning sentences with conjunctions is technically grammatically incorrect, it is not wrong. I am also not a fan or starting sentences with and or but, but they quite often work, and they definitely have their place. As long as it is not done too frequently, it is perfectly ok.

Have a look at these links:

http://www.getitwriteonline.com/archive/032601StartSentAndBut.htm
http://michelle-strozykowski.suite101.com/grammar-starting-a-sentence-with-or-and-or-but-a74404

ohthatmomagain
59193 words so far Winner!

It is a good point. I tend to write like I speak, and I tend to speak like that.

Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

-sigh-

Very well then.

Harlow
51784 words so far Winner!

(This will be over 1K words. The chapter itself is quite long)

Every city has the human element. New York, being the largest city, has more than most. Wealth and poverty, beauty and ugliness, love and hate – all of these existed hand in hand. In a society where such extremes of love and hate flourished, there was always more money made in trying to destroy enemies than in re-igniting the fires of love. Thus, hitmen roamed all over the city; from shadowy corners that parents often warned their teenage daughters about, to the bright lights of Manhattan. Hitmen were pervasive around New York, and practically ran the city. Different hitmen were better than others, and the better ones commanded higher prices. Being a hired gun was a lucrative industry, and one that Everett Belvidere had lucked out on.

Among streets filled with cars, a single black Porsche stood out amongst the yellow cabs and simpler vehicles. Behind its wheel was Everett Belvidere, who was one of those highly-paid hitmen. A normal person would have thought it impossible to maneuver through this bumper-to-bumper traffic that was endemic of New York streets. Everett, however, had no problem with it, as he recklessly weaved in and out of traffic, cutting people off and watching without a care as cabbies and delivery men shouted, swore and shook their fists at him. Time was money. Somewhere in this city, there was money to be made, and Everett never turned down the opportunity to kill a man and reap a handsome amount for his services.

Today’s job brought him to streets similar to where he lived. Streets with lower-income residences where, unlike in his own neighborhood, the residents often tended to be mired in poverty. There were bodegas on almost every corner and even small chapels inside a few of the buildings. In time, he found his destination – a very nondescript nightclub that could have easily been missed among the multitude of businesses. Parking his car, he donned his sunglasses, dusted off his suit, and stepped in, exuding confidence with each stride.

The club’s interior looked to be a place that was quite low-budget. Framed pictures were strewn all over the walls, with no real order to it. They were pictures of various celebrities with autographs on them. They didn’t have a name to them, however, so Everett just wrote them all off as being printed off from the internet. The tables had scratches all over them, scratches of varying depth and size. Initials and obscenities were carved into them, and Everett could only imagine the drunken stories behind the initials, scratches, chips and other dents. Each table was topped with a single seven-day candle with glass that looked greasy and unclean, as though they were rarely, if ever, changed. Whoever ran the establishment didn’t have the sense of mind to remove the carpet from the floor. It seemed to be red at one point, but now it was a sickening shade of brown, and it made Everett’s mind wonder about the sorts of things that had occurred on this floor, and what sorts of things had rendered this floor into such a repugnant state. The thought came to mind, and Everett had to force the unpleasant thought out. This shabby little hellhole wasn’t worth his time, and if the owner wasn’t talking about anything in terms of pay, Everett was sure that he would stand up and leave. He didn’t like people that had delusions of their own wealth. He knew what wealth was, and some people fancied themselves as millionaires, but had the pocketbooks of paupers.

“The boss’ll see you now,” a burly man in a black shirt walked up to Everett. The bouncer stood only slightly taller than Everett, who was quite tall in his own right. He didn’t much look down at him, but rather looked him in the face, treating the man as an equal. He knew what Everett was there for, and he had no desire to become a statistic. Everett, without acknowledging the bouncer, walked to the office, and slammed the door behind him.

“You require my services?” Everett requested, wanting to know who the fool was that decided to call him up. They may or may not get to hear words that they wanted to hear from Everett. It completely depended on how much money they were willing to offer to the man. The proprietor of the club turned around in his chair to quickly survey the man that he hired.

Everett received the order from the jilted boss and lover to kill this particular woman. The boss passed a photograph to him, with a woman and her name. She was a songstress, a young woman with a gifted voice and a striking face. Her hair was thick and waved, though in this picture, it was clear that she had straightened it beforehand. Her skin was the color of coffee with a hint of cream. Her lips were thin and pink, though slightly turned up as though she were as enigmatic as the Mona Lisa. Her eyes were upturned, giving her a slightly foreign, exotic appearance. She was indeed a black woman, but of indeterminable lineage. Was she biracial? Creole? Everett had a weakness towards black women based on just features and their bodies alone, but something about this one stood out even more to him. The expression that she wore on her face in this photograph of her was both enigmatic and serious, but for a moment, Everett was made silent just by looking at how incredibly beautiful she was. He had slept with women that were better looking than her, but she was indeed captivating.

He looked at the rather ratty looking sugar-daddy, eyed him harshly and took in everything about him. He was a black, small-statured, greasy looking little butterball. He wore a stained tracksuit with a large gold chain hanging from around his neck, and he reeked of marijuana, alcohol and body odor that he seemed to try to cover over with cheap cologne. The man was balding, and with his fat face, Everett was positive that no self-respecting woman would want to wake up to this aberration in the bed with her. In fact, the forgiving influence of alcohol wouldn’t work to make him more attractive.

Everett tightened his lips, arching an eyebrow at the fool. No shit that a woman like this Ingrid wouldn’t allow her to be with him. Women like Ingrid didn’t give men like this the time of day. It was so funny how men that were so abjectly repulsive felt that they were entitled to the most beautiful woman in a room. A guy like this would despise Everett – a man who used women to his own ends and who always had his pick of the litter. Still, a job was a job, and Everett certainly wouldn’t turn it down. Perhaps he could get to know this Ingrid before he killed her.

“Is there any preference to how you would prefer for me to do this job?” Everett sat back on the chair, pulling a cigar from the case of Cuban Cigars and lighting it. “Poison? Stabbing? Strangling? Kidnapping and disappearance? Or just take the easy way out and shoot her?”

The fat man’s eyes blazed. “I’d rather see her poisoned. She’s a fuckin’ dimepiece, mayne, and a face like that…you just don’t fuck it up. She’s gotta be fine as fuck even in the grave. I’m payin’ you good-ass money to make sure that this job is done right, son. She lives in Bed-Stuy and works at the 21 Club. Imma be up there soon to see if you did what I’m payin’ you for.”

Everett glared at the man. “Do you deign to presume that I am less than proficient with my job? You’ve been foolish enough to deal with amateurs for too long a time, and that is your problem. However, allow no confusion in this – I am exceedingly skilled in my job – and if you manage to botch it, it will be your head.” Everett coolly took a drag on the cigar, the sweet smoke permeating the air. “I do hope that such a standard is clear enough to you. I want the first half to be put into an Escrow account in my name – Vincent J. Marcotte – before I start the job, probably sometime tomorrow. I will show you the pictures and such and I’ll allow you to wait a day or two before sending me the remainder. If I don’t get the remainder, my good man…” Everett twirled the cigar in his hand, his voice becoming ever more menacing. It wasn’t even necessary for him to finish his statement.

“Then I think we got ourselves a deal, playa,” the man stuck his hand out for Everett to shake it. Everett immediately stood up and turned around, heading on his way out. He didn’t bother to shake the man’s hand. He would much rather get the job done.

The following evening, with the money Escrowed into his account, the debonair hitman dressed in his suit, and drove down to Bed-Stuy to his victim’s apartment. He kept a look at her picture, and knew that people would recognize her. Pretty women were all over Bed-Stuy, but as special as she was, people would be able to point her out. He parked his Porsche on the side of the street, in front of a large brownstone with the address that he wanted. Stepping out of the car, he showed Ingrid’s picture to a group of young women sitting on the stoop of an ornate brownstone. They pointed at the neighboring rowhouse, telling her him “Third floor. Her last name is Morrison.”

Everett easily walked his way up the obscene flights of stairs, and, after picking the lock, opened the door just enough to where he could see the security chain. ‘This will be easy,’ he chuckled to himself as he easily cut through the chain. In no time, he had finally stepped into a dark apartment, his nose immediately drawn to a very sweet, wonderful scent of flowers and perfume. He looked around the place, though he couldn’t see very much in the dark like this. As he walked to turn on a light and get a feel for the place, he felt something against his head, and the sound of a gun being cocked.

“Don’t move,” a smooth, feminine voice ordered. Everett couldn’t actually move – this woman had the jump on him and if he were to move an inch, she could very well shoot him. Smart one, this lady.

KAlast
50744 words so far Winner!

Hi Harlow,
ohthatmomagain (the poster above you) is yet to receive some feedback, would you mind taking a look just so she doesn't get missed, and everyone gets a turn.
Thanks :-)

J_S_C
100145 words so far Winner!

Dump the first paragraph. Paragraph two begins the story.

At first read, I something about it didn't sit well with me. So, I read it again, and I couldn't put my finger on what. Then, I read it backwards, paragraph by paragraph, and it hit me. It is the small errors in the exposition that one can read over and dismiss that made me hesitant to give this a thumbs up. Here are some examples of what I mean:

1) Mind the word "was." There are several places where that weak verb can be replaced with something stronger. Behind its wheel was Everett Belvidere, who was one of those highly-paid hitmen. It's used twice. Once I could let slide, but not twice in the same sentence.

2) Our hitman speak very formally, and when he does use the two contractions. There are two choices here. You can take the two out and make him totally unbelievable, or you can re-look at his dialogue and add them back in. I've said it before, contractions are part of our subconscious.

3) The exposition needs to be tightened. While it is good, and crafted well (note I did not say excellently), there is room for improvement. See the paragraph with the descriptions of the tables, or the description of the woman in the photograph. I'm not saying take the tables out, or the photograph, but you have the ability to condense that into something more succinct. (Personally, I think your third paragraph is the best one, but that too could use a couple of tweaks.)

As to the flow, this being a crime/thriller/noir, then the pacing is good, actually. It has the predictability (I knew what was going to happen as soon as I saw the picture) that people who read thrillers want, with (I hope) enough twists and suspense to keep them involved.

Grade: B+
Genre: Crime/Thriller/neo-noir
Turn the page: Most likely

--JSC

J_S_C
100145 words so far Winner!

Getting the anhydrous ammonia proved the most difficult part of the process. First he tried to bribe a fellow junkie with some of the winnings he earned on the show, but that doped up fucker never showed. The Sudafed was easy to get. All that took was time and gas money. He knew that it was unwise to go to local pharmacies to get the stuff, so he went to neighboring towns. He would go into the pharmacy, pick out three boxes and walk to the check-out counter. If they asked him for his license—which rarely happened—he would tell them that he forgot it in the car, walk out of the store, and then drive off and try the next one. At twenty pills in a box, he only needed nineteen. That would net him maybe twenty-five to thirty grams of product if he was careful. And he intended to be careful. If tonight worked, he would start the process again tomorrow on a larger scale: he would triple or quadruple the amount of Sudafed he bought.

Three days. It had only been three days, and he jonsed for it like nothing he ever knew. He couldn’t sit down or stay still and he was constantly popping Tylenol for the headache that would not disappear, his poor liver. He was glad that the sleepiness had not started. Maybe he had not gotten to that part of the withdrawal yet, or the coffee was masking it. Damn, that Mike for getting busted. How stupid do you have to be to leave that shit lying around for any Tom, Dick, or Harry to see it from the window? It was his fault that he had to start making his own. Maybe if his head were clear, he would have realized that it would have been safer to find another dealer than try to make his own.

The problem remained getting the anhydrous ammonia. One couldn't just buy it on the street, or walk into a hardware store and ask for it by name. No, it had to be stolen, or you had to be a licensed farmer to get it and even then it was heavily regulated. Since he didn't farm, he had to resort to thievery. He let the hour of midnight come and go before he got into his car and headed out into the country. When he turned off onto a country road, he killed the headlights and drove in complete darkness. He had to find a farm large enough to have need of a large component of the ammonia. Eventually he found it, and he thanked his fortune and lucky stars that he had not been spotted by a cop or some other do-gooder that might call the cops. He drove past the farm and parked his car on the side of the road and climbed a fence and walked through the fields that smelled of fresh fertilizer with a gasoline can in hand. He didn't know if the metal and the chemical would react, or what reaction would occur if they did, but he was so intent on getting the stuff that he did not really care. He had read stories of people that blew themselves up when making the shit, but he figured those people were the idiots of the world, and Darwinism ended up prevailing with them. He didn't consider himself an idiot, but people never really consider themselves as such in the process.

Slinking behind a large barn, a large shadowy structure in the moonlight, he found the object of his obsession: a large white storage tank with the words ANHYDROUS AMMONIA in green letters stenciled one side. Underneath the green stenciling were the words in a red stenciling, INHALATION RISK. He didn’t care. He didn't think that he was going to be breathing the stuff. All he needed was enough to fill the can, and then he would high-tail it off the farm and back home. Looking around, he lowered himself under the nozzle and jutted the gas can under it. A pressure valve jutted out near the base of the tank. He turned it, and heard a distant hissing. He turned the valve further and the hissing grew louder. A pungent odor filled the air around him, and he drew a large breath and turned the vale further. The hiss turned into a wail and a large plume of smoke streamed out of the nozzle.

All of his senses were filled with the sensation of burning. His lungs screamed in pain, he eyes watered in an attempt to flush out the noxious gas that was infiltrating the soft tissues, but in vain. The water reacted with the ammonia creating a powerful base that started eating away at the tissues of his eyes. Blindness came in seconds. Instinctively, he turned the valve closed. Blisters formed all over his face, hands, arms, and all other exposed parts of his body. Breathing became impossible, and he started suffocating before his body hit the ground. He couldn't see the beauty of the sky. The crisp fall night was clear and all of the stars were shining down on him. Wheezing as gasps escaped his body, he blindly looked upwards. He died alone, needing another hit of the drug that lead to his death.

Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

Really, that was amazing. I have no words.

Bravo.

Grade: A+ (100)
Buy it or shelve it: Buy it, most definitely.
Genre: Realistic fiction, adult.

Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

I am amazed by my own comment. Usually I find some kind of fault with everything, but this just struck me speechless. There really isn't anything for me to pick at.

And that's just terrible :c

Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

The snow drifted lazily past my head as I leaned out, cigarette in hand. Down below me people rushed, some with packages in hand. Sighing, I lit the cigarette and considered my position. Three days till Year’s End, still hadn’t gotten a present for Lucille, my fiancée.

Really, I should have been one of those rat-like people who were running around buying last minute presents for forgotten loved ones on their lists but instead here I was, smoking and standing around in my boxers, no plans for any sort of gift giving occasion. More than likely, she’d throw a fit for a few weeks, threaten to break off the engagement - not like she’d ever. Too much at stake for her.

I leaned back against the windowsill and thought about ordering one of my underlings to go out and get something nice for the gold-digging bitch. She was a bit more perceptive than her father- poor guy actually thought we were in love- and knew that she was only my beard and that I’d die before consummating anything with her, let alone our sham of a marriage.

I flipped the cigarette out the window and closed it. Making my way back over to the bed for a nap, my enhet rang, filling the room with that annoying bastardization of what once was a good song. Begrudgingly I pulled it out of my pants pocket and answered, my annoyance clear to the underling who had called me.

“Sorry sir! Did I wake you?” he said quickly, realizing from my rude greeting that he had done something wrong.
“No. Why the hell are you calling me? Do I even employ you?” This guy didn’t play the part well enough; he certainly didn’t work for me. Anyone who did would know how much I despised the word sir.

“No sir. I work for the Black Widow; she wanted me to deliver something but I have no idea where you live.” The man’s tone was high and panicky; he had obviously heard some kind of horror story from Vesapian about me.
“Ask her then!” I snapped gruffly, ending the call.

I fell back onto the dirty mattress situated under the half-wall that divided the living room/bedroom from the kitchen. Everyone who visited me thought it was weird that I lived in such a cheap apartment - everyone except for King and Vesapian, seeing as they weren’t much better about their living situations- when I had more than enough money to afford a lavish apartment with a doorman and all that shit.

The shear force of my back hitting the mattress sent a shudder through the floor and knocked loose more plaster from the walls, sending it to join the other pieces in a pile on the floor. Half-asleep, I thought about repairing the quickly deteriorating conditions of the apartment but realized how much effort that’d require.

No way was I going to put any effort into this shit hole. The doorbell rang just as I was about to fall asleep, pissing me off even more. I got up and yanked open the door, stopping the courier in the middle of pushing the button again.

“What the hell do you want?” I growled, narrowing my eyes at the terrified man who had disturbed my slumber. Tugging at his collar nervously, he took a few steps back and asked, “I’m sorry, but are you Daimeon Devique?”

I nodded and he handed me the beautifully wrapped box he had thrown to the side in his haste to get away from me. It was slightly squashed, I noticed as I glared angrily at the cowering man. He eeped and held out a clipboard.

“Puh-please sign this, Mr. Devique,” he stammered, his once proud stance wilting under my intently angry gaze. I quickly scrawled my name on it and shoved it back into his hands. I turned, present in hand, and closed the door behind me.

Giddy as a small child, I read the tag eagerly. In an elegant hand was the words, “To Daimeon. You’ll never guess what it is ;) Love, Lark.”

I tore the neatly wrapped paper off the box and peered inside. There was a card and a smaller box, this one wrapped in duct tape. I went to go get a pair of scissors from the kitchen, laughing all the way. This was just like him, making it difficult for me to get what I wanted.

Finally, I managed to get the last of the duct tape off, revealing a small black box. I opened it and drew in a sharp gasp; he didn’t. The ring glittering dimly in the low light told me he did.

I grabbed the card and opened it. As I had expected, it said only one thing, “Will you marry me, Daimeon?” Suddenly, I was weightless, the ground rushing up to break my fall.

When I woke up, I was surrounded. Vesapian’s troops had stormed the place, obviously in search of the ring. It was one of the seven state treasures; I had no idea why Lark thought he could get away with stealing it.

Vesapian herself sat elegantly on the edge of the windowsill, a hair’s width from falling and dying on the sidewalk. She was watching the passing pedestrians with an intent focus seen only in a hawk preparing to swoop down on an unsuspecting mouse.

She looked up and glanced over at me.
“Look who’s awake. You have a good nap, buddy?”
She was speaking to me in a tone reserved for small children and pets, which was in no way amusing. I snorted and asked,
“How long have you been here?”

Shrugging, she lept back into the apartment and in a surprising show of athleticism, landed on an armchair and tipped it over. She looked up at me and sat upside down in the chair, not willing to exert the effort required to put the chair back.

“Only about an hour or so. Don’t worry, I’ll pay for the door,” she chuckled, gesturing to where the door had been torn from the frame and thrown down the hall. I sighed and asked,
“What are you here for?”

“What, can’t I just show up because I’m lonely? Because I want your companionship? Jeez, what ever happened to hospitality?”
I struggled to not throw her out the window as I said between clenched teeth,
“You. Broke. Into. My. Apartment.”
She pouted and asked, “So?”

That was the last straw. I grabbed her by her pressed, no doubt expensive, white shirt and slapped her across the face. She whimpered at me and suddenly there were three soldiers behind me, guns cocked and at the ready. I dropped her and stepped back.

“Actually, if you must know, I was here to deliver this but fine! Be that way!” She shoved a red paper wrapped present at me as she stormed out of the apartment, fake sobbing the whole way.

eewashington
14972 words so far

The main thing this is suffering from is too much telling and not enough showing. For instance, when Daimeon picks up the phone to talk to the trembling little man, his annoyance should be apparent without saying so. The motives for characters to speak and act the way they do should always be apparent to the reader without having to explain it. In places, you really do achieve that toward the end of the excerpt, but in places it's still a bit iffy. Information is good for the reader, but beware of an overload of it.

MoonPhaseChick
0 words so far

Same, too much telling tends to really halt the imagination process. Since I know how he is dressed, I don't have to imagine the details. Showing may be a bit difficult but think of the rewards.

Really, I should have been one of those rat-like people who were running around buying last minute presents for forgotten loved ones on their lists but instead here I was, smoking and standing around in my boxers, no plans for any sort of gift giving occasion. <

eewashington
14972 words so far

Genre- I got a little bit of a young adult fantasy vibe, but it was hard to determine completely based just on the excerpt.
Buy it or Shelve it- Buy it, after you edit and revise the prose
Grade- A high C+, so about 83%.

Wilson3sd
12338 words so far

Ok, here goes:
(Beware a few choice words)

I. Emma


She stood out, a stark black against the white snow glistening in the afternoon sun. Trudging her way along the sidewalk between the brackish, slushy gray of cleared snow from the road and the stark, unblemished white of the yards. She thought it was quite nice compared to other wintry afternoons in Detroit. For Emma, the sun didn’t always shine. Her trek home from school took her through the suburban McMansions recently left standing, cold and empty. Emma’s neighborhood lay just beyond the subdivisions, Just close enough to make riding the bus, or taking a car, impractical. Just far enough to understand the clear distinction between the kids of those families who were left in the McMansions and herself.

Emma’s sharp contrast made it easy for her classmates to pick her out as they rode by on the buses (the ones more likely to circulate in Emma’s vicinity) and in their cars (the less likely, as their cars were usually upper end and thus they must associate with upper end people as well).

She stood out from the drifts for several reasons. Her personal style verged on Johnny Rotten crossed with a pink bow. Although she was no Nancy, for one she thought Sid and Nancy were dumb, definitely not a punk Romeo and Juliet. Second, because Emma was definitely not heroin chic. She was heavy set with a little baby fat on her tummy and strong arms. Her legs were stout, but not undefined. Emma did not suffer the dreaded “cankles” insult. Not that you could tell anyway, black hi-top Doc Martens laced tight moved into overlaid fishnets with the larger, holier pair pulled over the smaller, less ripped pair. The overlay was one of the only ways Emma dared wear her stockings to school. Although quite lax when it came to a dress code, her school wouldn’t have tolerated the already large spaces in her outer fishnets, especially when combined with the holes from the numerous rips and tears that gaped along her legs.

Over the stockings was a simple black knee length skirt, safety pins adorned the split up her left thigh. The skirt itself was tattered and frayed around the hems, the product of years of duty in the service of personal fashion. Her belt was studded, legit studs in fact, not the Hot Topic shit that popped off if you really had an urge to get at one. Waist up was always a combination of, rain or shine, winter or summer, spring or fall, a thermal and a stretchy shirt with rips and holes.

Over these she would wear any number of t-shirts. Unlike the hipsters who prided themselves on irony or obscurity in their fashion at her school, her tshirts were legit reflections of her interests. When she wore her Sex-Pistols shirt it was because she could feel that Queen could only be saved God, who happened to have a sneer and spiked blond hair. She was a Stooge, a streetwalking cheetah with a hide full of napalm. She was a Ramone, blitzkrieg bopping over the rainbow. Her Sting falsettoed So Lonely and was her own Message in a Bottle. The more black, the better was her decision when it came to clothing, maybe a touch of pink wasn’t so bad though. (She was a competition cheerleader after all. “She didn’t lift weights, she lifted people” said a fundraising t-shirt.)

To finish the look, Emma sported jet black hair and eyeliner to match. She had seen the Distillers once and thought the lead singer, Brodie, was just the fucking coolest. Joan Jett for Emma’s age, although she knew deep down there would never be another Joan Jett.

The only variance in the black, besides the occasional pink or splash of color on one of her t-shirts, was her dad’s military jacket. A faded olive drab, the jacket had seen time overseas in things her dad didn’t talk about much, like, ever. She had seen a plaque commemorating a bronze star once, and vaguely remembered a story her mother told her about a helicopter going down on the base where her dad was stationed. This had been before Emma’s mother was a casualty of the bad days in Detroit. Gentrification had brought the McMansions into her part of the Motor City, erasing (but never completely) the industrial and vicious edge she had always known.

So today, blacked out, with a dash of green, on the way home from school, Emma, fists clenched into the overlong sleeves of her father’s jacket against the cold, trudged home. The usual pit was in her stomach. For about a year Emma had felt a growth inside of her. No, she wasn’t pregnant. Instead, it was an ebbing and flowing emotional growth. She would wake up in the morning generally happy, very well adjusted for a teenage girl from a low-income part of town in a single parent family. She didn’t have boy problems, or catfights to worry about. Everybody was pretty much cool with Emma. She presented, and possessed, a very secure sense of self and people accepted it. Her first few practices had been rough as a freshman, of course. What is new is a threat, and what is misunderstood is definitely a threat to a closed system like cheerleaders. But, Emma, as always won them over by staying true. So what if she liked punk? She could still lift, toss, and base better than most, and she always hit her marks. When she pulled her back tuck before any other freshman on the team, the older, previously bitchy, girls shrugged with a sense of fuck it, she’s good and welcomed her to the fold.

The ebb and flow would usually begin once she got to school, although some days it may have begun earlier if her dad was up and about. She hadn’t really pinned it down exactly though. She knew it wasn’t anxiety, and it wasn’t food related. She wasn’t medicated, and she couldn’t identify any other possible reasons. Most of the time she was fine until she touched, or brushed, or made contact with someone else. Emma had almost narrowed it down to this, but had written it off because the odds of not physically touching someone in high school were astronomical. Halls the size of cattle chutes, friends with no respect for personal space, lockers stacked on lockers with an inch between them and even less for people, made the effort to stay untouched impossible.

Touching was one part she had almost identified, but that didn’t account for the other part that seemed to play a part. Sometimes the growth would stir from a word, or a look, or when she regarded someone. Sometimes it seemed as if the feeling crept in when she was merely in the room with someone, silent and separate as if the feelings she experienced were ambient energies attracted to her as if she was a magnet.

No genius, Emma worked her way through the only explanations she could generate. She had failed to notice people’s mood lightening after encountering her. Her locker buddies over the years had been strikingly good students. At least they were better than they should have been. The years they were not near her locker, with the daily interactions or contact, show a marked decline in discipline, attendance, and grades. It was still Detroit after all, and an almost inner city school until the gentrification had injected new tax money and new standards. As a result, the student population had become almost three quarters middle to upper middle class and the rest pretty severely impoverished and angry, rather than the completely impoverished reason to send your kids to private school it had been before.

Some kids were still angry, poor, and prone to crime, just not the ones who had the good fortune of having a locker near Emma, or even a class with her, or even seeing her in the hall or at lunch. Her teachers had better classes, the teachers themselves thought they were better, and generally the years people had Emma, the punk cheerleader who struggled in math and was only average in everything else, were career years. (When discussing Emma, her teachers would say “She’s not the brightest, but goodness she’s swee-eet.” If they had been in the South, they would have added a “bless her heart.”)

If she had thought about it a little more, beyond merely connecting the growth to contact, or speech, or thoughts, then she would have noticed that no one on her squad had ever really suffered any serious injury. Most cheerleaders carry any number of sprains, tears, or pulls at any given time. Those few who are lucky enough not have broken anything are the definite minority. Forest Hills High School competition cheerleading (Back-to-back-to-back State Champs! Woo!) hadn’t been plagued by the general breaks and sprains that were the bug-a-boo of its rival programs. Several times the trainer had stood shaking his head at the disappearance of concussion symptoms, or the regained resistance of a knee landed on awkwardly. Those injuries which had stuck, had occurred almost always in a manner in which the trainer had to quickly escort the injured cheerleader away from the squad into the arms of the parents to be whisked away to the doctor. (Although those injuries generally disappeared after joining back up with the team.) No one really gave it much attention. It was strange, sure, but not on such a level as to be overtly evident. Because no one else noticed it, Emma most surely did not.

Once all things were considered, Emma still drew a blank. She perceived far more than she understood. She could gauge from the looks on people’s faces their moods. The happy from the sad, the sincere from the insincere. Even her father, a stoic, was not unreadable to Emma. What she knew was that she was often happy until she met up with, or touched somebody. She also understood that people always seemed to leave her happy, or at least some degree happier or better than they were before.

She had been considering this more frequently than usual. Her dad had been different recently but she couldn’t quite put her finger on it. As she turned into the deserted lot her house backed up to, separated by a wobbly chain link fence, Emma sniffled and trudged on. She reached the fence, feeling the same wave of sadness, pain, and suffering, growing somehow more firm inside of her. She stepped through the gate, screaming on its rusty, slightly off center hinges. She turned her key in the lock on the cage protecting their inner door from the reality of her neighborhood, glancing twice over her shoulder as her dad had taught her to make sure no one was sneaking up on her, and entered the house.

“Dad?” she called. Knowing full well it was too early for him to be home, but vaguely remembering today’s schedule as different. She went to the refrigerator and grabbed a Mountain Dew. Caffeine was perhaps her only vice. Caffeine and, much to the disgust of her punk friends, saccharine pop music. She opened the can and took a long sip with her eyes closed. A song popped into her head. It was a Rihanna song about cheering the weekend, and how she’d drink to that. So would I, Emma thought, although she had never tried to drink before.

With the tune in her head, she dropped her bags by the door. Both her bookbag and training bag were laden with the essentials. Her bookbag, adorned with buttons, pins, and patches, slumped with the weight of her notebooks and her math book. Her training bag was full of shoes, shorts, tshirts, and bows. They shouldn’t have been remotely close in weight, but the amount of things a teenage girl needs would surprise most people. Enough at least to be equal to what the girl needs to be successful in school. Leaving the bags by the door, and her drink on the table, Emma flitted down the hallway from the kitchen leading to the living room and front door, humming her best Rihanna impersonation. In the foyer she turned and headed upstairs.

At the top she paused considering a few things before she decided on what she wanted to do. Bedroom or Bathroom? Both places had things she needed. But today was different than before. The itch and weight she felt were itchier and heavier than before and she was unsure of what she needed to do. Emma stepped down the hall, passed her bedroom on her left, and entered the bathroom. Closing the door, the humming from the hall broke into a full song. Emma sang the arias of Avril Lavigne laid under the track because she couldn’t quite remember the actual words. Locking the door, Emma turned to the sink and mirror.

Looking back at her was a disheveled mess. Unbeknownst to Emma, during the walk her body had already begun its processes. Her mascara and eyeliner gave off the impression of crying ink. Her hair, so tightly pulled back from practice, had slid off slightly to the left, still a ponytail but loose enough to allow a poof of sorts to grow over her forehead. Her bangs fell in strands along the edges of her face. Her heart dropped at the sight, and what had been easy to resist during the walk, the acceptance of the inevitability of now and what must happen, hit home with full force.

Emma sang. Muted, slower, more off key, but still she sang. As she turned on the faucet and placed a razor under the water growing steadily hotter, she sang. She left Rihanna, and sang her way through a search for a new song. Lines from a dozen songs echoed off the green tiles of the bathroom as she busied herself with preparations. Songs were tried and discarded until one felt right. She had stumbled into classic rock somehow. Her dad had tried everything he could to forge a bond with his daughter since his wife, and her mother, had been shot. Music had been the key.

The first thing I remember was asking father why, cause there were many things I did not know… crooned John Fogerty.

Emma turned back to the mirror, now fogging from the steam rising from the sink. She wiped a streak through the condensation and saw herself again. She had placed a towel beside her on the commode. As she left her own gaze and bent to pick it up, a drop of blood fell from her nose. A single dot on the porcelain, frozen in her mind. It was time.

And daddy always smiled at me, took me by the hand, and said to me someday you’ll understand.

“I hope so Daddy,” she thought and stripped her shirt off. She removed her sports bra and stood topless in the steam humming the song her mind settled on.

“God, I hope so,”

I’m here to tell you now, each and every mother’s son. You better learn it now you better learn it young... the chorus resonated.

She picked up the razor. A double sided insert into an old time razor that had been a gift to her father from her mother one Christmas that had been bought at a high-end shaving shop. It was light in her fingers as she turned the blade down and in a quick motion drew it deeply across her wrist. Sniffling, but still humming, the chorus echoed through her mind:

'Cause someday never comes...

She switched hands and drew another deep line in the meaty part of her forearm. Her hand was slippery with the blood, hot and sticky. As she finished her other arm Emma dropped the blade into the sink. The water was diluting the flowing blood into a pinkish shade. She thought it looked like her bows downstairs. A good thought.

Someday-ee-yay never comes...

Resting her arms on the lip of the sink so the blood poured into the basin, Emma sank to her knees. She rested her forehead against the front of the old porcelain dish and felt the cool surface. She closed her eyes and felt the ebb and flow again. This time the pain and sorrow ebbed, and a sense of release flowed in.

Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

Wilson3sd.

This is double the maximum word count. Please read the rules before posting your excerpt.

Thanks.

Wilson3sd
12338 words so far

I have read/did read the rules beforehand, but thanks for the reminder. I just posted the first chapter, didn't think it was more than 1,000 words. (Should have looked beforehand.) So I'm sorry for that.

In the future, others should receive the scolding as well. I am not the first to go over, nor will I (likely) be the last. I appreciate you pointing it out to me and I will do my best to follow them in the future. :)

Chaos-Insanity
52796 words so far Winner!

I apologize if it seems I was targeting you. I just happened to notice the big ol' TL;DR situated under my own post and decided to word count it. Usually, we don't word count the posts unless it is abnormally long since it may be that the word count was gone over or they just formatted it weirdly.
Once again, my apologies.

Wilson3sd
12338 words so far

No worries! I should have run it through a counter. E-live and learn. :)

Mallorca Writer
29940 words so far

I wrote a nice long critique of this piece earlier, but I now see that it has disappeared. Rats. Here is what I remember from my earlier critique.

Critique: I know you have probably heard this a million times, but here it is again---"Show. Don't tell." Showing draws the reader into the story. Telling creates distance. You have way too much telling here.

Your paragraphs are too long and uniform. They are aesthetically unpleasing on the page. Take a look at how successful novelists break up their texts on the page, and follow their examples whenever possible.

This piece doesn't fulfill the requirements of a first chapter. It's almost all taken up with a girl walking home in the snow. Lengthy descriptions and heavy backstory do not make compelling fiction in the twenty-first century. Modern novels have very little backstory in the first chapter, perhaps nothing more than a couple of sentences. This is because the reader doesn't care about the character yet. The reader won't start to care about her until after she is confronted with the novel's problem and begins to overcome that problem. After that, you will be able to put some backstory in, but try to avoid big info. dumps. Sprinkle it into the text in tiny doses.

Never tell the reader what the POV character is wearing unless it comes up naturally in the story. For example, she is discussing with her best friend whether to wear the blue dress or the red dress.

Get another character into the scene as quickly as possible. Try to avoid scenes with just one character. Drama and tension come when people are together. The way to reveal character is through interactions. Don't tell us what your character is like. Show us. We need action, dialogue, problems.

My suggestion to you is a big one. Eliminate everything you wrote prior to--"Emma sang. Muted, slower, more off key, but still she sang." That is a hook. It gets the reader asking questions. First chapters should be full of unanswered questions. Your first chapter is full of answers.

Genre YA. Maybe horror?

Shelve

Grade C




eewashington
14972 words so far

1 Night

I took one breath and I thought I died, then I lived again, and I was never more alive after that. But maybe that was just the toxic, gaseous spew of the city slowly killing the last of my brain cells. Either way, now (and now is the only thing that ever mattered), I felt alive. The choking smog, the glitzy smut, and the aching scent of a story yet to be told or even dreamed hung heavily in the air.

There was a big empty silence in the dark cavity of the city that night. Every artificial star melded into the endless void of moonlight, stone, and steel. My anxious footsteps fell in syncopation, mimicking the long dead rhythm of the night. Ahead, my brother went diving forward into the river of cars and came out the other side screaming with delight. His eyes dared me to follow. They were always daring someone into something.

“Wesley,” I let my voice sail to that pair of daring eyes. “Why are we here?”

“You’ll see,” an equally daring voice replied. He turned around to face me, with his eyes still ablaze. “There’s just this spot I need to show you. It’s just about perfect this time of night.”

“In the middle of Helene at three in the morning?” I ran forward to catch him, and he went whooping through a side alley, raving like a maniac.

“No! On Mars at the crack of dawn! So don’t be late.” I swallowed my curiosity momentarily, and went tearing after him to the dark, silent heart of the alley.

We filled that brooding silence with our roars, ugly symphonies of youthful noise and our own fiery madness. I think the city itself was writhing with the same insane, unadulterated joy that we were. Those roars erupted out of us like beasts in the wilderness, forsaken and hungry, and reverberated out across the twinkling city. In a way, that was exactly what we had become. We walked on and on and on, deeper into the heart of the city and deep enough to be caught by the spell of the underworld.

It was a valley of misshapen art and dust, with “art” being a very generous term. They city was haphazardly thrown together, with odd protruding spires of stone and dilapidated bits of wood adorning the downtown scene. We wandered meaninglessly, but not aimlessly, throughout the once vibrant ruins of the city. But what was left of the city anyway? Brown faded to ochre and weather-berated gray swathed every artificial element of the night. The moonlight reached out its wicked tentacles to illuminate the sad, decaying truth of it all.

“So where exactly are we going?”

“Oh, just shut up for once and enjoy the trip. This is your first time actually sneaking out, after all.”

“Oh yeah, this is just too much fun, leaving my nice, comfortable bed to waltz around a filthy rundown city. Thanks, Wes.”

“I know. I love this city too. Come on, Hector. Saffron Street is just around the corner.” Begrudgingly, I followed my smiling brother to the corner. Somehow I knew that particular night would end this way, with me walking faithfully into the solemn darkness after some smiling maniac.

The city was now just a wraith, a whisper of what had once been a mighty shout to the rest of the world. Around the corner the beggars would still be there, depending on nothing but the kindness of strangers. But in this city, kindness was practically a dead commodity. With every nostalgic footstep we knew that we were in a much different place, a much different time, from the city we knew.

My brother had dragged me out here, but I wanted to go. I wanted something, and I thought I might find it in the city. I didn’t know what I was chasing that night inside the ruinous city. It was something impossible, something either so impossibly profound or simple that it escaped my every desperate reach into the unknown. The chase went beyond the city. It went beyond me.

“Isn’t that where all the whores and drug addicts call home?" Once, we had lived in the city, in one of the ochre-colored apartment buildings with graffiti savagely strewn on the walls. I remembered distinctly being forbidden from venturing to Saffron Street at night, or any time of day, but especially night, and yet, there I was.

“You say that like it's a bad thing. They’re connoisseurs of all things pleasurable to experience. This is just...the Mecca of the underworld. It’s the center of the city. It’s beautiful if you look at it the right way." Wesley’s daring eyes looked wildly around.

"That right way would be with your eyes closed and praying that you're somewhere else, right?"

"Didn’t I tell you to shut up already? You’re not seeing things the right way yet."

We reached the end of the sidewalk, and waltzed across the street to the sound of car horns and aggravated shouts. The silence had been shattered, beautifully. Whatever I was searching for, whatever I had wanted, was fixed somewhere in the stars that captured my gaze. There I was, possessed and enamored by the blank and brilliant stare of the stars. For a moment I saw their brilliance fade and the swirling starlight was instantly replaced by the swiftly approaching car lights. There I was, on Saffron Street, the twisted, sadistic, and beautiful heart of the dilapidated city. Even in the dead of night, the vilest people and their cars still populated the city, ever faithful and lifeless. I was surrounded with life, it was crying out all around me, but I was almost certain I had never felt more alone in my life. With my soul thrashing and yearning with the stars for secrets unspeakable, I wasn’t just alone, I was bored.

“I don’t want to see anything but my eyelids when I curl up in my nice, soft bed!”

J_S_C
100145 words so far Winner!

There is nothing here. It's like reading techno music. With the techno music I know the song is done with the track changes. Here i know I'm done when the sample is finished.

You start to go somewhere in your penultimate paragraph, but by then it is too little, too late. Give me some movement other than being on a street that you aren't supposed to be on.

Genre: Sci-Fi
Grade: B-
Pick up or shelve: Shelve

BloodRoseAngel
85246 words so far Winner!

1. Critique (try to be specific and as detailed as possible): Your writing style is VERY descriptive. It's quite unique and almost poetic, with lots of unusual imagery. However, I think it could be overwhelming if it goes on like this for the entire book. It can sound quite obscure in places and could be cut down a bit. If it's jut used to introduce the story, I think it works well to bring the reader in. The characters clearly have two very different personalities so you've established that well to begin with. I'm intrigued about the world they live in from the beginning. :)

2. Genre and age group: Urban fantasy/sci-fi, YA

3. Shelve it or buy it: Buy

4. Score (either letter A, B, C, D, or out of 100): B

Who's online

There are currently 3579 users online.