RSS

Does cremation destroy DNA?

Display mode:
GuardianOfTheFronds
31329 words so far

Or could a good lab still find some in there somewhere?

EFBQ
71459 words so far Winner!

Cremation leaves ash and bits of bones. If it's done poorly/incompletely, it *might* be just barely possible to recover DNA from the bone fragments, but I would not bet on it.

angitiger
50153 words so far Winner!

Also teeth don't always get turned into ash. It is possible to extract DNA from there as well.

sallythecat
50015 words so far Winner!

I second the DNA in teeth thing. Teeth attached to jaw fragments can hold DNA for over 700 years. I've watched plague DNA isolated that way.

Canas
0 words so far

Teeth and bone are ground up into a fine powder before being placed in an urn if done professionally. In Japan, there is a custom where after cremation the family of the deceased will use chopsticks to pick up bone fragments and place them in the urn (hence why it is also considered rude in Japan to pass food to others with your chopsticks).

As for whether or not it is possible to retrieve DNA, there is very little chance. Of course, you might just find a character that runs a morgue and tends to keep "souvenirs" from his/her job...

angitiger
50153 words so far Winner!

Now that's just interesting. Thanks for sharing I so might be adding that in somewhere........

stephensdemise
50033 words so far Winner!

Remember, fiction does give you a bit of leeway. In your work, you can make it possible. All you have to do is come up with a reason to make it plausible for the reader. It may not pass muster with the scientists, but, hey, there's a reason it's called fiction.

simply_complex
50030 words so far Winner!

I agree here. There are several shows, for instance, that make statements that aren't true. Such as House, one of the doctors would suggest an infection in the patient, but another doctor would say, "but he doesn't have a fever." When in actuality, you can have an infection without a fever. Or in Law & Order, they would confront the suspect and trick them into confessing, and it ends suggesting that they make an arrest and charge the person based on the confession, but if the person was read their Miranda rights, their confession won't hold up in court.

So, in conclusion, you don't have to be 100% correct. Just have it entertaining and plausible enough and people will enjoy it. :)

Sayaren
6323 words so far

I don't know if you can find DNA in ashes, but I do know that if you add such and such or do this/that to it, you can tell if the person died of arsenic poisoning. (if I remember right, it turns purple?)

Hernandez

Greener way of cremation...body liquefaction..is the best way

Puddingpie

Not a direct answer to your question, but your victim might have bits of DNA that were spared cremation.

The Victorians were really into saving locks of hair for mementos of loved ones, like lockets and brooches. Or even embroidery and weird sculptures to commemorate the deceased. If they're into that sort of thing, the family might've requested hair for mementos from the body before it was cremated.

Or maybe the deceased donated hair to Locks of Love, so some cancer kid has a wig that's suddenly of vital interest to a criminal investigation. :D

Who's online

There are currently 4138 users online.