i haven't written a blatantly agender character yet but i have toyed with the idea. (i probably won't write any blatant asexuals simply because sexual themes rarely come up in my stories to begin with) seems this is even less well represented than LGTBQ.....
(speaking of agender topics - WHY does English not have a good gender neutral pronoun? WHY?!)
I'm using a singular they pronoun for my gender ambiguous character, who is one of the main characters and the antagonist as well as the protagonist's companion and friend.
Making a character sexually different only adds as many "sexual themes" to a story as making them heterosexual or cis gender. Nobody thinks of the aggressive heterosexual pairings in Disney movies as having a "straight agenda", now do they? ;)
flopart wrote: Making a character sexually different only adds as many "sexual themes" to a story as making them heterosexual or cis gender. Nobody thinks of the aggressive heterosexual pairings in Disney movies as having a "straight agenda", now do they? ;)
i don't quite follow this. I never said i wanted to write about asexual characters in order to avoid sexual themes. Actually i was kind of saying the reverse - that character sexuality/asexuality doesn't come up because my stories are pretty asexual to begin with. Any given character in one of my stories could theoretically - (my characters definitely have specific sexual orientations in my notes, i just never end up mentioning their attractions in the story) - they could theoretically be asexual, heterosexual, homosexual, bisexual, pansexual or any other variation thereof. It's simply never mentioned. and actually, i do think that the overabundance of sexual relationships is kind of an agenda but that's a whole different issue. :-)
i have seen some of the invented gender-neutral pronouns but i just wish there were such pronouns that everyone would automatically recognize. although, i suppose that's part of the point of writing agendered characters, isn't it? lol.
unfortunately I don't think that *everyone* recognizes they. I mean, a lot of people haven't even heard of the concept of someone being gender neutral, or really anything other than male or female gendered. I feel like for those people, "they" would be very confusing and possibly even need explanation, but I think that for people who haven't heard of the concept anything would need to be "explained" or just accepted.
Right...the majority of people recognize "they" as a pronoun that can be used "when a gender is unknown." The majority of people do not recognize it as a pronoun that someone uses for themselves. Therefore, in a book, if you have a character who uses "they," it's still going to confuse a lot of people. It's a big leap for most people to go from "when a gender is unknown," to what someone uses for their pronoun, because that is not how they've come to known "they." The moment you start using it for someone you know or the person you're speaking to knows, a lot of people get really confused, tell you you're using english incorrectly, think you're talking about a group of people, or any other number of things that indicate they really don't recognize it as a person's pronoun.
Are you not familiar with Spivak? They're a fairly useful set of invented gender-neutral pronouns (not that other neologisms aren't ~invented~) and they're some of the most prolific ones used! There's also sie/hir and variations, but I tend to stick with ey/eir/em as they're the ones I use for myself, and ones that feel the most freeing to use.
My MC is female and uses female pronouns this year, but I'm looking to stick in someone at least gq at some point, and maybe next year I'll be a bit more adventurous.
Oddly, I had never heard of these before. I currently use "they" and am familiar with the set of Ze (or Zi) pronouns, and the use of name as pronoun, but I really like the spivak pronouns (well, I think I like the ey better than e), and will most definitely be using them in my novel (and using them for myself, as well!)
Agender, not so much, but asexual yes. I attempt to put one in every single thing I write, because we need more love (No-one point out the irony in that statement.)
And yeah you;re right, they really are badly represented. Most people (at least other here) don;t even know what 'Asexual is', and thats porbably the same for agender. Hence why I always try to write at least one, and if possible slip the word in, so more people know and are aware of it.
But yeah even without 'sexual themes' you could have an asexual charater, even if you;re the only one who other knows, or the hints are very light, like them merely ignoring things taht would normally 'excite' other mebers of their gnder. Of course that might just lead to people thinking they're gay...again due to not many people being aware asexuality exsists.
My FMC might be asexual or demisexual, or she might be straight and have a low sex drive (and be religiously Catholic). She does have some kind of romantic feelings for the MMC, but I don't know if there's a sexual component or not...
I'm asexual and pan-romantic, and very happy this is getting more visibility.
One of the plots I'm considering writing this year includes three main characters, one who is definitely asexual and one who may or may not be asexual. The plot may need to marinate in my brain for another year though before its ready to be written.
As both agender and asexual, I'm kind of amused to see both of those aspects in a thread of their own, but okay, I guess? I see them all along the continuum of LGBTQQIAPP+ queerness.
One of my characters this year is fairly androgynous, although the concept is kind of hard to translate into a different culture, y'know? I say that if he lived in modern times, he'd probably be cool with "genderqueer". The other is entirely cis and sex-repulsed aromantic asexual. And these are all kind of major plot points.
sweet! and good point about making subtle hints that a character is asexual... that could be fun. i might actually do that... yeah, i think that could work. thanks!
agender could definitely fall along the continuum but i feel like asexuality is pretty different since it means (basically) not being sexually attracted to anyone. and then i thought while i was making a new thread, might as well include both topics that particularly interest me. :-)
One of my main characters is a bit of a conundrum when it comes to hyr gender (hyr? hys?). It's especially complicated because the character is based on a historical figure widely thought of as transgender, genderfluid, or just a plain old opportunist, but never really agender or asexual. Because I am writing a play, I've specified that the character can be played by a girl or a boy, however for simplicity's sake I'm referring to hyr as 'he' in stage directions, though the characters on-stage call hyr 'he' as well as 'Madame'.
It's a period piece; they simply have no indicator of non-gender at the time, and in French, the masculine pronoun can also be taken as a gender-neutral one.
I do have agender/asexual characters in my novel this nano, though it's not by choice. (Their souls were forced into a body that is mechanical after they died.) I'm finding it really challenging to write about, but its a lot of fun. It's actually really refreshing to write about how a person can love another person with feeling absolutely 0 physical attraction at all.
Don't know if this counts because it isn't a choice for my characters, but the themes are there.
I'm writing about this same thing! Their bodies look human, and have gender-specific features. They love each other, but of course they have no desire to do sexual things. It's cool somebody else thought of this. :)
I have a genderqueer character. I may add others as time goes on. It is a struggle to write a novel with genderqueer characters, though, for sure, because you have (ok, you don't HAVE to, but it's usually wise, if you're writing for a wide audience, at least) to explain the use of whatever pronoun you choose.
Oh man, I'm so glad I came here! I was hanging out in Fantasy. Anyway, I have a set of characters who are asexed. However, due to socialization they may not always be agendered. One of them, however, is genderqueer, I suppose, and for em I use Spivak pronouns, obviously. :)
I'm writing a story about three people who all live in the same body (young woman's body), one of whom is a girl (so technically asexual, but noone knows if that will change if/when she grows up. It's very likely she'll stay a 4-year-old all her life), another one an asexual young woman and the third one a gay boy with major angst about his body disphoria, although I'm probably only gonna hint at it, it's not plot-relevant. I love them :D In the world of my story (sci-fi), there is far less discrimination against people for any reason except money/ wealth and ability/ willingness to work. So they can live a life that's usually discrimination-free as long as they don't hang out in weird places where the last few bigots gather. So because there's next to no discrimination about people's identity or sexuality (or lack thereof) it's probably not gonna come up. I'm looking forward to including little hints, though, so for example if someone sais "I just fell in love" you wouldn't answer with "What's her/his name?" (using the pronoun that would assume a heterosexual love), instead you would use a gender-neutral phrasing.
Unfortunately I'm writing in german (because that's my first language) and there don't seem to be good gender-neutral pronouns. Using plural pronouns wouldn't work since they're nearly always identical to singular female pronouns. So I use "he" and "she" alternately for my genderqueer sidecharacter. I explained it in a footnote but I'm not sure it will work for readers. I'll have to find out in December...
If you want to read what I've got so far, you can do so here: http://www.nanowrimo.org/en/participants/meeresbande/novels/revolution-im-weltraum but like I said, it's in german.
My MC is androgynous in the way that their gender is not mentioned, at all. It's obviously intentional and any careful reader should be able to pick out where a specific gender only makes sense. Making my MC asexual would help this cause but it leaves out many of the places I would like to take my story, so for now, they do not have a specific age, gender or sexual orientation.
As for pronouns, I am writing a fictionalized memoir so I just use 'I' but I may need Spivak's later on. Wish me luck!
I've never tackled agender (though now I will), but I made two of my most important character asexual. It just made more sense given their similar outlooks and appearances, but they still can be romantic in their unique ways.
My MC is an androgen and I'm just sticking with the biological gender as pronouns referring to "him". Of course this character is pretty free with his orientation. I cannot stand writing "him" constantly. I'm keeping it first person for the most part. though. I'm just having some issues with the whole aesthetics of pronouns. I feel like there needs to be more words describing those who are genderqueer, gender-neutral, androgen or the like.
when i started this thread i wasn't sure how many people would respond, so seeing your responses is really great! :-)
my nano is getting ever more surreal so while i'm currently using gendered pronouns for my MC it's entirely possible that that could go out the window at some point. also, it's very visual so in the end i'm seeing it as more of a graphic novel or animated video or something. if that happens, i think the MC is going to be very ambiguously gendered. (yay for visual media!)
i do wonder though, if it would be hard for people that aren't agender to relate to a blatantly agendered character or if people that are sexual would have a hard time relating to a blatantly asexual character? on the one hand, i would think it wouldn't be an issue since people seem to relate to characters not of their own gender all the time but on the other hand it seems like being agender/asexual is such a foreign concept to most people that i wonder sometimes. even if the sexual orientation/gender identity is treated as a side note in the novel, is it going to distract some (most?) people from really following the plot/other themes?
and on that note - do any of you know of published books that feature asexual or androgynous/agendered characters?
Regarding your question wether or not it's hard for people to relate to agender and/or asexual characters, I think you're right that that isn't per se harder to do than to relate to bipolarly (it's a word now.) gendered and (hetero-)sexual people, but the difference is that we see those kinds of characters all the time and have great practice relating to them. We don't have practice relating to agendered and/or asexual characters -- yet. So I think it may take more explaining, but it should be perfectly possible.
As for identifying with asexual characters, I wonder why that would even be a foreign concept. Isn't everyone asexual as a child? Or is being an asexual child different from being a child who will grow up to be sexual? I ask this because sometimes gay/lesbian people say they have "always known I was different" even as a child. Being asexual myself, I don't really get that (I believe what people say about themselves, I just don't really understand this). Or maybe being (like) a child (in one respect) is just a foreign concept?
I think if you don't remind your readers that your character is agendered, they might just assign a gender to them in their heads -- just like agendered characters like robots are almost always portrayed as male or female. The same might be true for a character's sexual orientation. I don't know if that would be a problem though -- you can either put in little reminders here and there or let (some) readers assign them false genders if you don't feel like doing that. It's probably like reading a first person short story thinking the character is female and learning he is male somewhere near the end (that happens to me a lot when reading first person stories).
Meeresbande wrote: Regarding your question wether or not it's hard for people to relate to agender and/or asexual characters, I think you're right that that isn't per se harder to do than to relate to bipolarly (it's a word now.) gendered and (hetero-)sexual people, but the difference is that we see those kinds of characters all the time and have great practice relating to them. We don't have practice relating to agendered and/or asexual characters -- yet. So I think it may take more explaining, but it should be perfectly possible.
As for identifying with asexual characters, I wonder why that would even be a foreign concept. Isn't everyone asexual as a child? Or is being an asexual child different from being a child who will grow up to be sexual? I ask this because sometimes gay/lesbian people say they have "always known I was different" even as a child. Being asexual myself, I don't really get that (I believe what people say about themselves, I just don't really understand this). Or maybe being (like) a child (in one respect) is just a foreign concept?
i really don't know. it just seems like there's such an expectation of sexuality that people would be confused by a character who was explicitly stated to be asexual. but i guess we'll have to find out when we start publishing these novels. ;-)
My most magnetic main character is asexual, which is pretty much a running gag in my story. I based him a lot off of one my best friends, who is asexual and I'm actually getting a lot of my response ideas from him.
Not in the book I'm doing at the moment, but in the same series, later, one of the MMCs has a son who is asexual/ aromantic, and there will be a character who is technically neither male or female or anything else because she (who is presenting as female at that stage of the story) is a physical embodiment of an abstract concept. Later 'she' turns up with the same name, but is a 'he', and it's not questioned in-story (it would be kind-of a faux-pas to bring it up - 'excuse me, personification of an abstract idea, but you're doing humanoid presentation wrong - choose a gender/sex and stick to it' isn't really something you want to consider saying around this particular idea) And there's a lot of ambiguous/ androgynous characters, though my Narrator is a cis male, undisclosed sexuality (well, the nature of his existance sort-of ... makes sexuality irrelevant to him, personally. Probably I'd need a whole lot more than one post to explain it all) and his flatmate, the MMC is a cis male, pansexual, who kind-of missed the whole 'thing' of there being anything to make a fuss about with how anyone identifies (it's his son who is ace and aro, and when he 'comes out', this MMC is pretty much like 'good for you! this is a thing, isn't it? Party time! you get the sweets, someone else bring dvds, I'll find some wine! yaay!') Yup, so many in this series that aren't the base average, but they're balanced out by some 'normal??' secondary characters. (I really dislike the word 'normal' - what I mean is that they're more towards the middle of the bell curve. damnable imprecise concepts *shakesfist*)
The Shapeshifters in my story are all agender. They "start off" as male (in appearance, they are not human but appear to be), and can only reproduce as males, but the issue of pronouns comes in as half of them appear to be female all/most of the time. And when they're female, even thought they cannot reproduce as females, they are "all woman".
A constant silly argument I have with a writer friend is whether my MC and another character are a gay couple ("couple" used as a loose term here), as originally they were both "male". But they're not human, and one of them takes female forms all the time. They could if they wanted to, both act as male or female, or switch genders. We came to the conclusion that they are the ultimate bisexual couple.
With the pronouns, it depends on who's talking about the character with ambiguous gender. One of the characters spends an equal time as a male and female. The narrator refers to them as whichever gender they are "currently". Some of the other characters have an obvious preference to stay as male or female, and the narrator and some others use the appropriate gender pronoun. Some humans refer to the Shifters as "it", others as "ter" (and the rest of Casey Miller and Kate Swifts neutral pronouns). The only reason I'm writing it in the first person, actually, is to remove a tiny bit of pronoun confusion, as my MC and narrator changes occasionally.
I have three main characters. Of them, Abby is asexual (and pretty uncaring of others most of the time so I'm feeling aromantic as well), Ben is gay although, given his character, I'm pretty sure he's asexual homoromantic and Andru is hetrosexual. It doesn't really come up a lot in my story (aside from Ben propositioning a rescuer as a joke) although it's been touched on a little during Abby and Andru's heart to heart. It probably doesn't really come up because I don't really write relationships.
androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
just curious.
i haven't written a blatantly agender character yet but i have toyed with the idea. (i probably won't write any blatant asexuals simply because sexual themes rarely come up in my stories to begin with)
seems this is even less well represented than LGTBQ.....
(speaking of agender topics - WHY does English not have a good gender neutral pronoun? WHY?!)
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
I'm using a singular they pronoun for my gender ambiguous character, who is one of the main characters and the antagonist as well as the protagonist's companion and friend.
Making a character sexually different only adds as many "sexual themes" to a story as making them heterosexual or cis gender. Nobody thinks of the aggressive heterosexual pairings in Disney movies as having a "straight agenda", now do they? ;)
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
i don't quite follow this. I never said i wanted to write about asexual characters in order to avoid sexual themes. Actually i was kind of saying the reverse - that character sexuality/asexuality doesn't come up because my stories are pretty asexual to begin with. Any given character in one of my stories could theoretically - (my characters definitely have specific sexual orientations in my notes, i just never end up mentioning their attractions in the story) - they could theoretically be asexual, heterosexual, homosexual, bisexual, pansexual or any other variation thereof. It's simply never mentioned.
and actually, i do think that the overabundance of sexual relationships is kind of an agenda but that's a whole different issue. :-)
i have seen some of the invented gender-neutral pronouns but i just wish there were such pronouns that everyone would automatically recognize. although, i suppose that's part of the point of writing agendered characters, isn't it? lol.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
Everyone recognizes "they"! :D
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
unfortunately I don't think that *everyone* recognizes they. I mean, a lot of people haven't even heard of the concept of someone being gender neutral, or really anything other than male or female gendered. I feel like for those people, "they" would be very confusing and possibly even need explanation, but I think that for people who haven't heard of the concept anything would need to be "explained" or just accepted.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
Actually, they do. See what I just did there?
"Someone left THEIR books here".
Everyone recognizes they as a singular gender neutral pronoun already, they just don't THINK of it in terms of gender.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
Right...the majority of people recognize "they" as a pronoun that can be used "when a gender is unknown." The majority of people do not recognize it as a pronoun that someone uses for themselves. Therefore, in a book, if you have a character who uses "they," it's still going to confuse a lot of people. It's a big leap for most people to go from "when a gender is unknown," to what someone uses for their pronoun, because that is not how they've come to known "they." The moment you start using it for someone you know or the person you're speaking to knows, a lot of people get really confused, tell you you're using english incorrectly, think you're talking about a group of people, or any other number of things that indicate they really don't recognize it as a person's pronoun.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
Are you not familiar with Spivak? They're a fairly useful set of invented gender-neutral pronouns (not that other neologisms aren't ~invented~) and they're some of the most prolific ones used! There's also sie/hir and variations, but I tend to stick with ey/eir/em as they're the ones I use for myself, and ones that feel the most freeing to use.
My MC is female and uses female pronouns this year, but I'm looking to stick in someone at least gq at some point, and maybe next year I'll be a bit more adventurous.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
Oddly, I had never heard of these before. I currently use "they" and am familiar with the set of Ze (or Zi) pronouns, and the use of name as pronoun, but I really like the spivak pronouns (well, I think I like the ey better than e), and will most definitely be using them in my novel (and using them for myself, as well!)
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
Agender, not so much, but asexual yes. I attempt to put one in every single thing I write, because we need more love (No-one point out the irony in that statement.)
And yeah you;re right, they really are badly represented. Most people (at least other here) don;t even know what 'Asexual is', and thats porbably the same for agender. Hence why I always try to write at least one, and if possible slip the word in, so more people know and are aware of it.
But yeah even without 'sexual themes' you could have an asexual charater, even if you;re the only one who other knows, or the hints are very light, like them merely ignoring things taht would normally 'excite' other mebers of their gnder. Of course that might just lead to people thinking they're gay...again due to not many people being aware asexuality exsists.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
My FMC might be asexual or demisexual, or she might be straight and have a low sex drive (and be religiously Catholic). She does have some kind of romantic feelings for the MMC, but I don't know if there's a sexual component or not...
I'm asexual and pan-romantic, and very happy this is getting more visibility.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
One of the plots I'm considering writing this year includes three main characters, one who is definitely asexual and one who may or may not be asexual. The plot may need to marinate in my brain for another year though before its ready to be written.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
As both agender and asexual, I'm kind of amused to see both of those aspects in a thread of their own, but okay, I guess? I see them all along the continuum of LGBTQQIAPP+ queerness.
One of my characters this year is fairly androgynous, although the concept is kind of hard to translate into a different culture, y'know? I say that if he lived in modern times, he'd probably be cool with "genderqueer". The other is entirely cis and sex-repulsed aromantic asexual. And these are all kind of major plot points.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
sweet!
and good point about making subtle hints that a character is asexual... that could be fun. i might actually do that... yeah, i think that could work. thanks!
agender could definitely fall along the continuum but i feel like asexuality is pretty different since it means (basically) not being sexually attracted to anyone. and then i thought while i was making a new thread, might as well include both topics that particularly interest me. :-)
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
One of my main characters is a bit of a conundrum when it comes to hyr gender (hyr? hys?). It's especially complicated because the character is based on a historical figure widely thought of as transgender, genderfluid, or just a plain old opportunist, but never really agender or asexual. Because I am writing a play, I've specified that the character can be played by a girl or a boy, however for simplicity's sake I'm referring to hyr as 'he' in stage directions, though the characters on-stage call hyr 'he' as well as 'Madame'.
It's a period piece; they simply have no indicator of non-gender at the time, and in French, the masculine pronoun can also be taken as a gender-neutral one.
I too am glad that this is getting visibility.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
I do have agender/asexual characters in my novel this nano, though it's not by choice. (Their souls were forced into a body that is mechanical after they died.) I'm finding it really challenging to write about, but its a lot of fun. It's actually really refreshing to write about how a person can love another person with feeling absolutely 0 physical attraction at all.
Don't know if this counts because it isn't a choice for my characters, but the themes are there.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
I'm writing about this same thing! Their bodies look human, and have gender-specific features. They love each other, but of course they have no desire to do sexual things. It's cool somebody else thought of this. :)
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
I have a genderqueer character. I may add others as time goes on. It is a struggle to write a novel with genderqueer characters, though, for sure, because you have (ok, you don't HAVE to, but it's usually wise, if you're writing for a wide audience, at least) to explain the use of whatever pronoun you choose.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
Oh man, I'm so glad I came here! I was hanging out in Fantasy. Anyway, I have a set of characters who are asexed. However, due to socialization they may not always be agendered. One of them, however, is genderqueer, I suppose, and for em I use Spivak pronouns, obviously. :)
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
Hey, cool topic! Glad I found it.
I'm writing a story about three people who all live in the same body (young woman's body), one of whom is a girl (so technically asexual, but noone knows if that will change if/when she grows up. It's very likely she'll stay a 4-year-old all her life), another one an asexual young woman and the third one a gay boy with major angst about his body disphoria, although I'm probably only gonna hint at it, it's not plot-relevant. I love them :D
In the world of my story (sci-fi), there is far less discrimination against people for any reason except money/ wealth and ability/ willingness to work. So they can live a life that's usually discrimination-free as long as they don't hang out in weird places where the last few bigots gather. So because there's next to no discrimination about people's identity or sexuality (or lack thereof) it's probably not gonna come up. I'm looking forward to including little hints, though, so for example if someone sais "I just fell in love" you wouldn't answer with "What's her/his name?" (using the pronoun that would assume a heterosexual love), instead you would use a gender-neutral phrasing.
Unfortunately I'm writing in german (because that's my first language) and there don't seem to be good gender-neutral pronouns. Using plural pronouns wouldn't work since they're nearly always identical to singular female pronouns. So I use "he" and "she" alternately for my genderqueer sidecharacter. I explained it in a footnote but I'm not sure it will work for readers. I'll have to find out in December...
If you want to read what I've got so far, you can do so here:
http://www.nanowrimo.org/en/participants/meeresbande/novels/revolution-im-weltraum
but like I said, it's in german.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
My MC is androgynous in the way that their gender is not mentioned, at all. It's obviously intentional and any careful reader should be able to pick out where a specific gender only makes sense. Making my MC asexual would help this cause but it leaves out many of the places I would like to take my story, so for now, they do not have a specific age, gender or sexual orientation.
As for pronouns, I am writing a fictionalized memoir so I just use 'I' but I may need Spivak's later on. Wish me luck!
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
I've never tackled agender (though now I will), but I made two of my most important character asexual. It just made more sense given their similar outlooks and appearances, but they still can be romantic in their unique ways.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
My MC is an androgen and I'm just sticking with the biological gender as pronouns referring to "him". Of course this character is pretty free with his orientation. I cannot stand writing "him" constantly. I'm keeping it first person for the most part. though. I'm just having some issues with the whole aesthetics of pronouns. I feel like there needs to be more words describing those who are genderqueer, gender-neutral, androgen or the like.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
when i started this thread i wasn't sure how many people would respond, so seeing your responses is really great!
:-)
my nano is getting ever more surreal so while i'm currently using gendered pronouns for my MC it's entirely possible that that could go out the window at some point. also, it's very visual so in the end i'm seeing it as more of a graphic novel or animated video or something. if that happens, i think the MC is going to be very ambiguously gendered. (yay for visual media!)
i do wonder though, if it would be hard for people that aren't agender to relate to a blatantly agendered character or if people that are sexual would have a hard time relating to a blatantly asexual character?
on the one hand, i would think it wouldn't be an issue since people seem to relate to characters not of their own gender all the time but on the other hand it seems like being agender/asexual is such a foreign concept to most people that i wonder sometimes.
even if the sexual orientation/gender identity is treated as a side note in the novel, is it going to distract some (most?) people from really following the plot/other themes?
and on that note - do any of you know of published books that feature asexual or androgynous/agendered characters?
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
Regarding your question wether or not it's hard for people to relate to agender and/or asexual characters, I think you're right that that isn't per se harder to do than to relate to bipolarly (it's a word now.) gendered and (hetero-)sexual people, but the difference is that we see those kinds of characters all the time and have great practice relating to them. We don't have practice relating to agendered and/or asexual characters -- yet. So I think it may take more explaining, but it should be perfectly possible.
As for identifying with asexual characters, I wonder why that would even be a foreign concept. Isn't everyone asexual as a child? Or is being an asexual child different from being a child who will grow up to be sexual? I ask this because sometimes gay/lesbian people say they have "always known I was different" even as a child. Being asexual myself, I don't really get that (I believe what people say about themselves, I just don't really understand this).
Or maybe being (like) a child (in one respect) is just a foreign concept?
I think if you don't remind your readers that your character is agendered, they might just assign a gender to them in their heads -- just like agendered characters like robots are almost always portrayed as male or female. The same might be true for a character's sexual orientation. I don't know if that would be a problem though -- you can either put in little reminders here and there or let (some) readers assign them false genders if you don't feel like doing that. It's probably like reading a first person short story thinking the character is female and learning he is male somewhere near the end (that happens to me a lot when reading first person stories).
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
i really don't know. it just seems like there's such an expectation of sexuality that people would be confused by a character who was explicitly stated to be asexual. but i guess we'll have to find out when we start publishing these novels. ;-)
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
Robin Hobb has several series that include a gender-fluid/gender ambiguous character.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
My most magnetic main character is asexual, which is pretty much a running gag in my story. I based him a lot off of one my best friends, who is asexual and I'm actually getting a lot of my response ideas from him.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
Not in the book I'm doing at the moment, but in the same series, later, one of the MMCs has a son who is asexual/ aromantic, and there will be a character who is technically neither male or female or anything else because she (who is presenting as female at that stage of the story) is a physical embodiment of an abstract concept. Later 'she' turns up with the same name, but is a 'he', and it's not questioned in-story (it would be kind-of a faux-pas to bring it up - 'excuse me, personification of an abstract idea, but you're doing humanoid presentation wrong - choose a gender/sex and stick to it' isn't really something you want to consider saying around this particular idea)
And there's a lot of ambiguous/ androgynous characters, though my Narrator is a cis male, undisclosed sexuality (well, the nature of his existance sort-of ... makes sexuality irrelevant to him, personally. Probably I'd need a whole lot more than one post to explain it all) and his flatmate, the MMC is a cis male, pansexual, who kind-of missed the whole 'thing' of there being anything to make a fuss about with how anyone identifies (it's his son who is ace and aro, and when he 'comes out', this MMC is pretty much like 'good for you! this is a thing, isn't it? Party time! you get the sweets, someone else bring dvds, I'll find some wine! yaay!')
Yup, so many in this series that aren't the base average, but they're balanced out by some 'normal??' secondary characters. (I really dislike the word 'normal' - what I mean is that they're more towards the middle of the bell curve. damnable imprecise concepts *shakesfist*)
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
The Shapeshifters in my story are all agender. They "start off" as male (in appearance, they are not human but appear to be), and can only reproduce as males, but the issue of pronouns comes in as half of them appear to be female all/most of the time. And when they're female, even thought they cannot reproduce as females, they are "all woman".
A constant silly argument I have with a writer friend is whether my MC and another character are a gay couple ("couple" used as a loose term here), as originally they were both "male". But they're not human, and one of them takes female forms all the time. They could if they wanted to, both act as male or female, or switch genders. We came to the conclusion that they are the ultimate bisexual couple.
With the pronouns, it depends on who's talking about the character with ambiguous gender. One of the characters spends an equal time as a male and female. The narrator refers to them as whichever gender they are "currently". Some of the other characters have an obvious preference to stay as male or female, and the narrator and some others use the appropriate gender pronoun. Some humans refer to the Shifters as "it", others as "ter" (and the rest of Casey Miller and Kate Swifts neutral pronouns). The only reason I'm writing it in the first person, actually, is to remove a tiny bit of pronoun confusion, as my MC and narrator changes occasionally.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
I have three main characters. Of them, Abby is asexual (and pretty uncaring of others most of the time so I'm feeling aromantic as well), Ben is gay although, given his character, I'm pretty sure he's asexual homoromantic and Andru is hetrosexual.
It doesn't really come up a lot in my story (aside from Ben propositioning a rescuer as a joke) although it's been touched on a little during Abby and Andru's heart to heart. It probably doesn't really come up because I don't really write relationships.
Re: androgynous/agender and/or asexual characters? themes?
I haven't got any agender characters, but my MC is asexual.