Which is grammatically correct?

MizzRaynsta
Which is grammatically correct?

8,052 / 50,000
Joined: Oct 12, 2007
Location: The Shadows of a Dream
Posts: 102
Posted on:
Jul 10, 2008 - 21 52

And considering I don't even know if I spelled that right, I'm not even sure I should be writing... Oh well.

A. Her eyes were a pure blue; the color of a cloudless sky in the morning.

or

B. Her eyes were a pure blue, the color of a cloudless sky in the morning.

I get very confused when dealing with commas and semi-colons.
----------

tomdgGlowing Halo
Winner!
63,376 / 50,000
Joined: Nov 17, 2004
Location: Leamington, Warwickshire, UK
Posts: 174
Posted on:
Jul 11, 2008 - 04 06

The comma is correct. Normally you use a semicolon when the bits either side would work as whole sentences in their own right, which isn't true in this case: "The color of a cloudless sky in the morning." Isn't a proper sentence because it lacks a verb. (They're also used in some circumstances to separate things in lists where the things themselves are long, but that's not your situation here).

So also gramatically correct (but not very good) might be:

"Here eyes were a pure blue; they matched the cloudless sky."

----------

Tom

I think therefore I am pretentious.

Kimberly DawnGlowing Halo
Winner!
57,563 / 50,000
Joined: Oct 20, 2004
Location: Nowhere
Posts: 479
Posted on:
Jul 11, 2008 - 07 50

The grammar of a comma is correct, but the writing is meh. Adjective overload. In a story ithe prose would bring toomuch attention to itself.

You can also use a "--" in your story in the place of a comma. For example, "He was wrong--especially about the flowers." It really depends on the effect you're looking for.

----------

Telling someone you're a writer is like telling them you're an obsessive compulsive bipolar schizophrenic that goes to AA meetings once a week.

MizzRaynsta

8,052 / 50,000
Joined: Oct 12, 2007
Location: The Shadows of a Dream
Posts: 102
Posted on:
Jul 11, 2008 - 12 35

Ah, thanks. ^^ Now it won't be in my head the whole time about when I can use a semi colon. ^^

Home :: About :: Authors :: My NaNoWriMo :: FAQs :: Fun Stuff :: Donation/Store :: Forums :: Our Programs
Privacy Policy :: Terms and Conditions :: Returns Policy

Copyright © 2008 The Office of Letters and Light :: All posted novel excerpts remain copyright their authors.
Powered by Drupal