Synopsis: Captain Atom and Doctor Proton go to college (working title)

Daniella 'Danny' Eldridge grew up quietly Protestant in suburban America. But when her grandmother, a Holocaust survivor, dies, leaving behind years of letters and diaries, Danny feels bound to find out more about the faith her grandmother hid for so long. As she gets more and more involved with the Jewish community in her college town, she feels an increasing connection with the religion, but things get complicated when she falls for Shoshanna, a deeply closeted Jewish girl who is rebelling against her Orthodox parents and who has become distant from religion. With the help of Danny's theater friends, Danny and Shoshanna resist matchmaking attempts while hiding Shoshanna's orientation from her parents. Meanwhile, Danny considers conversion, forcing Shoshanna to grapple with her own alienation from Judaism.