[FANTASY] Gods, Devils and Birds

Kimberly DawnGlowing Halo
[FANTASY] Gods, Devils and Birds
Winner!
57,563 / 50,000
Joined: Okt 20, 2004
Location: Nowhere
Posts: 422
Posted on:
Apr 8, 2008 - 09 56

Length, Draft and Language 1557 words, Draft 2.0

Brief Summary (not more than 300 words) A thief steals a phoenix egg to get magical powers.

Sub Genre & Keywords - fantasy, dark fantasy, sword and sorcery.

Known Issues - This is a rewrite of a previous draft that had the following problems: too many unexplained terms, characters that were flat, sensory deprivation, non-use of tags, telling and showing in the wrong places.

Critique Requested - I want to know if the stuff from known issues is still an issue. Are there parts that are confusing? Is there Info dump in the wrong places?

Critique Tolerance - 10--burn me, as long as you're specific.

Experience & Goals - Second draft, trying to get this published. Was on critique circle.

Anything else? Disclaimers (violence, strong language, graphic sex, etc.) If you're offended with the idea of someone eating a god, or you won't read stories where someone eats a raw egg, this isn't for you.
***

Celdron was supposed to steal a green phoenix--feng huang egg as the locals called it--egg from the nest. According to Kendra, his informant, the nest was one-hundred-forty paces straight from the center main chamber from there several tunnels curved out from the center. The path he was supposed to go down was level. He saw the light at one-hundred-twenty-nine paces. He looked around and saw the open sky. Maybe his paces were larger than hers? He looked at the map of the cave and the instructions. He traced his finger along the path. The map was so confusing. How did these people get around?

There were rumors that they believed the birds were psychic, but everyone outside of this city in the North knew that was just crap they made up to boast how great these stupid birds were. How the locals could think they were Gods because they were big was beyond Celdron.

It had to be this exit. Alright, there had to be a ledge. He peered out to the left. He thought about the old convention of not looking down, but found himself looking at how wide the ledge was anyhow. He tried not to get dizzy from the drop down. He calmed his mind. Alright, this was the first time he had to steal something from so high, but the principle should be the same. He breathed. He counted the width of the ledge with his boot. It was exactly five boot widths across. He went to the right. He put his back to the wall and sled a foot along the ledge. It was windy this far up. Even with the coat he wore, it was still chilly. He wished for the warmth of his cloak, but knew it wasn't smart to go out with a cloak in weather like this.
He suddenly was aware of his knapsack. It was hanging from his belt too low. His leg work was getting mashed up. He was stuck half way here and half way back.

Kendra in her most authoritative bird guard tone had said he only had two candles to get the egg and escape. They would be back from patrolling for kleyersha soon. Celdron privately thought that kleyersha was also a hoax. But it took a thief to know a thief.

He carefully reached down for the sack and hitched it up. A strong wind whipped into his face. He tried not to scream and hung on with all his might. This path was longer than he was expecting. After he breathed more deeply, he shifted the sack up and tried to tie the loose straps with one hand into a knot. he shifted the whole thing to his left side.
He moved his feet side to side again along the ledge. The ledge was gently curving up. He finally saw the nest. It seemed further than Kendra had told him it was. It was beyond him why a guard would sell out her own gods.
He finally reached the nest which was huge. He had to climb up the sides to get inside. It smelled vaguely sweet and spicy mixed with the smell that must have been the birds themselves.

Kendra hadn't told him that the eggs were supposed to glow. It was almost beautiful. Such a shame that he was going to eat it for magical powers. He now believed it when he'd heard from that tavern down South a solaros ago that one could get magical powers from eating these eggs. Why else would they make such a complex maze in the rock face?
Maybe the lunaros of planning were worth it. He selected the smallest looking egg, as he'd agreed with Kendra. It was more out of practicality of bringing it back than it was respect.

He cracked the egg not able to resist just a taste of his victory. It tasted gooey and sweet in his mouth. However, this was just the egg white. He really wanted to taste the yolk.

"Those bird worshipers don't know what they're missing!" he said.

He took the cracked egg and replaced the pieces of the egg. He used the sappy material that Kendra had given him to seal the egg. He was surprised it worked so well.

The embryo shouldn't have developed visibly yet. At least that's what Kendra had told him. It would make him feel a little guilty to eat the actual bird.

Despite it being smaller than the others it was still half his height. He untied his knapsack. He took out the fine net. He wrapped it around the egg. Perfect fit. He hitched it up onto his back with the straps he'd made earlier. The egg now glowed weirdly. He ignored it.

The sun had moved a lot. He had maybe one candle left from looking at his shadow. The birds would be back soon. He couldn't stall.

The straps cut into his shoulders. He tried to find his balance and stepped out onto the ledge. He had to go face first this time. The torque of the egg made him bend backwards. He struggled to hold onto the cliff. It made him wonder how the riders of these birds could do this every day.

He finally made it back to the tunnel entrance. A strong gust of wind knocked him forward. He struggled to regain his balance so the egg would not crack. He couldn't see well in the darkness. He'd gotten here by following the tunnel wall and counting steps. He also could see better in the dark at that time since his eyes didn't have to adjust so much, but now coming from the bright light he couldn't see anything. The egg faintly glowed in the dark. He placed his hands along the wall and counted his steps down the corridor. He almost panicked when he counted to one hundred thirty three and didn't see the light of the main chamber. He slowed his breathing and reminded himself that the egg would make him step smaller steps. He continued until he saw the soft glow of the main chamber.

He cheered under his breath. He'd finally made it! He turned around once to celebrate, but then found himself staring in Kendra's eyes. A sword was firmly lodged at his throat.

"It's the wrong egg. It's not a green's egg, idiot! It's a red one. Return it."

Celdroin couldn't understand how she would know that. But maybe the woman was lying.
"You want part of the cut, don't you?" Celdron asked.

Celdron hitched the egg up on his back. The straps only cut into his shoulders more.

More footsteps resonated in the main chamber, however he couldn't figure out which hallways it was. Celdron cursed.
He hadn't even gotten a chance to drink the yolk yet.

"Return the egg or I'm in deep trouble."

"What? Why?" Celdron said. He tried not to say too much.

A bird screech from outside echoed down the halls. Kendra pulled him into one of the hallways.

"Xiao Si's nest was raided!"

He peered around the corner of the tunnel. It was the bird worshipers. They were in their riding gear--low boots, tight pants and a loose fitted shirt and jacket. Even though their eyes were all distant, they scattered quickly. They commanded several guards who spread out.

"The sacred egg is gone?" A priest inquired.

"No, it's still here, but the thief stole a red egg."

The voice was still a little distant. It was only a matter of time before they discovered him. Celdron scrunched his shoulder against the wall trying to hide the egg.

"The thief is still here. Xiao Si can still hear her egg."

Celdron cursed. They were psychic afterall.

Celdron looked around the corner again. If he was going to be caught he may as well benefit from the magical power of the egg. He set it down on the ground. He ignored Kendra's comments about how he was breaking the deal. He rubbed his shoulders. He turned the egg on it's point. The air sack would be at the bottom of the egg. The yolk would be there.

He cracked it, reached past the soft film and then drank what yolk he had left in his hand. Torches lit up around him. At least five swords were aimed at his throat. There were twenty more soldiers in the main chamber.

Celdron cursed. The stories weren't true. Where was the magical power? He didn't feel any different.

"We save you and yours from kleyersha and this is how you repay us?"

The same thing about kleyersha. He couldn't believe that these bird worshippers actually believed a children's tale used to make them behave. Who would believe such a tale about a beast made up of two people.

The hairs of his arm, sticky with the broken egg, clung. The egg dripped.

He ignored the scream of the bird down the cave and a woman holding her head.

He spotted Kendra, also in their custody. Figured. She wasn't bright enough to keep her mouth shut in her panic.
He regretted going to all this trouble if this was the result. No magical powers afterall. This was the last urban legend he was going to follow.
----------
Telling someone you're a writer is like telling them you're an obsessive compulsive bipolar schizophrenic that goes to AA meetings once a week.

fruit_cocktail_man
Winner!
51,243 / 50,000
Joined: Nov 1, 2007
Location: Texas
Posts: 817
Posted on:
Apr 27, 2008 - 19 47

Quote:
Celdron was supposed to steal a green phoenix--feng huang egg as the locals called it--egg from the nest.

This should be written as:
Celdron was supposed to steal a green pheonix EGG—feng huang egg, as the locals called it—from the nest.
Egg should be included in the first part, not broken and placed in the second part. Also, I think there should be a comma before “as the locals called it,etc.”
Quote:
According to Kendra, his informant, the nest was one-hundred-forty paces straight from the center main chamber from there several tunnels curved out from the center.

Wait, what? Do you mean, “One hundred and forty paces from the main chamber. From there, several tunnels curved out from the center?”
Quote:
The map was so confusing. How did these people get around?

I don’t know how much detail you want to get into, but maybe you could explain why the map is confusing? Is the maps “compass” confusing? Is the path winding with many criss-crosses and obstacles to navigate around? It seems like you could show instead of tell.
Quote:
There were rumors that they believed the birds were psychic, but everyone outside of this city in the North knew that was just crap they made up to boast how great these stupid birds were. How the locals could think they were Gods because they were big was beyond Celdron.

I’m not sure, but if this is a pagan religion you’re talking about, I believe the word “Gods” shouldn’t be capitalized. Also, it’s very difficult to tell if this is the character thinking or narrating. Is it a diary?
Quote:
It had to be this exit.

“This had to be the exit,” maybe? 0.o
Quote:
Alright, there had to be a ledge. He peered out to the left. He thought about the old convention of not looking down, but found himself looking at how wide the ledge was anyhow. He tried not to get dizzy from the drop down. He calmed his mind. Alright, this was the first time he had to steal something from so high, but the principle should be the same. He breathed. He counted the width of the ledge with his boot. It was exactly five boot widths across. He went to the right. He put his back to the wall and sled a foot along the ledge. It was windy this far up. Even with the coat he wore, it was still chilly. He wished for the warmth of his cloak, but knew it wasn't smart to go out with a cloak in weather like this.

Throughout this passage, you make it sound like a narrator instead of thought. The “he’s” are confusing. But, in the beginning, it sounds like thought! It seems there are a few point of view issues.

Quote:
It was hanging from his belt too low. His leg work was getting mashed up. He was stuck half way here and half way back.

These sentences are clumsily worded. I don’t think they articulate the actions you’re describing very well. “Too low” doesn’t tell me very much about where the knapsack is hanging. If it’s on his belt loop, how could it be hanging “too low?” Are his pants falling down? “Mashed up” doesn’t describe leg work well either. Is he contorting into uncomfortable positions or something? In the third, I’d explain more what he’s stuck between.
Quote:
Kendra in her most authoritative bird guard tone had said he only had two candles to get the egg and escape. They would be back from patrolling for kleyersha soon. Celdron privately thought that kleyersha was also a hoax. But it took a thief to know a thief.

In the first sentence, “in her most authoritative bird guard tone,” should be separated by commas. Also it should be, “authoritative(comma) bird guard tone,” I believe.
Quote:
This path was longer than he was expecting.

He’s hanging on for his life and he’s thinking about this? Weird.
Quote:
he shifted the whole thing to his left side.

You didn’t capitalize at the beginning of the sentence.
Quote:
It was beyond him why a guard would sell out her own gods.

Aha! You don’t capitalize gods in this instance. Just a little inconsistency.
Quote:
He finally reached the nest which was huge.

A bland, curt sentence.
Quote:
It was almost beautiful.

It sounds odd to say something is “almost beautiful.” To me, it’s not a fine line. 0.o
Quote:
Why else would they make such a complex maze in the rock face?

Why does the narrator ask so many questions? The narrator is supposed to be the grounding force in a story, that has authority and grip on what’s happening. If the narrator is confused, the reader will be too.
Quote:
not able

The word I believe is “unable.” :)
Quote:
It tasted gooey and sweet in his mouth.

Could it taste gooey and sweet on his foot? In his armpit? “In his mouth” is unnecessary. :) Plus, I don’t think “gooey” is a taste!
Quote:
He took the cracked egg and replaced the pieces of the egg. He used the sappy material that Kendra had given him to seal the egg. He was surprised it worked so well.

You start a LOT of your sentences in this excerpt that begin with “he.”
Quote:
Despite it being smaller than the others it was still half his height.

I thought he had intentions of carrying it down. Half his height could be really bulky. 0.o
Quote:
He untied his knapsack. He took out the fine net. He wrapped it around the egg. Perfect fit. He hitched it up onto his back with the straps he'd made earlier. The egg now glowed weirdly. He ignored it.

A lot of “he’s.”
Quote:
He had maybe one candle left from looking at his shadow.

Again, the narrator seems REALLY confused. “Maybe” can be removed.
Quote:
He finally made it back to the tunnel entrance. A strong gust of wind knocked him forward. He struggled to regain his balance so the egg would not crack. He couldn't see well in the darkness. He'd gotten here by following the tunnel wall and counting steps. He also could see better in the dark at that time since his eyes didn't have to adjust so much, but now coming from the bright light he couldn't see anything. The egg faintly glowed in the dark. He placed his hands along the wall and counted his steps down the corridor. He almost panicked when he counted to one hundred thirty three and didn't see the light of the main chamber. He slowed his breathing and reminded himself that the egg would make him step smaller steps. He continued until he saw the soft glow of the main chamber.

Eleven sentence passage. Nine begin with “he.” :(
Quote:
Celdron cursed.

It sounds weird to say this. Maybe find a substitute curse word or something.
Quote:
The voice was still a little distant. It was only a matter of time before they discovered him.

Okay, my first thought when I read this was, “Duh!” :) If they were truly searching for him, of course they would find him!
Quote:
Celdron cursed.

Maybe, “Whispered an inaudible curse” even. That way it gives a reason for the narrator’s obliviousness.
Quote:
At least five swords were aimed at his throat. There were twenty soldiers in the main chamber.

Okay, this is an example of an inconsistent narrator. He doesn’t know how many swords are pointed at Celdron’s neck, but he knows how many soldiers are in the room? It doesn’t make much sense at all!
Quote:
Celdron cursed.

You use this too much! XD
Quote:
Who would believe such a tale about a beast made up of two people.

You missed the question mark at the end of the sentence. :)
Quote:
The hairs of his arm, sticky with the broken egg, clung. The egg dripped.

What? The first sentence doesn’t make sense. :(
Overall, I must say that I liked your other work with the Akademos much better. This one had a lot of repeated errors throughout, which made for a distracting read. I like the concept of your story. It seems adventurous, almost Indiana-Jones like in a way. Don’t give up on it! It has some potential! :) I hope this helped!

Kimberly DawnGlowing Halo
Winner!
57,563 / 50,000
Joined: Okt 20, 2004
Location: Nowhere
Posts: 422
Posted on:
Apr 28, 2008 - 06 48

Thank you for the critique.

^^;; I posted it with the hope of looking for if the previous issues that were brought up before still existed... like can you get a feel for the character better, the setting better, etc.

This is later in the timeline of the world at large. In Sufushia's timeline this is like about a thousand years later? Something like that.

^^;; I didn't check it for stylistic elements and grammar yet, ^^;; I just want to know if I'm wasting my time in rewriting the beginning...

fruit_cocktail_man
Winner!
51,243 / 50,000
Joined: Nov 1, 2007
Location: Texas
Posts: 817
Posted on:
Apr 28, 2008 - 06 57

Oops! Sorry if I went overboard!0.o I read what you were looking for, but I also saw that your critique tolerance was 10, so I immediately assumed you wanted a full fledged review as well.^^;; I definitely think you should go for this one, because I found a lot fun aspects in the relationship between Kendra and Celdron. They had an interesting friendship, it seemed. And the adventure sounds exciting too! Keep writing! I apologize this sat so long on the critique forum, without a reader! The shame! ^.^ Again, sorry if I went overboard...

Start :: Info :: Auteurs :: Mijn NaNoWriMo :: FAQs :: Fun Stuff :: Schenkingen/Winkel :: Forums :: Onze Activiteiten
Privacy Beleid :: Voorwaarden :: Retourzendingen

Copyright © 2008 The Office of Letters and Light :: All posted novel excerpts remain copyright their authors.
Powered by Drupal